Little v. Cellco P'ship
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision. The 1 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Berbig v. U-Haul Co of Arizona (United States District Court for the District of Idaho 2023)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This matter is about whether Verizon's Customer Agreement, which contains an arbitration clause, binds the defendant, Judy Little, and requires the court to submit this action to arbitration. For the reasons that follow, the defendant's Motion to Compel Arbitration and Stay Proceeding pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act (ECF No. 5) is hereby GRANTED and plaintiff's action is DISMISSED without prejudice.
I. BACKGROUND
Judy Little purchased a mobile hotspot device on October 21, 2015, at a Verizon *510Wireless retail location in Princeton, West Virginia. See ECF No. 5-1, ¶ 4. Before activation, Verizon required Little to sign a standardized electronic sales receipt agreeing to the terms and conditions of Verizon Wireless' Customer Agreement. See ECF No. 5-1, Ex. A ("Verizon Sales Receipt"). The electronically signed sales receipt stated in pertinent part:
I AGREE TO THE CURRENT VERIZON WIRELESS CUSTOMER AGREEMENT ... INCLUDING THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF MY PLAN ... I UNDERSTAND THAT I AM AGREEING TO ... SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES BY ARBITRATION INSTEAD OF JURY TRIALS... I AM AWARE THAT I CAN VIEW THE CUSTOMER AGREEMENT ANYTIME AT VERIZONWIRELESS.COM OR IN MY VERIZON ACCOUNT.
See id. at 3 (emphasis added). The sales receipt states "JUDY LITTLE" as the "Account Owner Name" and includes a signature. See id. While Little's signature does not appear to be a full signature, see id., plaintiff does not claim that she did not sign the sales receipt. The Customer Agreement referenced in the sales receipt is a 10-page document that includes an arbitration provision within a section titled "HOW DO I RESOLVE DISPUTES WITH VERIZON WIRELESS?" See ECF No. 5-1, Ex. B, at 7-9 ("Verizon Customer Agreement"). This section expounds upon the arbitration clause announced in the sales receipt. Id.
Little used the wireless hotspot for "less than two weeks," but the device "failed to work properly." See ECF No. 7-1, Ex. A, ¶¶ 9. As a result, she returned the device but Verizon continued to charge her. See id. at Ex. A, ¶¶ 9-11. Later, Verizon allegedly contacted Little in an attempt to collect the outstanding balance owing. See Amended Complaint at ¶¶ 3, 7-33. These telephone calls form the basis of Little's allegation that Verizon engaged in violations of federal and state debt collection laws. Id. at ¶ 3.
II. APPLICABLE LAW
A. Standard of Review
Motions to compel arbitration " 'exist in the netherworld between a motion to dismiss and a motion for summary judgment.' " U.S. ex rel. TBI Investments, Inc. v. BrooAlexa, LLC,
B. Federal Arbitration Act
The Federal Arbitration Act ("FAA") embodies "a liberal federal policy favoring arbitration," AT & T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion,
*511A written provision in ... a contract ... to settle by arbitration a controversy thereafter arising out of such contract ... or an agreement in writing to submit to arbitration an existing controversy arising out of such a contract ... shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, save upon such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract.
A party can compel arbitration under the FAA if it establishes: "(1) the existence of a dispute between the parties, (2) a written agreement that includes an arbitration provision which purports to cover the dispute, (3) the relationship of the transaction, which is evidenced by the agreement, to interstate or foreign commerce, and (4) the failure, neglect or refusal of the [opposing party] to arbitrate the dispute." Whiteside v. Teltech Corp.,
"When deciding whether the parties agreed to arbitrate a certain matter, courts generally [...] should apply ordinary state-law principles that govern the formation of contracts." First Options of Chicago, Inc. v. Kaplan,
III. Discussion
A. The Arbitration Agreement is Valid and Enforceable
Little alleges that she never agreed to arbitrate any dispute with Verizon and that defendant has failed to meet its burden of demonstrating she entered into an enforceable arbitration agreement. See Plaintiff's Response in Opposition (ECF No. 7). Accordingly, the first, third, and fourth factors in Whiteside v. Teltech Corp. are not in dispute.
Plaintiff hangs her hat on State ex rel. U-Haul Co. of W. Virginia v. Zakaib, wherein the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals held that "a general reference in one writing to another document is not sufficient to incorporate that other document into a final agreement."
