Taewoo Kim v. Jump Trading, LLC

In the United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR $@R69O5=:8R 
 A7 *7"@AR " $* )6
&& "" )AR ,2R  
 A AR#R    AR  $$*)6
&& ""$*)@R MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR
 33 3  3 3  3  33 3  3  33(3  3 '3 '3$%3 3$&$#323 
  (
'3 MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR

54A646:Q 
57A646:R MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR $'R
 ARAR#R A7 (+ *7 + )@R 
 A7 (+ *7 + @R''RE''FR#R 
R ,'R '.%)$*''# (R $#R ) R ''R !$   #AR ,  R ,(R "# R.R''$'"R (ARR # %$'#R$"%#.@R#! R R # AR ,  R " #) #(R #)'! /R '$'(R $R %$( )$'(JR !#(AR R !$   #R "%!$.(R R #)'! /R #),$' R $R *('(R)$R+' .R R)'#() $#@R 
R,(RR)' ) $#!R'.%O )$*''#.AR"* R! R )$ #AR, $(R+!*R1*)*)R(R $#R(*%%!.R#R"#@R''AR.R$#)'()AR,(R(*%%$(R)$R RR()!$ #AR, $(R+!*R,(R! # R)$R($"R$) 'R(()Q 6R $@R69O5=:8R $'R''AR) R@@R$!!'@R R''R$ #R,(R(*%%$(R)$RR ,$') R>5@
$()R()!$ #(R'!.R$#RR'('+R$R#$) 'R(()R)$R" #O ) #R)  'R+!*@R R$ #R (RR! "R)$R>5R #R) R'('+(AR($R ) R ()!$ #R ( $*!R R ,$') R >5@R E )R (AR )R ( $*!R R 'O "!R$'R>5R #R(()(AR(* R(R%$( )(R)RR# @FR''AR $,+'AR*(R#R' )' R" # ("R)$R" #) #R )(R+!*@R
#R! $' ) "R!!$,R $!'(R)$R$#+')R R''R$ #R #)$R R$!!'J(R,$') R$R 
R#R+ R+'(@RE) 'R) #R ! O ))R) R- # R$R''R$'R 
AR) R! $' ) "R,$' R .R()'$. # RR''R$ #R#R" #) # R 
R)$R'%!R )R$'R .R()'$. # R 
R#R" #) # RR''@FR #AR R) R"'O )R%' R$R''R! #R!$,R>5AR' )' *'(R$*!R*.R )AR$#+')R) R''R #)$RR$!!'R$R 
AR#R(!!R) R 
AR %'$0) # R'$"R) R(%'@R$R!$# R(R) (R(%'R,(R ')'R ) #R) R$()R$R)' # AR #+()$'(R,$*!R*.R''R#R$#O +')R )R)$R 
R$'R$#+')R''R) .R!'.R$,#@R#R%' #O  %!AR) (R,$*!R'()$'R''J(R%' R)$R>5@
''$'"J(R' )' R" # ("R), R !R)$R %R )(R +!*R)R>5@R$) R) "(AR''J(R%' R! #AR#R, !R #O +()$'(R $! # R''R$*!R$#+')R )R)$R 
AR$'R+' $*(R '($#(R) (R"R*#( '!@R''$'"R,(R!R)$R($!+R ) R0'()R! #AR #R6465AR.R%'(* # R *"%R' # R)$R*.R " !! $#(R$R''R$ #(R #R- # R$'R$%) $#(R)$R*.R 
R  %!.@R *"%J(R%*' (R'()$'R) R%' R$R''R)$R>5@R*)R #()R$R%'$! " # R *"%J(R'$!AR''$'"R%')#R) )R ) R' )' R" # ("R R'()$'R''J(R%' @R
$'O # R)$R) R$"%! #)AR )R,(R) #R) )R #+()$'(Q*#,'R$R *"%J(R'$!R*' # R) R0'()R' ( (Q$* )R''AR)'*() # R) R ' )' R " # ("@R  #R )R  !R   #AR #R 6466AR ''J(R %' R $!!%(@R  (R ) "R *"%R  #J)R #)'+#@R ''$'"R !)R!!R)' # R#R0!R$'R# '*%).@R
$*)R>84R !! $#R #R#$" #!R+!*R+# ( @
