Ostrom v. Clapp
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- State v. LaFera (N.J. 1964)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The evidence of plaintiff, appellee, showed: That on July 21, 1902, Ostrom gave one of the mortgages to secure a $525 note, executed by him on that date to Clapp, due July 21, 1903, with interest from date until paid at the rate of 7 per cent, per annum, and the second mortgage was given on August 7, 1903, by Ostrom to Clapp to secure a second note of that date for $1,332.50 from Ostrom to .Clapp, due February 7, 1903, with interest from date until paid at 7 per cent, per annum, delinquent interest to bear interest at 8 per cent, per annum. That these loans were negotiated by one Gilbert. That for the $525 note Ostrom received in cash $500. That $25 in said note was a commission to Gilbert under a written contract from Ostrom reading as follows: “July 21, 1902. I hereby employ N. T. Gilbert to procure for me-from such person as he is able, a loan of five hundred and twenty-five dollars ($525.00) for one year at seven per cent, interest per annum secured by cattle and horses and agree to pay said Gilbert for his services twenty-five dollars ($25.00). J. A. Ostrom.” That for the $1,332.50 note Ostrom received in cash $1,299. That $32.50 in said note was a commission to Gilbert under a written contract from Ostrom as follows: “August 7th, 1902. I hereby employ N. T. Gilbert to procure for me a loan of one thousand three hundred and thirty-two dollars and fifty cents
The sixth, seventh, eighth, and ninth errors complained of relate to the following condition, and may be all considered together: The ninth specification of error is as follows: “The court erred in overruling appellant’s motion for a new trial and rendering judgment on the verdict on account of the misconduct, bias, and prejudice of A. J. Musgrove, one of the-jurors who tried this cause, and who on his voir dire swore that he had not formed or expressed an opinion as to the merits of the case, but who during the trial of said cause, after the examination of one witness only on the part of plaintiff,- at the dinner table stated
The question of usury was before the jury. Contradictor testimony upon the matter of usury was there for determination, and the question was to be determined upon the evidence in this particular case by a jury competent and unprejudiced. One of the affidavits submitted on the hearing of the motion for new trial as to juror Musgrove reads as follows: “After the jury had returned a verdict for plaintiff'in the case of C-lapp vs Ostrom * * * one of the jurors in the trial .of said cause, to wit, A. J. Musgrove, came into the room; that he, James Martin, and John Carter were all in the room when said juror appeared. Carter said to the juror: ‘Did jou fix him?’ The juror said: ‘We threw it into his neck this time. On the first vote there were ten to two, on the second vote we drew one over, on the next, we drew another, and then the rest came across.’ ” This affidavit being taken as true, Musgrove, who had determined the case before being sworn as a juror, through his ability and his determination to “throw it into the neck of appellant,” brought 10 other men at first in opposition to him to his way of thinking, and we do not think, under such circumstances, that appellant had a fair and impartial trial, and the cause is therefore reversed and remanded.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.