Nevertheless, U-Haul argued that since the Addendum was incorporated by reference in the Rental Contract, plaintiffs' acceptance of the Rental Contract resulted in their acceptance of the Addendum as well. Id. at 590. The court disagreed, stating a "general reference is not enough," rather:
(1) the writing must make a clear reference to the other document so that the parties' assent to the reference is unmistakable; (2) the writing must describe the other document in such terms that its identity may be ascertained beyond doubt; and (3) it must be certain that the parties to the agreement had knowledge of and assented to the incorporated document so that the incorporation will not result in surprise or hardship.
See Syl. Pt. 2, id. (cited by Covol Fuels No. 4, LLC v. Pinnacle Min. Co., LLC,
U-Haul is distinguished from this matter because the executed sales receipt that Little signed
Furthermore, the Verizon sales receipt "make[s] a clear reference to the [Customer Agreement] so that the parties' assent to the reference is unmistakable." Syl. Pt. 2,
Plaintiff alleges that she never read or had knowledge of the Customer Agreement, resulting in her "surprise and hardship." See Plaintiff Response in Opposition, at 6-7 (ECF No. 7). Nevertheless, the Sales Receipt not only provided notice of the Customer Agreement but also gave independent notice of the arbitration clause, further detailed in the Customer Agreement.
Little also misreads U-Haul as requiring Verizon to provide her with a physical copy of the Customer Agreement, which she never received.
Plaintiff lodges two additional objections. First, plaintiff alleges that the signature on the sales receipt is not hers, instead resembling a "pixelated loop" created by a computer. See ECF No. 7, at 5-6. Plaintiff does not allege she did not sign the Verizon contract, nor that the signature was procured by fraud, coercion or inducement. Id. Rather, even if the signature is not a realistic model of Little's signature, it makes no legal difference. See Grant-Fletcher v. Collecto, Inc., No. CIV.A. RDB-13-3505,
Second, Little alleges that if she had known that she was signing an arbitration agreement, she would not have executed the contract. Such an argument attempts to undercut the foundation of contract law.
*514"The fact that [Little] may have chosen not to access or read the language of the Arbitration Agreement does not render it invalid or non-binding."
With the broad federal principle in favor of arbitration in mind, see AT & T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion,
B. Plaintiff Also Waived the Right to Bring a Class Action.
The Customer Agreement also contains a waiver of the right to bring a class action suit. See Verizon Customer Agreement, at 8. Because the Customer Agreement is valid, binding on the plaintiff, and enforceable by the defendant, arbitration may proceed only on an individual, not class, basis.
C. Plaintiff's Action is Dismissed.
Although defendant has moved only to stay proceedings in this matter, see ECF No. 5, the Fourth Circuit has "acknowledged that dismissal is a proper remedy when all of the issues presented in a lawsuit are arbitrable." Aggarao v. MOL Ship Mgmt. Co.,
Since all of plaintiff's claims are subject to arbitration, "no useful purpose will be served by staying the pertinent proceedings pending arbitration." Crawl v. Experian Info. Sols., Inc., No. CV PJM 15-97,
IV. CONCLUSION
This Court finds that defendant's Motion to Compel Arbitration and Stay Proceeding pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act should be, and hereby is, GRANTED. Accordingly, the Complaint is DISMISSED without prejudice.
It is SO ORDERED this 19th day of January, 2018.
Even if plaintiff did contend these factors were at issue, plaintiff's arguments would fail. As to the first factor, the Amended Complaint illustrates a dispute between the parties. Regarding the third factor, internet services are instrumentalities of interstate commerce. See, e.g., PSINet, Inc. v. Chapman,
Plaintiff argues in her Response and Surreply that the affidavit offered by Meryl Friedman, a senior paralegal employed by Verizon is inadmissible. See ECF No. 5-1. Ms. Friedman's affidavit attaches and gives context to the Verizon Sales Receipt (which includes Little's alleged signature) and the Verizon Customer Agreement.
Verizon does not dispute that it did not give a physical copy of the Customer Agreement to Little because it is its policy to provide access to the Customer Agreement online. See Verizon Sales Receipt ("I AM AWARE THAT I CAN VIEW THE CUSTOMER AGREEMENT ANYTIME AT VERIZONWIRELESS.COM OR IN MY VERIZON ACCOUNT.")
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.