Hubbell v. Commissioner
Opinion
*144
A corporation purchased annual premium annuity contracts for petitioners, who were stockholders of the corporation and its principal officers. So-called employees' trusts were created for petitioners, under which a trustee held the annuity contracts. The corporation had no pension plan or program for its employees generally and none of its employees other than petitioners have ever received pension or retirement benefits.
*627 These consolidated proceedings involve deficiencies in income tax for the year 1941 as follows:
| Petitioner | Docket | Amount |
| No. | ||
| D. D. Hubbell | 3322 | $ 10,606.03 |
| Elias F. Wildermuth | 3323 | 4,527.81 |
*145 The only question presented is whether amounts paid under so-called employees' trusts by the White-Haines Optical Co. for premiums upon annuity contracts on the lives of the petitioners, who were officers of that company, constitute income to petitioners in the year in which the premiums were paid.
Petitioners are residents of Columbus, Ohio, and filed their returns for the taxable year with the collector for the eleventh district of Ohio.
FINDINGS OF FACT.
During the year 1936 the White-Haines Optical Co., hereinafter called the Optical Co., was contemplating the purchase of annuities for both petitioners. Since the Optical Co. had not reached a decision by October 1936, petitioner Hubbell, on October 2, 1936, made application to the Prudential Insurance Co. of America for an annuity policy on his own life, with payments of annuities to him commencing at his 70th birthday. The policy was to be issued for 40 premium units and the annual premium was to be $ 4,000. In his application petitioner named his daughter as the person entitled to receive death benefits.
Hubbell was president, treasurer, and general manager of the Optical Co. and had been associated with that company since*146 1901. Petitioner Wildermuth was secretary and sales manager of the Optical Co. and had been employed by it since 1913. The only other officer of the Optical Co. was one Ballard, who was its vice president.
The Optical Co. was controlled by the Bausch & Lomb Optical Co., which owned 59 percent of the Optical Co.'s outstanding stock. Hubbell owned 8 percent and Wildermuth owned 2.3 percent. The Optical Co.'s board of directors consisted of Hubbell, Wildermuth, Ballard, one Haines, and two representatives of the Bausch & Lomb Optical Co.
On December 4, 1936, at a meeting of the Optical Co.'s board of directors, a resolution was passed which provided,
Whereas, it is the desire of the Company to facilitate the retirement of certain of its executives and employees with compensation by providing suitable pension funds commensurate with the salaries of said executives and employees during the years preceding retirement, the years of service of such executives and employees being also considered in determining the amounts of such retirement pensions
*628 And Whereas, Daniel D. Hubbell is now President, Treasurer and General Manager, and E. F. Wildermuth*147 is now Secretary and Sales Manager of said company, and are two of the officers for whose retirement said company desires to provide pension funds, now therefore be it
"Resolved, that the proper officers of said company be and they are hereby authorized and empowered to purchase from The Prudential Insurance Company of America Premium Refund Annuity Contracts calling for an annual purchase premium of $ 5,000.00 per annum for Daniel D. Hubbell, and an annual purchase premium of $ 3,000.00 per annum for E. F. Wildermuth; and the Treasurer is authorized and directed to pay to said Insurance Company such annual premiums; and ordered further that said Contracts of Insurance so procured from said Insurance Company be made payable to The Ohio National Bank of Columbus, Ohio as Trustee in accordance with the terms of a Trust Agreement to be entered into between the Corporation and said bank."
Pursuant to this resolution, the Optical Co. on January 2, 1937, took over the policy previously secured by Hubbell, increasing the policy to 50 premium units, with an annual premium of $ 5,000. The $ 4,000 previously paid by Hubbell to the Prudential Co. was returned to him by that company and the *148 Optical Co. paid the Prudential Co. the new policy premium of $ 5,000. On February 4, 1937, pursuant to the application of the Optical Co., an annuity policy was issued by the Prudential Insurance Co. of America, payable to Wildermuth as the annuitant. The policy provided for 30 premium units, with an annual premium of $ 3,000, and the annuity payments were to begin when Wildermuth reached the age of 70 years. Both policies contained the following provisions:
Death Benefit. -- Immediately upon receipt of due proof of the death of the Annuitant before the first montly instalment of any Annuity hereunder has become due, while this Policy is in force, and upon legal surrender of this Policy at the Home Office of the Company, the Company shall pay either the sum of all the premiums actually paid under this Policy which fell due prior to such death, less any existing indebtedness on account of this Policy, or the net Cash Surrender Value of this Policy at the time of such death, whichever is the greater; or, if a Life Annuity (A) as herein provided has not been elected and the Annuitant lives to receive one or more monthly instalments of Annuity hereunder, but dies before the one hundred*149 and twenty monthly instalments certain have been paid the instalments certain remaining unpaid discounted at three and one-quarter per cent, per annum compound interest shall, upon receipt of due proof of the death of the Annuitant, be paid in one sum; such payment shall be made to The Ohio National Bank, of Columbus, Ohio, Trustee under Trust Agreement Dated December 23, 1936.
