Charles L. Huisking & Co. v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Full Serv. Beverage Co. v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1995)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*249
Debenture bonds unsecured, subordinate to the claims of all creditors, and containing a provision for interest payments by the corporation at its option,
*595 The Commissioner has determined a deficiency of $ 7,491.10 in petitioner's income tax and of $ 1,417.13 in its declared value excess profits tax for the year 1939.
The sole issue before us for determination is whether certain payments made by petitioner during the taxable year 1939 to the holders of its "series A debenture bonds" constitute dividends on stock which were not deductible from gross income, as determined*250 by respondent, or whether they constitute payments of interest within the meaning of
Two other issues raised by the pleadings have been agreed upon and settled by the parties and will be given effect under Rule 50.
Some of the facts have been stipulated by the parties and are found accordingly. Other material facts are found from the evidence.
FINDINGS OF FACT.
The petitioner, Charles L. Huisking & Co., was incorporated under the laws of the State of New York in August 1927, under the name of *596 Five Platt Street Corporation. Its purposes were manufacturing, importing, purchasing, selling, and dealing in, as principal or agent, upon commission or otherwise, drugs, medicines, chemicals, oils, and general merchandise. Petitioner kept its books on the accrual basis of accounting and filed its tax returns for the year 1939 with the collector for the second district of New York.
Charles L. Huisking had started a similar business in 1910, which he operated as proprietor until 1917. In that year the business was incorporated under the laws of New York, with the corporate title of Charles L. Huisking, Inc.
*251 On August 29, 1927, the petitioner was incorporated as Five Platt Street Corporation, pursuant to a plan sponsored by Huisking. Its business purposes were as above described.
All of the stockholders of Charles L. Huisking, Inc., assigned and transferred their stock to the Five Platt Street Corporation and received therefor one share of its stock and a debenture bond, series A, having a face amount of $ 100 for each share so transferred. The shares issued by the Five Platt Street Corporation were without par value.
The holders of debenture bonds and the stockholders of Five Platt Street Corporation on or about October 6, 1927, were as follows:
| Name | Shares | Debenture |
| bonds | ||
| Charles L. Huisking | 2,929 | $ 292,900 |
| Catherine F. Huisking | 1,580 1/2 | 158,050 |
| George P. Huisking | 306 1/2 | 30,650 |
| Joseph A. Huisking | 300 | 30,000 |
| Peter A. Dirr | 300 | 30,000 |
| William J. Dawson | 60 | 6,000 |
| Kurt J. Kohler | 25 | 2,500 |
| John J. Lantz | 18 | $ 1,800 |
| George W. La Cour | 9 | 900 |
| William E. Martin | 9 | 900 |
| Cyril F. Mathias | 14 | 1,400 |
| Total | 5,551 | 555,100 |
The debenture bonds issued by the petitioner contained a definite promise to pay a specified principal*252 sum on a fixed and certain maturity date in 1950, and provided for the payment of interest until the principal was paid, at the rate of 6 percent per annum on specified semiannual dates. The rights of the bondholders, however, were set forth with particularity and the debentures contained, among other provisions, the following:
1. This debenture is subject in all respects and subordinate to the claims of all creditors of the Corporation, and upon the dissolution or liquidation of the Corporation no payment shall be due or payable on this debenture unless and until all other creditors of the Corporation shall have been paid in full, or the amount of any disputed claim has been duly bonded.
2. Interest on the debentures of this series may, at the option of the Corporation, be deferred or suspended without limit of time, and may be paid or unpaid and/or, at the option of the Corporation, in whole or in part.
3. The debentures of this series are subject to redemption at par and accrued interest, if any is authorized by the Board of Directors, to be paid on any *597 interest date in whole or in part, pro rata at any time on thirty days prior notice given to the registered holders*253 in such manner as the Board of Directors may by resolution authorize, and after the date fixed in such notice of redemption, interest, if any authorized, shall cease.
* * * *
5. No holder of this debenture shall have any right to institute any suit, action or proceeding in equity or at law upon this debenture unless the holders of sixty percent in amount of all debentures of all series voluntarily consent and join in such suit, action or proceeding.
Under its certificate of incorporation the Five Platt Street Corporation was authorized to issue a total of 7,500 shares of stock, all of one class and without par value, and to issue notes, bonds, and debentures, and other obligations.