$@R69O5=:8R 7R ,$$R "R $,#R ''R $ #(R , #R )  'R +!*R %!*"O ")R #R6466@R "R#RR%'$%$(R!((R$R #+()$'(R #R''R (*R *"%R*#'R) R$""$ ) (R- # R
)R#R )(R(O ($ )R' *!) $#(AR(R,!!R(R*#'R) R$""$#R!,R$R*#O *()R #'  "#)@R "R !! (R ) )R *"%R $#(% 'R , ) R 'O '$'"R )$R "# %*!)R ) R %' R $R ''AR #AR #R ($R $ # AR $$!R "R #)$R ) # # R ) )R ''$'"J(R ' )' R " O # ("R!$#R$*!R" #) #R )(R&* +!#R, ) R) R@@R$!O !'@
"R$*!#J)R +R(*R''$'"R*(R )R# $.(R' )(R *#'R #R ' )') $#R  '"#)R ) )R "R ( #R , #R R $ #R) RK
# $'R'$)$$!LQR%'$ '"R) )R!!$,R $!O '(R$R''R)$R)'R)  'R$ #(R#R!#R) "R)$R$) 'R*('(@R  R '"#)R%'$+ (R) )R + ,!3  33   !3 3 333 3 3 3 1  (3 3
 (3   3 !3   3  3 3
 .3   (3  !33  (33 !3 3 3 3 3 3  3 ! 3  !3  3  3 3 3  (3 1  3) 3 3 3 *3 !3  33   !3 3 3    1  !3)/ 0*(3 3 33 3 3" !3 3 !3 1   33 33   3  3 3
   3 33 3 3   3
   3 3)/
3 0*' *"%R' *(R) )R "R#J)R(*R )R ) 'R*(R )AR)$$AR#O 0)(R'$"R) R '"#)@R)R"$+R #R) R ()' )R$*')R)$R$"O %!R' )') $#@R ) 'R )R R($R*#'R=R@@@RN8R$'RN64:R (R *#!'CR) R"$) $#R"#) $#(R# ) '@R *"%R(.(R) )R=
@@@R N646R $+'#(R) R' )') $#R '"#)R),#R "R#R'O '$'"AR($R,R, !!R((*"R) )RN64:R%%! (@R #R) R ()' )R $*')R# R *"%J(R'&*()AR(R6469R@@R ()@R  R<<<=<R E @@R!!@R .R=AR6469FAR )R%%!R*#'R=R@@@RN5:EF@R *"%R #$,! (R) )R )R (R#$)RR%').R)$R) R '"#)R ),#R "R#R''$'"@R#()AR )R(.(R) )R) R$)' #R $R&* )!R()$%%!R'&* '(R "R)$R' )')AR( #R "R (R (* # R *"%R $'R $#*)R #R ,  R ''$'"R ,(R R $O$#O (% ')$'@R #R *"%J(R + ,AR R !,(* )R   #()R )R ,$*!R #.R 8R $@R69O5=:8R ''$'"R ) R #0)R $R ) R ' )') $#R  '"#)R *(R *"%R ".R (*R ''$'"R $'R $#)' *) $#@R
#R ) )R ,$*!R $'R ''$'"R )$R ! ) )AR ') 'R ) #R ' )')AR &*() $#(R $*)R )(R" ($#*)@R)R''$'"R#R )(R(*(($'R #R# O '*%).R +R # ) 'R #)'+#R #$'R 0!R #R " *(R ' R )$R (*%%$')R *"%Q*#'()#!.R($@R R'R)R$'R! "(R #R ) R# '*%).R (R%((AR#R''$'"J(R'" # # R(()(R 'R !R #RR! &* ) # R)'*()R'$"R,  R *"%R##$)R#O 0)@R )R" (RR(* )R.R *"%R  #()R''$'"R*#! !.@7 *"%R#$#) !((R$#)#(R) )R#R' )')$'AR') 'R) #R R$*')AR( $*!R R) R ((*R$R&* )!R()$%%!@R)R'(R ) R %$') $#R $R ) R  '"#)R '&* ' # R ' )') $#R $R K#.R ! "R$'R$#)'$+'(.R(R)$R' )' ! ).LR)$R"#R) )R, #O +'R) 'R (RR (%*)R, ) 'RR) 'R%').R#R#$'R) R  '"#)AR) )R (%*)R"*()RR' )')@R
#R )R%$ #)(R)$R !# * R '$"R ) R *%'"R $*')J(R  ( $#R #R %-)#7 ,27  $7 0 (7 .$%")37 $2AR97;R@@R;=RE6446FAR#R$*'R$,#R #R $ R,27+ )*(7& *"7%(&2AR:59R@7R;79RE;) R '@R6454FAR) )R )R) # (R$"%!(R) (R$#!*( $#@R$ ) 'AR) (R' *"#)(R %'(#)R),$R&*() $#(BR0'()AR, $R (Q) R$*')R$'R#R'O  )')$'Q) R"' )(R$R *"%J(R&* )!R()$%%!R' *"#)DR
