Smith v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
4 later published cases cite this decision.
- Armour v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1946)
- Lawrence v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1957)
- W. D. Haden Co. v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1946)
- Armour v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1946)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*288
Petitioners, executors and residuary legatees of their father's estate, distributed to themselves as residuary legatees the assets of the estate on December 31, 1937, without settlement of certain gift and estate taxes due by the estate to the United States. Thereafter, petitioners paid these deficiencies, together with interest thereon.
*256 These cases, consolidated for hearing and disposition, involve income tax deficiencies for 1940 in the original*289 amounts of $ 6,151.68 and $ 5,995.36, respectively.
By virtue of stipulations by and between the parties, all matters have been settled except that part of the deficiencies attributable to deductions taken in the returns of the two petitioners in respect of certain interest items, paid by each, upon tax deficiencies assessed against their father's estate, of which they were executors.
FINDINGS OF FACT.
The facts have been stipulated and are found accordingly. In so far as they are pertinent to the consideration of the sole question here, they are as follows:
Petitioners are sons of the late Arthur G. Smith of Poughkeepsie, New York, who died testate May 6, 1936. Each of them filed a return for 1940 with the collector for the fourteenth district, at Albany, New York.
Under the terms of their father's will, the two sons were named as executors and residuary legatees of the estate. They qualified and entered upon their duties as executors on May 11, 1936. Assets of the estate were received and collected, specific legacies were delivered and paid, and the debts of the estate and costs of administration, so far as known and determined, were paid. On December 31, 1937, they transferred*290 the remaining assets of the estate to themselves as residuary legatees. At that time the Federal estate tax return filed for the estate had not been audited. In considering the propriety of transferring the assets to themselves the petitioners were informed by their legal adviser that he had reason to believe that the Bureau of Internal Revenue was contemplating making claim against the estate in respect of certain alleged gifts made by the decedent during his lifetime. The petitioners decided that if a deficiency in tax arose against the estate, together with penalties and interest, they would pay it themselves, one-half each.
Thereafter, a deficiency in gift tax was asserted by the Commissioner in the amount of $ 82,110.20. In addition thereto a proposed deficiency in estate tax was under consideration by the Bureau of Internal Revenue in the pre-90-day stage. The executors took the gift tax deficiency to the Board of Tax Appeals. After certain deliberations an agreement was reached whereby it was stipulated that there *257 was a deficiency in gift tax in the amount of $ 27,472.50 and a deficiency in estate tax amounting to $ 82,527.50. Hence, all matters in controversy*291 relative to Federal taxes were settled.
The two items in tax were paid in 1940, each petitioner paying one-half, of which $ 9,159.74 was interest paid by each. Of the interest paid by each, $ 2,476.16 accrued prior to December 31, 1937, the date of the distribution of the estate assets by the executors to themselves.
Since the probate of the will and the qualification of the executors, no accounting of any kind has been filed with the surrogate's court having jurisdiction, nor any orders taken in respect of distribution or disbursement of the estate's assets. The estate has not been closed, nor the executors discharged by any decree of judicial settlement.
In his income tax return for 1940 each petitioner claimed the full amount paid by him as interest on the deficiencies in estate and gift taxes assessed against their father's estate as proper items for deduction from taxable income. On brief, however, petitioners concede that they are not entitled to a deduction for that portion of the interest which accrued prior to December 31, 1937. The respondent disallowed the claimed deductions in their entirety.
OPINION.
The sole issue is whether the petitioners are entitled to a deduction*292 from their gross income for the amount of interest which accrued on the estate and gift tax deficiencies after distribution of the remaining assets of the estate to themselves. The applicable statute is
Much has been written with respect to the deductibility of interest payments of the character here considered and the law is not settled. Various cases posing different factual situations, but a common question, are directly in point. Since the decision in
We are of the opinion that we should adhere to our established view that the interest on the deficiencies for the period after the petitioners received the assets of the estate was paid
Adjustments provided for in the stipulation, as well as that necessitated by this determination, will be made under a Rule 50 computation.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.