On November 3, 1927, by a certificate which was in conformity with the requirements of law of the State of New York, the Five Platt Street Corporation duly merged with it the corporation known as Charles L. Huisking, Inc., and, on November 25, 1927, by appropriate certificate the name was changed to "Charles L. Huisking & Co., Inc.," which is the present name of the petitioner.
At the time the corporate reorganization was consummated the total assets of Charles L. Huisking, Inc., as shown by its balance*254 sheet, were $ 860,152.47, with liabilities listed in the sum of $ 198,155.57, plus outstanding common stock at an aggregate par value of $ 555,100, and a surplus of $ 106,896.90.
By an appropriate certificate which was executed on August 23, 1935, the authorized capital stock of the petitioner corporation was reduced from 7,500 shares without par value to 100 shares having a par value of $ 100 per share. Thereafter the outstanding capital stock of petitioner, consisting of 5,081 shares without par value, was surrendered to the company for cancellation, in exchange for which petitioner issued one share of the new par value $ 100 stock for every 60 shares of its previously authorized stock. At that time the stockholders and their respective interests were as follows:
| Shares | |
| Huisking Investments, Inc | 4,509 1/2 |
| Joseph A. Huisking | 300 |
| Peter A. Dirr | 211 1/2 |
| William J. Dawson | 60 |
| 5,081 |
Huisking Investments, Inc., was a family holding company, all of its capital stock being owned by Charles L. Huisking, his wife, and their children. Charles L. Huisking, the founder and president of the petitioner corporation, owned all of the voting stock of Huisking Investments, *255 Inc.
Petitioner has paid the several bondholders the sums called for as interest on all of its issued and outstanding debenture bonds, with *598 the exception of a nine-month period in 1931. In the years 1934, 1935, and 1938 payments were made even though the corporation's net income was of a lesser amount than required for the interest payments. In 1931 petitioner suffered a loss of approximately $ 192,000 and the bondholders agreed to waive "interest" for the last nine months of that year. At the same time Huisking agreed to surrender for cancellation, without further consideration, $ 150,000 in petitioner's debenture bonds.
In 1939 the outstanding debenture bonds of the petitioner amounted to $ 357,150 and were owned as follows:
| Huisking Investments, Inc | $ 300,000 |
| Joseph A. Huisking | 30,000 |
| Peter A. Dirr | 21,150 |
| William J. Dawson | 6,000 |
Joseph A. Huisking, a brother of Charles L. Huisking, was secretary of the petitioner corporation. William J. Dawson was treasurer of the petitioner corporation, having been associated with Charles L. Huisking since 1915. Peter A. Dirr was also a "key man" of the petitioner corporation, being in the purchasing and selling end *256 of the business, and he had been with Charles L. Huisking since 1911.
The bonds held by Joseph A. Huisking in the principal sum of $ 30,000 were redeemed by petitioner on June 15, 1939, at par, plus accrued interest at the date of redemption.
A dividend of $ 13,118.75 was paid to the stockholders in 1939 and a dividend of $ 12,000 was paid in 1941. In 1941 Peter Dirr and William J. Dawson sold their stock to the petitioner corporation for $ 650 per share and purchased petitioner's debenture bonds with all or part of the proceeds.
During the taxable year 1939 petitioner paid the sum of $ 20,454 to the holders of its debentures and deducted that amount on its income tax return for that year as interest paid on indebtedness. The respondent disallowed the deduction.
OPINION.
The only issue before us is whether petitioner's payments to the holders of its debenture bonds were payments of interest on an indebtedness within the meaning of
As we said in
The instrument has been designated a "debenture bond" and the payments thereunder have been called "interest." While the name given by the parties may not be lightly disregarded,
The fundamental basis for our conclusion that these securities are more nearly like preferred stock than indebtedness is the fact that the debentures are unsecured and are subordinated to the claims of all creditors of the petitioner and the payment of interest is not absolute.
Indeed, the instrument provides that interest may be "paid or unpaid" at the option of petitioner. This alone is sufficient to distinguish the instant case from
Nor is any significance to be attached to the fact that the debenture holders had no voting right, for that again is quite characteristic of preferred shares. See
The circumstances under which the debentures in question were issued make it clear that their terms were dictated by Huisking and not arrived at by negotiation between the so-called debtor and creditors. No new capital came into the corporation by reason of this financing, and, while there may have been the interest of certain key men to be considered in the plan as undertaken, their interest was small compared with that of Huisking and*261 his family.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.