#R ($#AR R R $*')R  (AR (R *"%R #) )!R )$R ' )')R   #()R "D7
' )') $#R (R$#)')*!CRR$*')R#R$"%!R )R$#!.R R) R %') (R +R  'R )$R ' )')@R
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
(R) R*%'"R$*')R-%! #R #R  $*6
6 $* (37  )*37 $2R ,27 !)%$AR 9:5R @@R :7AR ;5R E6454FAR $*')(R R#$)R$#!.R, ) 'R%') (R +R 'R)$R!O )R &*() $#(R $R ' )' ! ).R )$R #R ' )')$'AR *)R !($R , ) 'R#R.R, $"R#R '"#)R! ) # R) (R&*(O ) $#(R#RR#$'@R#R $*6
6 $* (R$#R$R) R%') (R'O *R) )R#R '"#)R)$R' )')R(*()#) +R (%*)(R,(R +$ @R R *() (R !R) )R#R' )')$'R,$*!R#R)$R R , ) 'R ) )R ,(R )'*AR ( #R ) R %') (R R  'R )$R ' O )')R&*() $#(R$R' )' ! ).@R*)R )R,$*!R +R!!#R)$RR $*')AR#$)R#R' )')$'AR)$R R, ) 'R) R '"#)R)$R :R $@R69O5=:8R ' )')R&*() $#(R$R' )' ! ).R,(R#$'!R R) R%'O ) (R R !!# R )RE') 'R) #R) R '"#)R)$R' )')R (*()#) +R (%*)(F@R *()R($R '@R "R".R +R 'R)$R' )')R) R&*(O ) $#R, ) 'R) 'R%') (R#R#$'R (R(*()#) +R' )'O ) $#R  '"#)R , ) R ''$'"@R *)R R $*')R "*()R  R ,  R ) 'R %') (R #R #$'R ) R  '"#)R )$R ' )')R K! "G(HR$'R$#)'$+'(G (HR(R)$R' )' ! ).L@R) ', (AR#O .$#R $*!R #0)R '$"R R ()'# 'J(R  '"#)R )$R ' )')R ) (R&*() $#(R, ) $*)R+'R # RR%').R)$R )QR'(*!)R) )R ) R$' #'.R!,R$R$#)')(R$(R#$)R!!$,@R
#R) R'!R
' )') $#R
)R $(R #$)R K!+)R G '"#)(R )$R ' )')R &*() $#(R$R' )' ! ).HR$+'R$) 'R$'"(R$R$#)')@LR $*6
6 $* (AR9:5R@@R)R;5@R  (R "#(R ) )R * (AR #$)R #R ' )')$'AR "*()R  R , ) 'R) R '"#)R),#R "R#R''$'"R)$R' O )')R ' )' ! ).R +(R ' )(R )$R *"%@R *"%R (.(R ) )R !#O * R'&* ' # R "R)$R' )')R! "(R(R$#R''$'"J(R " ($#*)Q$'R (R $#R K)(R $'R $" (( $#(R $'R ,  R .$*R G "HR ".R $#)#R ) )R ,R G''$'"HR 'R ! !LQ +(R ' )(R)$R$O$#(% ')$'(R #R) )R" ($#*)AR*)R) R)-)R$"O %!(R ) R $%%$( )R $#!*( $#BR ) )R "R  'R )$R ' )')R , ) R''$'"R$#!.@RR $7( 7
+*%#%* , 7(*)7
$* *(+)*7 * 6 * %$AR=95R@7R7;;AR7<9RE:) R '@R6464FRE'$R($%R$R (O %*)(R$+'R.R !)'!R' )') $#R '"#)R R#$)R *(O ) .R%%!. # R '"#)R)$R' )')R' )' ! ).R)$R) 'R%'O ) (FCR (# (7,27%.%*7 %*%(7%(&2AR;49R@7R5566AR556;P6<RE=) R  '@R6457F@RR$#( 'R!($R) R*!)R'*!R #R())R!,R) )RKR #G#$)HR! "R' )(R*#'RR$#)')R) )R (R$#!.R
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
%%@R 7R94<AR958P5:RE6448FCR(R!($R+$%7 $* ($* %$"7 $27,27 $ )+7 +$%7% " (7%237 *2AR $@R69O6695RE;) R '@FRE ((*R$#)"%$O '#$*(!.F@R $R$#R(* ()(R) )R %%#R '@R *)R ,(R ) R  ()' )R * R $'')R )$R %%!.R !! #$ (R !,DR *"%R' *(R) )R %)'R6R$R) R'!R
