In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

";G21E1372G < ;;<G!G  < ;;<G   #
 <G

!G


 ;<%'%,G"G"(& !G!G%!G) "#E !'<G  #
;G CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

 ! ! ! !  ! !! ! !  ! ! ! !  ! !  ! !! ! !   
  
 ! CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

  14<2021
F 20<2021G CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

"%G <G$ <G!G
 G!G
<$   $  ;G 
 <$  $ ;G
'%G'G ',G"G " '<G !" &<G "! !GG"(& !G) "# !'G !G,G *G&'G !G *G (.G@" ' ) ,G *G&'A<G!G# G:15G "!G "%G'G#%"#%' &<G'G#%' &G &%G"('G'G##%"#% 'G G * The court granted the parties’ joint motion to waive oral argument. 2G ";G21E1372G

 &#"& ' "!G"GG(!G*"%'G%"( ,G:2;7G "!;G &G(!<G &' &G(!%G"!'%'&G'*!G *G&'G!G'GE #%' !'G"G"(& !G!G%!G) "# !'F*"&G%!'G &(&  &G"%G "*E !" G'!!'&G#%") G "&'G G"G'G "!,G"%G"#%' !G'G"(& !G) "# !'FGG&''G " G"G!&(% !G''G "!,G*"( GG)  G"%G  !'E !!G!G%# %G"G'G#%"#%' &G G *G&'G( 'G"!G '&G" ' "!&G'"G'!!'&G"%G'G#%' !';G *G&'G  !E ' !&G''<G(&G 'G &G!"G "!%G%&#"!&  G"%G  !'!!G "%G%# %<G 'G&"( G% )G'G "!,;G('G'G#%' !'G&G %(&G *G&'B&G !&G"%G#, !'G!G &G"  !G'G "!,G"%G'G!-'G"G " '<G* G&(G *G&'G&G 'G(  !&BG#%"#% '"%;G
G &#('G"('G'G &#"& ' "!G"G'G%&%)G(!G%"&G (% !G'G"! !' "!G#%" !<G('G*G G !G $ !$  $  "$ ! !<G921G;3G693G@7'G %;G2019AG@  $  $ A<G''G 'G &&(G &G"%GG&#%'G&( 'G* 'G'G#%' !'G&GE !!';G &G&( 'G &G'G%&( ';GG &'% 'G (G%!'G'G #%' !'B&G "' "!G"%G&( %,G ( !';G2021G;;G &';G G21393G@ ;;G ;G;G4<G2021A;G

 $  $ G%&G'*"G"! (& "!&G#%' !!'G'"G'G(%E %!'G&( '=G-%&'<G''G12G;;;GD1702G* )&G'G#%' !'B&G &")% !G (! ',G '"G G   G &G "!G G "!'%'>G &"!<G ''G"! ,GG"!'%'<G%'%G'!GG&''('G"%G%( ' "!<G".%&G *G&'G!,G#%"&#'G"G&(&&;GG#%' &G' G'&G"!E  (& "!&G&G )!<G&"G*G!G'"G%&" )GG &#('G"('G'G ! !G"G'G"!'%'&G'*!G *G&'G!G'G#%'E !';G ('G *G &'G "&G !"'G % ,G "!G "!'%'( G  ;G !E &'G 'G&,&G''G'G#%' &BGG"G#%")  !G&(% ',G"%G%E # %&G!G  !'!!G # &G''G'G "!,G (&'G "!G'"G ";G21E1372G 3G

