U.S. Circuit Court for the District of District of Columbia, 1808

Harper v. Smith

Harper v. Smith
U.S. Circuit Court for the District of District of Columbia · Decided July 15, 1808 · Duckett
11 F. Cas. 583; 1 Cranch 495
Harper v. Smith

Opinion of the Court

THE COURT

(DUCKETT, Circuit Judge,

contra) refused to instruct the jury that the bond produced on oyer was not the bond of J. & D. Douglas, because they supposed the question not material to the issue. The averment in the plea was, in substance, that the bond in the declaration mentioned was executed in pursuance of the corrupt agreement, and the description of the bond, calling it the bond of J. & D. Douglas, was not necessary to be proved, the proof being that the bond in the declaration mentioned was given in execution of the corrupt agreement.

The allegation in the plea was, that the corrupt agreement was made on the-day of November, and the evidence was, that the terms of the agreement were concluded in September.

THE COURT (nem. con.) said the variance was not material.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.