Zhejiang Amerisun Tech. Co. v. United States
Opinion
+*.. # " +$*,1*'' 3 &'s/& &,,*'&/)s&/s3&02%(& s2/1s &'&,%$,1 $,% &'&,%$,1,1&/3&,s/ ,%CAB/7<7<5B63'%3>/@B;3<B=4=;;3@13NA47</:A1=>3@C:7<5B6/B13@B/7< 3<57<3AAC16/A6=<5?7<5$/B=NA$ %3<57<3A/@3<=B7<1:C2327<B63 /<B72C;>7<5/<21=C<B3@D/7:7<52CBG=@23@A=<13@B/7<D3@B71/:A6/4B3<57<3A 03BE33<11/<2C>B= 11/<2>/@BAB63@3=44@=;B63#3=>:3NA$3>C0:71=4 67</s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
=C@B!= #/53 E7B6:/E031/CA3 B63A1=>3:/<5C/53=4B63"@23@A<37B63@A>3174732B6/B/ 53/@0=F1=<<31B32B=/A6/4BE/A>/@B=4B633<57<3<=@7<1:C232/<G:/<5C/53B6/B @3/A=</0:GAC553AB32AC16/@3AC:B/<2=;;3@13C<:/E4C::G7<B3@>@3B32AC16 A7:3<13B=/AAC;3B6/BB633<57<3E/AE7B67<B63A1=>3=4B63"@23@A B63 )797>327//@B71:3AB6/B=;;3@1317B32E3@3<=B@3:7/0:3=@AC447173<B3D723<134=@ B632347<7B7=<=4/K>=E3@B/93=44A6/4BL/<2 B63#3<<AG:D/<7/%B/B3 '<7D3@A7BG/@B71:3=<E6716=;;3@13@3:732272<=B>@=D723AC447173<B3D723<B7/@G AC>>=@B4=@B63A1=>323B3@;7</B7=<+6387/<5;3@7AC< %C>> 2/B J <7BA$3;/<2$323B3@;7</B7=<=;;3@1323B3@;7<32B6/B13@B/7<3<57<3A AC16/AB636=<5?7<5$/B=NA$ %3<57<3/@3<=B1=D3@320GB63A1=>3=4B63 "@23@A$3;/<2$323B3@;7</B7=</B ! &63=C@B6/A8C@7A271B7=<>C@AC/<BB=%31B7=< / D7=4B63 &/@7441B=4 /A/;3<232 '%I // D7/<2 '% I 1&63=C@BE7::6=:2C<:/E4C:/<G23B3@;7</B7=<4=C<2B=03 C<AC>>=@B320GAC0AB/<B7/:3D723<13=<B63@31=@2=@=B63@E7A3<=B7</11=@2/<13 E7B6:/E '%I /0 7 =B6#:/7<B744/<2343<2/<BA339B=ACAB/7<B63$3;/<2$323B3@;7</B7=<
=C@B!= #/53 0CB#:/7<B74427A/5@33AE7B6K=;;3@13NA;7A16/@/1B3@7H/B7=<=4B63$ % 3<57<3/A/M;=274732D3@B71/:A6/4B3<57<3NL%33#:NA@/B J 34NA@/B J =;;3@137<7BA$3;/<2$323B3@;7</B7=<23B3@;7<32B6/B6=<5?7<5 $/B=NA$ %3<57<3E/A<=B1=D3@320GB63A1=>3=4B63"@23@A0CB27A/5@332 E7B6B63=C@BB6/B B63:/<5C/53=4B63A1=>3;CABA>3174GB6/B/53/@0=F1=<<31B32B= /A6/4B7A>/@B=4/<3<57<37<=@23@4=@=;;3@13B=47<2B6/BAC16/ 1=<475C@/B7=<7A/<7<B35@/B32>/@B=4/D3@B71/:A6/4B3<57<3/<2 =;;3@13;/G<=B@3:G=</1/23;71>C0:71/B7=<AB6/BA>3/9B=3<57<3 AB@C1BC@3AC16/AB63/@B71:34@=;#3<<,AG:D/<7/s%B/B3'<7D3@A7BG=< E6716 =;;3@13 @3:732 7< B63 7</: %1=>3 $C:7<5 3D3< 74 AC16 A=C@13A /@3 <=B A>317471 B= :/E< ;=E3@A 3A>317/::G 57D3< B6/B B63 >@=2C1BA1=D3@320GB63"@23@A/@3<=B:7;7B32B=:/E<;=E3@3<57<3A $3;/<2$323B3@;7</B7=</B =;;3@13/:A=AB/B32B6/B7BE=C:2<=B16/<53B6316/@/1B3@7H/B7=<=4 6=<5?7<5$/B=NA$ %3<57<3/A/;=274732D3@B71/:A6/4B3<57<3E63< @343@@7<5B=7BA>@7=@23B3@;7</B7=<7<B637</:%1=>3$C:7<5 2/B =;;3@13/AA3@B32B6/B4=@B63>C@>=A3A=4B63$3;/<2$323B3@;7</B7=< 6=E3D3@7B@343@@32B=B63>@=2C1B/B7AAC3/AK13@B/7<3<57<3AAC16/A 6=<5?7<5$/B=NA,$ %sL 2#:/7<B744/5@33AE7B6=;;3@13NA<3E 23B3@;7</B7=<7<B63$3;/<2$323B3@;7</B7=<B6/B6=<5?7<5$/B=NA$ %3<57<3/<2A7;7:/@3<57<3AE3@33F1:C2324@=;B63A1=>3=4B63"@23@A
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
=C@B!= #/53 C25;3<BE7::033<B3@32/11=@27<5:G A 3<<743@6=3@=D3A 3<<743@6=3@=D3A C253 /B32"1B=03@ !3E*=@9!3E*=@9
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.