Farmer v. International Fur & Leather Workers Union
Farmer v. International Fur & Leather Workers Union
Opinion of the Court
Appellee, the International' Fur and Leather Workers Union of United States and Canada, brought this suit to enjoin appellants, who are members of the National Labor Relations Board, from depriving appellee of its compliance status under § 9(h) of the National Labor Relations Act.
Ben Gold, the president of the Inter-nationa] Fur and Leather Workers Union, was convicted in April 1954 of filing a false non-Communist affidavit in 1950.® Affidavits are required to be filed annually and are effective only for one year. On May 11, 1954, immediately after Gold was re-elected by the Union, he submitted a non-Communist affidavit to the Board for the ensuing twelve-month period in accordance with the annual filing requirement. In proceedings which the Beard had instituted immediately after Gold’s conviction, an order was issued on May 28, 1954 rejecting Gold’s 1954 affidavit because of his conviction, and holding the Union therefore not in compliance under § 9(h). From the fact of Gold’s conviction, the Board draws a conclusion that the Union was aware of the falsity of his May 11, 1954 affidavit.
Now that the Board has brought the “union awareness” problem before us, we feel our decision must be the same as that in the United Electrical, Radio & Machine Workers case. The absence of authority in the Board to deprive the. Union of its compliance status under § 9(h) cannot be supplied by membership awareness of the falsity of the affidavit.
Affirmed.
. 61 Stat. 146 (1947), as amended, 29 U.S. O.A. § 159(h): “No investigation shall be made by the Board of any question affecting commerce concerning the representation of employees, raised by a labor organization under subsection (c) of this section, and no complaint shall be issued pursuant to a charge made by a labor organization under subsection (b) of section 160 of this title, unless there is on file with the Board an affidavit executed contemporaneously or within the preceding twelve-month period by each officer of such labor organization and the officers of any national or international labor organization of which it is an affiliate or constituent unit that he is not a member of the Communist Party or affiliated with such party, and that he does not believe in, and is not a member of or supports any organization that believes in or teaches, the overthrow of the United States Government by force or by any illegal or unconstitutional methods. The provisions of section 35A of the Criminal Code shall be applicable in respect to such affidavits.”
. 1953, 93 U.S.App.D.C. 178, 211 F.2d 36, certiorari denied, 1954, 347 U.S. 943, 74 S.Ct. 638, 98 L.Ed. 1091, hereafter referred to as United Electrical Workers.
. 93 U.S.App.D.C. at page 181, 211 F.2d at pag( 39.
. Ibid.
. This conviction is now pending on appeal in t lis court (Gold v. United States, No. 12,332).
. Nor does the Act empower the Board to reject Gold’s 1954 affidavit on the ground that his 1950 affidavit was false.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Guy FARMER, as Chairman, Abe Murdock, Ivar H. Peterson, Philip Ray Rogers and Albert C. Beeson, as members of and constituting the National Labor Relations Board v. INTERNATIONAL FUR AND LEATHER WORKERS UNION OF UNITED STATES AND CANADA
- Cited By
- 5 cases
- Status
- Published