Perry v. Crammond
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Michigan Insurance v. Estate of Leavenworth (Vt. 1856)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
(charging jury). These have been called accommodation bills, and, in one sense of the term, they may be so considered; but it does not follow, that an endorsee of them, for a valu-' able consideration, though with full notice ■of every circumstance attending them, may not recover. If they were deposited with Hadfield for the accommodation of the drawers, to enable him to raise money for their use, or for his own indemnification; they were given for a consideration, and would give a right of recovery to any person who might choose to purchase, and pay a full consideration of them. Nay, if they had been drawn for the accommodation of Hadfield. and with a view to enable him to raise money upon the credit of the drawers; they, after thus lending their names, could not resist payment to a bona fide purchaser of them, though notice was given at the time of transfer, of the purpose for which they were drawn. Wherever a bill is drawn for a consideration which is illegal, or which happens to fail, neither the payee, nor any subsequent endorsee, with notice, can recover; but that is quite a different case from the present.
The nature of this transaction, the purpose for which these bills Were drawn and remitted. and the double character in which Hadfield stood as drawer and agent; furnish answers to most of the objections against the plaintiffs’ right of recovery. The bills were sent over with blank endorsements, and were to be used as occasion might require, for supporting the credit of Clow A Cay. No doubt the plan contemplated by Clow & Cay, and also by Hadfield, was to dispose of as many of these bills at a time, as would raise money to enable Had-field to take up such bills as were becoming due; and in case remittances should arrive in time, again to take up such of these bills, as had been negotiated, and were becoming due, by a negotiation of more of them; so as to postpone the protest of any of them, until remittances should arrive. If Hadfield should be able, from his own funds, or from the aid of friends, to raise money for the above purposes; he was authorized, by Clow & Cay, as he expressly swears in his answer to the defendant’s bill in England, to hold or use those bills for his indemnification and repayment; or he might at any time have delivered them over to any person, advancing money for the use of Clow & Cay; and therefore, if he had delivered these bills to Muilman & Company, as they made their advances, or even if the advances had been made upon the security of these bills, and under a promise to deliver them when called for; in the former case, no doubt could exist of the plaintiffs’ right to recover; and even in the latter case, I should incline to think that the delivery, after the death of Clow & Cay, might not be open to the objections which have been made. But, as it appears, obviously, that the advances made by Muilman & Co., were upon the credit of Hadfield, backed by the guarantee of Clow & Cay; Hadfield could not, merely upon the ground of those advances, transfer these bills, after the death of Clow & Cay, for the purpose, as Hadfield declares, of giving Nantes a better security. The intention of sending him the bills, having been, to enable him, on the credit of them, to raise money; not to protest them, with a view to securing prior advances, made upon another account. This however, is of very little consequence in the present case; because, if Hadfield has, from his own funds, or from those of Muilman & Co., advanced for Clow & Cay, a sum equal to the amount of the bills in suit, he thereby became a creditor of Clow & Cay, to that amount; no matter from whom he obtained the money; and in the latter ease, being to that amount the creditor of Clow & Cay, and the debtor of Muilman & Co., he had a right, at any time, to pass away these bills, for the purpose of repaying or indemnifying himself; and this brings us to the great question, whether he was a creditor of Clow & Cay, to this or any other amount, at the time he delivered over the bills to Nantes. It must be admitted, that advances, to a larger amount than these bills, were made by Muilman & Co. to Hadfield, for the use of Clow & Cay; but the question is, whether they were not discharged by remittances made by Clow & Cay to Hadfield. In the account stated by the master in England, we find very large sums of money paid by Had-field for the use of Clow & Cay, leaving at
As to the objection, on the ground of the acceptance being antedated, as well as other irregularities attending the negotiation of the bills, I will not say that they would be fatal in a transaction so peculiar in its nature as the present, if Nantes appeared to have been a fair bona fide purchaser, upon the ground of a debt due from Hadfield to him for money advanced to him for Clow & Cay, and from them to Hadfield. still remaining unpaid; because from the nature of the trust reposed in Hadfield, he could not easily negotiate them in the ordinary way, to answer, the purposes for which they were deposited' with him. The question then, for the jury, will'be, whether Hadfield was a creditor of Clow & Cay, for advances to the amount of the bills in question; so as to authorize him or his endorsee to recover upon the ground of indemnity. If not, the verdict ought to be for the defendant; if otherwise, for the plaintiff.
Verdict for the defendant.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.