Ivra v. Britton
Ivra v. Britton
Opinion of the Court
Appellants in these consolidated cases are present and former black employees of the Crawfordsville, Arkansas School District. They appeal from the district court’s
In the first of these lawsuits filed in 1974 (Ivra, et al.), twelve plaintiffs asserted a variety of allegations of discriminatory treatment in the terms and conditions of employment in the Crawfordsville School District. On October 5, 1983, the district court issued a comprehensive opinion ruling against plaintiffs on all claims and dismissing the complaint. We have carefully reviewed the record and, finding no mistake of fact or law, affirm the dismissal on the basis of the district court’s memorandum opinion.
Less Doll Twillie, Dorothy Bass, and Dewitt Martin filed a third suit
On appeal, Twillie, Bass, and Martin challenge the court’s failure to find that the school district did not renew their contracts because of their race, and allege various errors in the scope of the relief granted. Defendants cross-appeal, alleging error in the district court’s finding of unlawful discrimination and in the scope of the backpay award. In addition, cross-appellants contend that the trial court did not squarely rule on the defense of qualified immunity asserted by the individual defendants, and that the court should have directed dismissal as to defendants in their individual capacities. After examining the record and considering the arguments of the parties on appeal, we conclude that the judgment of the district court should be affirmed. However, we remand this ease to the district court for the limited purpose of clarifying whether the monetary awards were assessed against the named defendants in their individual capacities as well as in their official capacities.
Appellants Mansell Twillie, Wilma Thornton, and Florence Perkins filed the fourth lawsuit in 1980, alleging that the school district did not renew their employment
Accordingly, the judgment of the district court in each of these cases is affirmed, subject to our limited order of remand in the 1978 lawsuit. See 8th Cir.R. 14.
. The Honorable G. Thomas Eisele, Chief United States District Judge for the Eastern District of Arkansas.
. A second lawsuit, filed by Floyd Munn, has not been appealed.
. Should the district court determine that the money judgment applies to the named defendants in their individual capacities, and should the defendants wish to challenge that ruling, we will expedite an appeal on that issue.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Jessee IVRA, Velma Smith, Barbara Jones, Lawrence Woods, Less Doll Twillie, Dorothy Woods, Anna Brown, Hazel A. Drinkwater, Earnestine Taylor, Ora Harris, Mansell Twillie, and Leurlene Price v. C.B. BRITTON, President of the Crawfordsville School Board, W.J. Carlson, Robert English, Randall Johnson, and Henry Valentine, Board Members, and G.B. Pouncey, Appellees Floyd MUNN v. C.B. BRITTON, President of the Crawfordsville School Board, W.J. Carlson, Robert English, Randall Johnson, and Henry Valentine, Board Members, and G.B. Pouncey, Appellees Mansell TWILLIE, Wilma J. Thornton, and Florence Perkins v. G.B. POUNCEY, Superintendent, Edward Hampton, President of the Crawfordsville School Board, Bill Robinson, David Wallace, W.H. Green, and James Jackson, Jr., Board Members, Appellees Less Doll TWILLIE and Dorothy A. Bass, Dewitt D. Martin v. CRAWFORDSVILLE, ARKANSAS SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 2, Farrington B. Snipes, Jr., President of Board of Directors, W.J. Carlson, Edward Hampton, W.D. Robertson, each in their individual capacity and as members of the Board of Directors of the Crawfordsville Independent School District No. 2, G.B. Pouncey, Superintendent, in his individual capacity and as Superintendent of Schools of Crawfordsville Independent School District No. 2, Appellees Less Doll TWILLIE, Dorothy A. Bass, and Dewitt D. Martin v. CRAWFORDSVILLE, ARKANSAS SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 2, Farrington B. Snipes, Jr., President of Board of Directors, W.J. Carlson, Edward Hampton, W.D. Robertson, each in their individual capacity and as members of the Board of Directors of the Crawfordsville Independent School District No. 2, G.B. Pouncey, Superintendent, in his individual capacity and as Superintendent of Schools of Crawfordsville Independent School District No. 2, Appellants Less Doll TWILLIE and Dorothy A. Bass, Dewitt D. Martin v. CRAWFORDSVILLE, ARKANSAS SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 2, Farrington B. Snipes, Jr., President of Board of Directors, W.J. Carlson, Edward Hampton, W.D. Robertson, each in their individual capacity and as members of the Board of Directors of the Crawfordsville Independent School District No. 2, G.B. Pouncey, Superintendent, in his individual capacity and as Superintendent of Schools of Crawfordsville Independent School District No. 2
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published