Otterback v. Patch
Otterback v. Patch
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court:
If the case had been presented on the demurrer originally
That there were many errors and irregularities in the several successive writs of scire facias, issued for revival of ■ the original judgment, would seem to be clear; but those errors and irregularities are not within the reach of an
In the trial of an issue made on a plea of nul tiel record, to a scire facias on judgment, the court decides by an inspection of the record; but the record inspected makes no part of the proceedings of the case on trial; and the decision of the lower court can be reviewed only by means of a bill of exception, setting forth the record offered, and the ruling thereon, to which exception is taken. Dorsey v. Whetcroft, 1 Har. & John. 463; Ayres v. Kain, 3 Gill & John. 24; Mullikin v. Duvall, 7 Gill & John. 355; Le Strange v. State, 58 Md. 41.
And so, in respect to the ruling on the trial of the plea of the Statute of Limitations, if there be no exception to such ruling, or no special verdict found, setting forth the facts upon which the ruling of the court is made, an appellate court cannot review the decision of the court below on the decisions thus made. There must be an exception taken to the ruling of the court complained of. In this case, there is no question presented for review here, and it follows, that the judgment appealed from must be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed, with costs to the appellees.
070rehearing
On December 14, 1894, Messrs. Willoughby & Willoughby, on behalf of the appellants, filed a motion for a rehearing, and also a petition for an order for the production of the original papers.
On January 22, 1895, the motions were overruled,
delivering the opinion of the Court :
There is a motion made in this case for rehearing, and also for an order for the production of the original papers in the case to be used on such rehearing. But we think neither motion ought to be granted. The transcript of the record brought into this court appears to have been made up by stipulation of the counsel of the parties, and if they
Motions overruled.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- OTTERBACK v. PATCH
- Status
- Published