Henderson v. Morse
Opinion of the Court
On January 26, 1915, the Cogswell Candy Company, a corporation of Missouri, engaged in the retail candy business, had a fire at its place of business, resulting in the destruction of considerable property, upon which it carried insurance in five insurance companies, aggregating $9,000. Ruth Cogswell was its president, and W. R. Cogswell its secretary and treasurer. Shortly after the fire occurred W. R. Cogswell signed a contract, as secretary and treasurer of the company, employing the appellant, Devereaux Henderson, an attorney at law, to collect the claims of the candy company against the insurance companies, for 15 per cent, of the total sum collected. On the same day the president objected to the contract, and soon thereafter the board of directors of the company repudiated it. Henderson, as soon as the contract was signed, entered upon the discharge of the duties of his employment, but did little, if any, work before he was advised of the disapproval of his contract. On January 28, 1915, the company was adjudicated a bankrupt, and John J. Morse, the appellee, chosen trustee. He collected, without the assistance of Mr. Henderson, $5,354.51 from the insurance companies, and Henderson presented a claim against the estate-in bank
The rule is well settled in this court that the findings of a referee in a case like this, concurred in by the court on petition for review, are presumptively correct, and will not be disturbed by an appellate court unless some obvious error of law or serious mistake in considering the evidence has occurred. As we are unable to find any such error or mistake, and think the order is well sustained by the proof, it must be affirmed, and the petition to revise dismissed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- HENDERSON v. MORSE (two cases). In re COGSWELL CANDY CO.
- Status
- Published