Hulbert v. Twin Falls County
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The petitioner Hulbert bid $1,050 for a used farm-type gasoline tractor which Twin Falls County, Idaho, offered for sale at an auction. His was the highest bid. Upon being informed by the Office of Price Administration that the amount bid was above the ceiling price pf $723.56, petitioner refused to pay the full amount. He tendered $723.56 which the County refused to accept. Thereupon the County sued the petitioner in the state district court for $1,050. Petitioner tendered $1,050 to be disposed of according to the outcome of the case. He defended on the ground that he had been advised by the Office of Price Administration that the regulation setting a ceiling price was applicable and stated that he was willing to pay any sum up to $1,050 which was not prohibited by this regulation. The Administrator intervened, alleging that the bid price exceeded the ceiling price fixed by Maximum Price Regulation 133
The only question properly before us is whether Maximum Price Regulation No. 133 applies to sales of tractors
Reversed.
7 F. R. 3185, 6936, 7599 ; 8 F. R. 234.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting.
I think Judge Givens, writing for the Supreme Court of Idaho (66 Idaho-, 156 P. 2d 319), has shown that it is at least doubtful if Congress meant to include the States as sellers under this Act.
Sec. 302 (h) defines the term “person” as including “an individual, corporation, partnership, association, or any other organized group of persons, or legal successor or representative of any of the foregoing, and includes the United States or any agency thereof, or any other government, or any of its political subdivisions, or any agency of any of the foregoing: Provided, That no punishment provided by this Act shall apply to the United States, or to any such government, political subdivision, or agency.”
See note. 1, supra.
A permissible construction is that the. phrase “the United States ... or any other government” means the United States or other comparable national sovereignties, i. e., foreign governments.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- HULBERT Et Al. v. TWIN FALLS COUNTY
- Cited By
- 12 cases
- Status
- Published