U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, 2023

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Decided September 28, 2023
Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com

Opinion

In the United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit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

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.