Kuroiwa v. United States
Opinion of the Court
MEMORANDUM
Plaintiffs James I. Kuroiwa, Jr., Patricia A. Carroll, Toby M. Kravet, Garry P. Smith, Earl F. Arakaki, and Thurston Twigg-Smith appeal the district court’s judgment on the pleadings in then- action alleging breaches of trust and constitutional claims against Defendants Linda Lingle, Georgina Kawamura, Russ K. Saito, Laura H. Thielen, Sandra Lee Kunimoto, Theodore E. Liu, Brennon Morioka, Haunani Apoliona, Walter M. Heen, Rowena Akana, Donald B. Cataluña, Robert K. Lindsey, Jr., Colette Y. Machado, Boyd P. Moss-man, Oswald Stender, and John D. Waihee IV. Plaintiffs’ lawyer, H. William Burgess, appeals the district court’s imposition of sanctions against him under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11. Burgess also appeals the district court’s denial of his motion for Rule 11 sanctions against Defendants’ lawyers. Reviewing de novo the judgment on the pleadings, Knappenberger v. City of Phoenix, 566 F.3d 936, 939 (9th Cir. 2009), and reviewing for abuse of discretion the imposition of Rule 11 sanctions, as well as a refusal to do so, Holgate v. Baldwin, 425 F.3d 671, 675 (9th Cir. 2005), we affirm.
1. The district court correctly held that Plaintiffs’ claims are foreclosed by Arakaki v. Lingle, 477 F.3d 1048 (9th Cir. 2007). Although we remanded in Arakaki to allow the plaintiffs to present an alternative theory of standing, if any exists, Plaintiffs here raise only theories of standing that we rejected in Arakaki. Our decision in Arakaki is binding on us. See generally Miller v. Gammie, 335 F.3d 889, 899-900 (9th Cir. 2003) (en banc).
2. The district court did not abuse its discretion in imposing Rule 11 sanctions
3. The district court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion for sanctions against Defendants’ lawyers. The district court correctly concluded that the motion was, itself, “wholly frivolous.” Kuroiwa v. Lingle, No. CV-08-00153-JMS-KSC, 2008 WL 4056137, at *5 (D.Haw. Aug.27, 2008) (unpublished order granting OHA Defendants’ motion for Rule 11 sanctions and denying Plaintiffs’ motion for Rule 11 sanctions).
AFFIRMED.
This disposition is not appropriate for publication and is not precedent except as provided by Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- James I. KUROIWA, Jr. Patricia A. Carroll Toby M. Kravet Garry P. Smith Earl F. Arakaki Thurston Twigg-Smith, Plaintiffs—Appellants v. UNITED STATES of America, Respondent—Appellee, Linda Lingle, in her official capacity as Governor of the State of Hawaii Georgina Kawamura, in her official capacity as Director of the Department of Budget and Finance Russ K. Saito, in his official capacity as State Comptroller and Director of the Department of Accounting and General Services Laura H. Thielen, in her official capacity as Chairman of the Board of Land and Natural Resources Sandra Lee Kunimoto, in her official capacity as Director of the Department of Agriculture Theodore E. Liu, in his official capacity as Director of the Department of Business Economic Development and Tourism Brennon Morioka, in his official capacity as Interim Director of the Department of Transportation Haunani Apoliona, in her capacity as Chairperson of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs Walter M. Heen Rowena Akana Donald B. Cataluna Robert K. Lindsey Jr. Colette Y. Machado Boyd P. Mossman Oswald Stender John D. Waihee, IV, in their official capacities as Trustees of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, Defendants—Appellees James I. Kuroiwa, Jr. Patricia A. Carroll Toby M. Kravet Garry P. Smith Earl F. Arakaki Thurston Twigg-Smith, and H. William Burgess v. United States of America, Respondent—Appellee, Linda Lingle, in her official capacity as Governor of the State of Hawaii Georgina Kawamura, in her official capacity as Director of the Department of Budget and Finance Russ K. Saito, in his official capacity as State Comptroller and Director of the Department of Accounting and General Services Laura H. Thielen, in her official capacity as Chairman of the Board of Land and Natural Resources Sandra Lee Kunimoto, in her official capacity as Director of the Department of Agriculture Theodore E. Liu, in his official capacity as Director of the Department of Business Economic Development and Tourism Brennon Morioka, in his official capacity as Interim Director of the Department of Transportation Haunani Apoliona, in her capacity as Chairperson of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs Walter M. Heen Rowena Akana Donald B. Cataluna Robert K. Lindsey Jr. Colette Y. Machado Boyd P. Mossman Oswald Stender John D. Waihee, IV, in their official capacities as Trustees of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, Defendants—Appellees
- Status
- Published