'G"!G'G#%" 'B&G"*!%& #G#&&&G'"G&" "!G &;G &G * G!"'G";G%#&<G(&G'G "!,G G%" G'GE % G%&(%,G'%"(G'G#, !'G"G")E % 'G%!'&<G'G "!,G&"( G%)%'G'"G'G%&(%,;G%G#%#&<G(&G'G "!,G &G& !G'"G#%") G&(% ',G G'G#%" 'B&G"*!%G  &G'"G 'G '&G%&#"!&  ' &<G'G(!G&"( G#&&<G* 'G'G (  !&<G'"G'G#%" 'B&G!*G"*!%;G%G#%#&<G(&GG " G "G 'G (!G &G '"G #%"''G '!!'&BG !'%&'&<G 'G "!,G &"( G G  &'% ('G '"G 'G '!!'&G "%G (&G '"G %(G ' %G %!'&;G
G!% G" ' )G"&G!"'G%&" )G* G"G'&G#"&E &  ' &G'G"!'%' !G#%' &G ';G'G%$( %&GG E & "!G!"G !G%G !(<G* G'&G"!'%'&G  ;G *G&'G &G'G#  !' .G!G%&G'G% & G"G!"!E#%&(& "!;G "E*'B&E&'E E' !&E"!& %G &GG#""%G&(&' '('G"%G "!%'G !(G !GG"!'%'G&;G "*G 'G &!B'G$( 'G% 'G'"G&,G''G *G&'G,#&&&$G "!'%'( G !(;G (% ',G % !'&G )G 'G #%'E !'GG !G"!G'G(!B&G"!'!'&<G!G'&G%G'G"! ,G"!E '%'&G"!G* G *G&'G% &;G!G'G"! !' "!G*&G " # '<G!G *G&'G!"G "!%G"*!G'G#%" '<G'GE #%' !'G % &G '&G !G ,G #%"#%G "( !'&G (!%G 'G ! "% G" %  G";G
"% !G'"G *G&'<G' &G!E &&% ,G&"*&G''G 'G!"*G"*!&G'G(!G"('% ';G('G''B&G !"'G &";G G !G "G 'G !G !&G ''G 'G #%' !'G !"G "!%G&GG&(% ',G !'%&';G('G*"$  G'G(!?GGE &!G "G G &(% ',G !'%&'G "&G !"'G !&*%G 'G $(&' "!F !<G &G *G +#  !G ")<G 'G #"&&  ' &G ! (G *G &'<G 'G  ',G "G " '<G 'G %&(%,<G !G 'G '!!'&;G  &G &!&G(&G G'"G'G"!'%'&<G* G"G!"'G%&&G'G&(E ';G *G &'G )G 'G #%' !'G &(% ',G !G *')%G #%"#%',G !'%&'G *G&'G#"&&&&G !G'G(!<G('G'G'G "G" !G&"G"&G!"'G&' &G*'G *G&'B&G !'%&'G*&;G 4G ";G21E1372G

*G&'G' &G(&G''G 'G'%'G ' "!&G'"G'G%&%)G (!G&G'+ G !" <G%" G* G 'G"! (&G''G 'G (&'G "*!G'G "!,;G 'G"&G!"'G&,<G"*)%<G''G!,' !G !G '&G "!'%'&G * 'G 'G #%' !'G %$( %G 'G '"G '%'G 'G (!G ''G*,;G 'G*"( GG %( %G'"G#% 'G *G&'B&G'+G%E #"%' !G '"G &' &G '&G "*!%& #;G %#&G  G ' &G &"*&G &G ''G *G&'G&G%#"%'G'""G (G !" G!G!&G'"G - G !G'+G%'(%!&;G G#%' &BG% &G &(&&G  ("(&G !(G !GG  G "# ! "!G &&(G !G 2001G ,G 'G !,B&G
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
&G'G &'% 'G"(%'G"&%)<GG&( 'G& !G E &G "%G "!)%& "!G %$( %&G !G  ! &'%' )G   G (!%G 'G% G"%'G  &G
'<G&G28G;;;GD2675@A<G!G *G &'G"!&G''G 'G G!"'G#%&!'G&(GG  G'"G'GE #%' !';G
G % ,G (!%G 'G 
G &G + (& )G *!G 'G &''('G ## &<G &G 28G ;;;G D2679@A<G &"G *G &'G !!"'G ";G21E1372G 5G

(&G12G;;;GD1702G&GG* )%G"G&")% !G (! ',G'"G#(%E &(GG'"%'G  ;G "'G''G' &G /%&;G"G)GG  G"%G'"%' "(&G"!)%E & "!G "G #%"#%',<G *G &'G (&'G -%&'G &' &G ''G 'G "!,G !G'G%&%)G(!G &G '&G#%"#%',;G !G"'%G*"%&<G'"G * !GG'"%'G  G *G&'G (&'G-%&'G* !G '&G"!'%'G  F !G G 'GG!G G'"G#%) G"!G'G"!'%'G  G@* G 'G  !B'A<G *G &'G *"( G !"'G )G !G G "!)%& "!G   G&GG  ;G AFFIRMED