' )') $#R
)AR=R @@@RNNR645P4<Q,  R "%!"#)(R) R$#+#) $#R$#R) R $ # ) $#R#R#$'"#)R$R$' #R
' )'!R
,'(RE) R ,R$' R$#+#) $#FQ%'$+ (R) R%%! !R!,R$R&* O )!R()$%%!@R %)'R6R (R( !#)R$*)R, ) 'R) 'R%') (R #R #$'R ' )') $#R  '"#)(@R ) !!AR *"%R ' *(R ) )R  %)'R6R*) $' /(R'!R$*')(R)$R+!$%R)  'R$,#R!,R $R &* )!R ()$%%!@R  (R ()#(R #R $#)'()R )$R  %)'R 5AR ,  R*((R) R'*!(R$R&* )!R()$%%!R'$"R())R!,@R
(6 * +(7
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
37 %(&27 ,27 +*%!+#&+7 * $" ))7
37 AR9=4R@@R876RE6464FAR%'" )(R'!R$*')(R )$R+!$%RR$""$#R!,R$R&* )!R()$%%!R, ) R'(%)R )$R $#)')(R $+'#R .R  %)'R 6@R  'R ) R *() (R !R ) )R#$) # R #R) R())*)R%'+#)(R'!R$*')(R'$"R%%!.O # R K$"() LR $)' #(R $R &* )!R ()$%%!R )$R ((R #O +$!+ # R ) (R $#)')(@R #R ) R # )R ))(AR ) R %'+ ! # R K$"() LR$)' #(R$R&* )!R()$%%!R'R$*#R #R())R !,@R
(* +(7
$ () $7)!!(R*(R) )R %)'R5R$R) R'!R
'O  )') $#R
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
)RE
FR'&* '(R%!#(JR(%$#($'(R)$R %R ) R%'$" ((R) .R" R)$R,$' '(R #R,!'O#0)R%!#(@R $@R69O5=:8R =R  (R'*!R#RR#$'R$#!.R.R%%!. # R$)' #(R$R$#O )')R !,Q,  AR  # R (#)R '$"R 
AR '!R $*')(R "*()R$%)@R+#R) #AR $,+'AR) R'!R$)' #(R'RO ($'R'$"R())R!,R') 'R) #R # R')R$*)R$R, $!R !$) @R AR @ @AR 17 %".# ()7 
37 7 ,27 ! 0AR 9;8R @@R 86;RE6459F@RR!($R7 $+)*( "7227,27 ) AR9<7R@@R577AR 579P7:RE645<FRE%%!. # RK$' #'.R%' # %!(R$R$#)')R!,LR )$R #)'%')R $!!) +O'  # # R  '"#)(R $+'#R .R '!R!$'R!,F@R %)'R6R$R) R'!R
' )') $#R
)AR ,  R$(R#$)R(.R$#R,$'R$*)R()$%%!AR$(R#$)R#R $"%!) $#R) '$* R'!R$""$#R!,@R  )R %)'R6R$(R(.R (R) )R %)'R5R $+'#(R, ) R '(%)R )$R !!R (* )(R #$)R $+'R #R  %)'R 6R $'R ) R ,R $' R$#+#) $#@R=R@@@RN64<@R()$%%!R (R$#R$R) $(R(*O )(R $" 3R '$"R  %)'R 6Q*)AR %'R
(* +(7
$ () $AR (R $+'R #R %)'R5R) '$* R) R #$'%$') $#R$R())R!,@R )R$!!$,(R) )R())R!,R$#)'$!(R (%*)(R$*)R()$%%!R*#O 'R %)'R6R(R,!!@R R'$ # /R) )R$*'R '* )(R +R !R) )R'!R$"O "$#R !,R %'$+ (R ) R '*!R $R &* )!R ()$%%!R $'R  'O "#)(R $+'#R.R %)'R6@R 0.7,27 ( $ ,)7+ $ ".7 AR 7R @8) R 55::R E=) R  '@R 6465FC7 $* ( $7 227 ,27 ( $AR 788R @7R578AR587P88RE5()R '@R6447FCR# * 5$(%$7% $ (* %$7 #6 * 7 (*$ () &37 $27 ,27 # * 7 % $ (* %$7 $* ($* %$"37 $@AR 5=<R @7R <<AR =:R E6R  '@R 5===FCR $* ($* %$"7 & (7 %27 ,27  -  )) $7 ) $ $717