If there is no Beneficiary living at the death of the Annuitant to receive the Death Benefit herein provided, such Death Benefit shall be paid to the executors, administrators or assigns of the Annuitant, unless otherwise provided in this Policy. The right to change the Beneficiary has
* * * *
Non-Forfeiture Provisions
Paid-up Annuity. -- If this Policy, after being in force one full year, shall lapse or become forfeited for non-payment of any premium on the date when *629 due, as specified herein, and if it is not surrendered for its Cash Surrender Value, the Company will put in force in lieu of this Policy,
Cash Surrender Value. -- If this Policy is continued in force by the due payment of premiums for at least one year, the Annuitant, by written application and return of the Policy to the Home Office of the Company at any time but not after three months from the due date of any premium in*151 default, may elect, subject to the consent of any irrevocable beneficiary, to surrender this Policy for its net Cash Surrender Value. * * *
* * * *
Provisions for Annuity Payments Prior to Maturity.
At any time prior to the due date of the first monthly instalment of Annuity provided on the first page hereof, if all due premiums have been paid, the Annuitant may, subject to the consent of any irrevocably designated Beneficiary, elect in writing to receive
(A) A Life Annuity, payable in equal monthly instalments in every year during the lifetime of the Annuitant, commencing on the date to which premiums have been paid under this Policy and terminating with the last monthly instalment due before the death of the Annuitant, the amount of the monthly instalment payable to be determined upon the basis of the attained age of the Annuitant at the commencement of such monthly instalments in accordance with Table A below; or
(B) An Annuity payable in equal monthly instalments in every year during the lifetime of the Annuitant, commencing on the date to which premiums have been paid under this Policy and terminating with the last monthly *152 instalment due before the death of the Annuitant, except that if the Annuitant dies before receiving one hundred and twenty monthly instalments certain, the discounted value of the unpaid instalments certain shall be paid in accordance with the provision of this Policy headed "Death Benefit," contained on the first page hereof, the amount of the monthly instalment payable to be determined upon the basis of the attained age of the Annuitant at the commencement of such monthly instalments in accordance with Table B below.
Both policies contained the following endorsements:
*630 Pursuant to the resolution of December 4, 1936, two separate trust agreements were executed on December 23, 1936, by and between the Optical Co. as settlor and the Ohio National Bank of Columbus as trustee, in which the petitioners were the respective*153 beneficiaries. The agreements were executed in behalf of the Optical Co. by Hubbell as president, and Wildermuth as secretary. The agreements, which were identical except for the name of the beneficiary and the amount of annual premium, recited that the Optical Co. desired to provide a pension fund for each beneficiary and to that end had purchased an annuity contract for each beneficiary maturing when the beneficiary reached the age of 70 years. Under the agreements, the Optical Co. transferred all right, title, and interest in the annuity contracts to the trustee. The trustee agreed to hold the contracts and use its best efforts to collect all sums payable thereunder. The trustee was not required to present a claim to the insurance company until notified in writing by the Optical Co. or the trust beneficiary and was not required to take legal steps to collect any claims until indemnified. If the contracts matured during the lives of the beneficiaries, the trustee was to receive the monthly payments from the insurance company and remit such amounts, less its commission, to the beneficiaries within five days of receipt of such payments. In the event of the death of a beneficiary, *154 the trustee was to remit any payments under the contracts to such persons as the beneficiary shall have designated in his lifetime. The trustee was not required to pay any premiums to keep the contracts in force and it was particularly charged not to permit the beneficiaries to withdraw any of the cash value of the contracts while such beneficiary was employed by the Optical Co. It was further provided that the Optical Co. was not to be a beneficiary of any payment under the contracts nor was it entitled to receive any payments by way of a refunder of premiums. If the company should discontinue the payment of premiums, the annuity contracts were to be held in the reduced proportions provided therein and the trusts were to continue to operate in the same manner as if the Optical Co. had continued such premium payments.
On December 13, 1938, the board of directors of the Optical Co. passed a resolution authorizing the treasurer to discontinue payments on the annuity contracts for the benefit of petitioners and in lieu thereof a bonus was paid to Hubbell of $ 2,500, and to Wildermuth of $ 1,500. On December 18, 1939, the Optical Co. passed a resolution authorizing payment of a bonus*155 to Hubbell in the amount of $ 5,000 and to Wildermuth in the amount of $ 3,000. During each of the years 1938 and 1939, the Optical Co. did not pay the premiums specified in the two annuity contracts. During the years 1936 to 1941, inclusive, Hubbell received an annual salary of $ 20,000, exclusive of bonuses, *631 and Wildermuth received an annual salary of $ 12,000, exclusive of bonuses.
