In the United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHL '>L53J46:6L
 L

 ?L$+'L#&'/&L+L
 L

 ?L  
 ?L L  L
L
 ?L>
>?L  
>L HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHL
(( $L *'%L, L&!, L,, +L!+,*!,L'-*,L '*L, L '*, *&L!+,*!,L' L $$!&'!+?L+, *&L!.!+!'&>L '>L4<LL9846LKL  
?  >L HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHL  L
L5:?L5353LKL L L;?L5353L HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHL  '* L
 ?L ?L& L>L?    >L 
 ?    >L
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
$$LI4<63B CL +L,'L+1L'-,L (( $$, L !$!& L +L !&L  (, *L 46L !+K&', !& >L  ,L $ . +L I4<48L!&L($ >L ,!$$?L +,&!L +L L (*'$ %>L  (, *L 46L !+L +! & L '*L ( '($ L/ 'L&L(1L%'+,L! L&',L$$L' L, !*L ,+>L L'- J $+L>L!* ?L    L (, *L5LB9, L >L5347C>L
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