$" $7 AR64:R@7R855AR85;R #@8RE8) R '@R6444F@R
R0) R $!(AR)$R) R$#)''.AR) )R())R!,R %%! (@R  $*%$7 ,27 $ $7 (%(7 $)+($ 7 %@AR 5:5R @8) R 6<6AR 6<;P<<RE9) R '@R6469FAR%) ) $#R$'R') $'' R%# # AR $@R69P 57<7@R R 'R, ) R $*%$R#RR) )AR+#R R,R,'R)$R'O )R R '!R '*!R $R &* )!R ()$%%!AR ,R ,$*!R )R ) R 54R $@R69O5=:8R '!R '*!R '$"R ())R !,@R
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
(* +(7
$ () $7'&* '(R*(R)$R#$'R' )') $#R 'O "#)(R*#'R %)'R5R$R) R'!R
' )') $#R
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
Q,R +R+!$%R) "R'$"R K$' #'.LR$'RK #'!LR%' # %!(R$R$#)')R!,@R 17%"6 .# ()AR9;8R@@R)R879CR%!7,27%#&+* (7
))% * )7 $* ($* %$"37 $2AR69;R@7R;44AR;48P49RE;) R '@R6445F@R *"%J(R%'$%$(R'*!R ,$*!R!!$,R) 'R%') (R)$R' )')R! "(R) )R!! R $ #)R " ($#*)R .R )R #R ) R ( #)$'.R )$R #R ' )') $#R  'O "#)@RR 7 " (7 (,  7%(&27,27($!" $AR5;;R@7R=86AR=8;R E55) R '@R5===F@R (R'*!R$(R#$)R("RK$' #'.LR)$R*(@R)R ,$*!R!!$,R) 'R%') (R)$R( R#0)(R'$"RR$#)')R$'R ,  R# ) 'R%').R# $) )AR%' + # R "R$R) R#0)R $R (R '  #R , ) R ''$'"@R R 5 $'AR  "" )*%$7 %$7 %$6 *(*)RN5B5RE8) R@R646:FREK R $!R$R$#)')R!,R (R)$R $!R %') (R)$R)  'R '"#)(R($R) )R) .R' +R) R#0)(R$R )  'R'  #(@LF
)R".R" R(#(R)$R%%!.R&* )!R()$%O %!R, #RR%').R)$RR$#)')R$(R($") # R)$R" RR) 'R %').R) # R R (R$*#R)$R )Q$'R-"%!AR R "R(*R *"%R $'R' # R) R)'"(R$R('+ @RR7$ ( .AR9=4R@@R)R 87;RE&*$) # R65 $'AR "" )*%$7%$7%$*(*)RN9;B5=R)R644RE8) R @R645;FF@R*)R "R (#J)R((') # RR$#)')*!R' )R  #()R *"%R#AR(R'R(R,R#R)!!AR#+'R R#.) # R)$R" R *"%R) # R )R,(R$*#R)$R) R)'"(@R
$%) # R *"%J(R'*!R " )R!($R ()*'R- () # R$""' !R'!) $#(CR%') (R)$R O !)'!R' )') $#R '"#)(R,$*!RR!)R,$#' # R,  R ) 'R%') (AR%$(( !.R*# #$,#R)$R) "AR$*!R#$'R)  'R 56R $@R69O5=:8R ' )') $#R '"#)(R  #()RR%$(( !R!,(* )@RR # ""7 %%)AR884R@@R)R;6<P6=@R *"%R'! (R$#R$ (-( * ()7*7 "%.4)7,27
( %$+*7 $)+($ 7 %@AR944R@7R9;5RE;) R '@R644;FAR,  R*(RR'*!R',#R'$"R '!R !,R $+'R $#R '$"R ! $'# R !,R , #R   # R , ) 'RR"#R)$R' )')R,(R) "!.@R )R ( $#R$(R #$)R$#'#R()$%%!Q#R )R%'(R
(* +(7
$ () $AR,  R )$!R*(R)$R )R'*!(R$R()$%%!R'$"R())R!,@R R%#!R'! R $#RR(*%%$(R#R$'R#) $#!R*# $'" ).R) )R) R*%'"R $*')R' )R),$R.'(R!)'@R*(R )R%')R
(* +(7
$6  () $AR) R%#!R #R
( %$+*R!($R R#$)R$#( 'R) R2)R $R=R@@@RN64<AR,  R''(R R)$R %)'R5R)$R #!R*#O %'$+ O$'R((@R )+'R$'7
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
  R