Supreme Court of the United States, 1873

Reed v. Gardner

Reed v. Gardner
Supreme Court of the United States · Decided November 10, 1873 · Hunt
84 U.S. 409; 21 L. Ed. 665; 17 Wall. 409; 1873 U.S. LEXIS 1377 (United States Reports)

Counsel

Messrs. Carlisle and McPherson, for the plaintiffs in error, , Mr. W. W. Boyce, contra, , Messrs. Carlisle and McPherson replied

Reed v. Gardner

Opinion

Mr. Justice HUNT

delivered the opinion of the court.

It has been frequently held by this court, that in passing upon the questions presented in a bill of exceptions, it will not look beyond the bill itself. * The pleadings, and the statements of the bill, the verdict, and the judgment, are the only matters that are properly before the court. Depositions, exhibits, or certificates not contained in the bill, cannot be considered by the court. The case of Flanders v. Tweed, was exceptional. The court intend to adhere to this practice.

Under this rule there is then nothing whatever in the present case for the court to pass upon.

It is impossible upon a record such as this is, that we should know whether the charge is correct or erroneous, or .whether the refusals to charge as requested were justified, or whether they were improper.

■ As already said, there is absolutely nothing presented to this court for consideration.

Judgment aeeirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.