On December 5, 1940, the board of directors of the Optical Co. passed a resolution to the effect that the annuity contracts should be reinstated and the current payments paid. It was decided that the insurance company be asked to make a loan upon the annuity contracts in the aggregate amount sufficient to pay the lapsed premiums thereon. The insurance company refused to make the loans as desired by the Optical Co. and thereafter, during the year 1941, the Optical Co. paid the insurance company the back premiums and the current premiums in the aggregate sum of approximately $ 25,000.
On August 14, 1941, a supplemental trust agreement was entered into between the Optical Co. and the Ohio National Bank of Columbus, as trustee in connection with the Hubbell trust. The agreement recited that*156 by reason of an error on the part of the insurance broker the application for the Hubbell annuity contract was filed on a personal rather than a corporate application form, and that as a result of the error the annuity contract appeared to have been owned by Hubbell prior to its assignment to the trustee, when in fact the Optical Co. owned the contract prior to the assignment. The agreement further recited that to correct the error Hubbell, on July 8, 1941, assigned the contract to the Optical Co., which in turn, on the same date, assigned the contract to the Ohio National Bank of Columbus, as trustee. The agreement provided that the trustee should hold the annuity contract under the terms of the trust agreement of December 23, 1936. On December 10, 1941, the board of directors of the Optical Co. passed a resolution that it was never the intention of the Optical Co. to allow the annuity contracts to lapse, but that the real intent was merely to defer the payment of premiums on the contracts until the company was in a better cash position.
On February 4, 1942, the Optical Co. decided to discontinue the annual payments on the annuity contracts, and the annuity contract on the life*157 of Wildermuth was converted into a paid-up annuity policy providing for an annuity of $ 2,122.44, payable in equal monthly installments of $ 176.87, beginning February 4, 1957. This policy contains an endorsement as follows:
Provisions as to Ownership of the Policy
All legal incidents of ownership in the Policy, including all rights, benefits and advantages which the printed provisions thereof purport to confer on the Annuitant, except the right of the Annuitant to receive any Annuity payments becoming due during his or her lifetime, shall, anything in the Policy to the contrary notwithstanding but subject to any limitation herein set forth, belong to The White-Haines Optical Co., of Columbus, Ohio, Its Successors or Assigns.
*632 Without limiting the generality of such incidents of ownership, such incidents shall include the right.
(a) to change the Beneficiary from time to time; and
(b) to elect that Annuity payments shall begin prior to the due date of the first monthly instalment of the Annuity provided on the first page of the Policy;
but the incorporation of this rider in the Policy shall not affect the right to receive any payment after the death of the Annuitant, unless*158 the right to change the Beneficiary is exercised. Any exercise of the right to change the Beneficiary shall be by written request to the Company at its Home Office, and shall become effective when a provision to that effect has been endorsed upon the policy by the Company.
On February 7, 1942, the annuity contract on the life of Hubbell was converted into a paid-up annuity policy providing for an annuity of $ 3,419.40, payable $ 284.95 monthly, beginning October 7, 1953.
During the taxable year, the Optical Co. had approximately 350 employees. The Optical Co., to the date of the hearing in this proceeding, has never established employees' trusts for any of its employees other than petitioners, nor has it had any plan or program for the formation of such employees' trusts.
OPINION.
The issue in these proceedings is whether amounts paid under so-called employees' trusts by the Optical Co. during the taxable year for premiums upon annuity contracts on the lives of petitioners constitute taxable income to petitioners under
*160 *633 Petitioners contend that the two trusts created by the Optical Co. comply with the literal requirements of
Respondent contends that the trusts for petitioners are not employees' trusts within the meaning and intent of
The legislative history of
Upon due consideration of all the facts of these proceedings, it is our opinion that these trusts do not qualify as tax exempt trusts under
We do not believe that it was ever the legislative intent to allow trusts such as these to qualify as tax-exempt under
Were it not for the creation of the trusts in these proceedings, the factual situation here would be similar to that in
*164 Does, then, the creation of these trusts bring the proceedings within
The
Under the circumstances it is held that the trusts created by the Optical Co. are not within the purview of
Footnotes
1.
SEC. 165 . EMPLOYEES' TRUSTS. [Prior to amendment by sec. 162 of the Revenue Act of 1942.]A trust forming part of a stock bonus, pension, or profit-sharing plan of an employer for the exclusive benefit of some or all of his employees --
shall not be taxable under section 161, but the amount actually distributed or made available to any distributee shall be taxable to him in the year in which so distributed or made available to the extent that it exceeds the amounts paid in by him. Such distributees shall for the purpose of the normal tax be allowed as credits against net income such part of the amount so distributed or made available as represents the items of interest specified in section 25 (a).(1) if contributions are made to the trust by such employer, or employees, or both, for the purpose of distributing to such employees the earnings and principal of the fund accumulated by the trust in accordance with such plan, and
(2) if under the trust instrument it is impossible, at any time prior to the satisfaction of all liabilities with respect to employees under the trust, for any part of the corpus or income to be (within the taxable year or thereafter) used for, or diverted to, purposes other than for the exclusive benefit of his employees.↩
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.