Cobb v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
9 later published cases cite this decision.
- Epp v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1982)
- Luman v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1982)
- Merians v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1973)
- Statler v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1956)
- Steckel v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1956)
- Gran v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1980)
- Morgan v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1978)
- Estate of Steckel v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1956)
- Lykes v. United States (United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida 1949)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*257
Taxpayer in 1941 made certain gifts, thereafter filed a gift tax return, and paid the tax as disclosed by the return. In 1942 he was notified that a proposed adjustment would result in a gift tax deficiency of $ 13,840.52. Thereupon taxpayer employed attorneys, upon whose advice a protest was filed. Upon receipt of notice of deficiency a proceeding was brought in this Court. Thereafter, pursuant to settlement, taxpayer paid a deficiency of $ 6,000 in gift tax, together with interest of $ 643.80. In 1944 he paid his attorneys for their services $ 2,260.
*381 The Commissioner determined a deficiency of $ 360.32 in income tax for the year 1944. The only issue to be determined is whether attorneys' fees in the amount of $ 2,260 are deductible under
FINDINGS OF FACT.
Most of the facts were stipulated and are found by us to be as stipulated. Those material to the issue are as follows:
The petitioner resides in Cleveland, Ohio, and filed his income tax return for 1944 on January 15, *259 1945, with the collector for the eighteenth district of Ohio, at Cleveland. During 1944 petitioner was employed as general counsel by the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co. and received $ 10,416 as compensation for his services rendered in that year. In addition to his salary the petitioner received in 1944 net income of $ 16,380.32 from real estate rentals and $ 10,790.25 from dividends and interest.
Prior to December 1, 1941, the petitioner owned an undivided one-half interest in a certain parcel of real estate located at 234-236 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio. On or about December 1, 1941, petitioner delivered to each of his four daughters a deed of gift transferring to each of them an undivided one-twelfth interest in fee simple of such real estate.
The petitioner filed a gift tax return for 1941 in which he listed such gifts to his daughters and other gifts, and paid a gift tax of $ 18,943.65 with the return.
Thereafter, on July 29, 1942, the internal revenue agent in charge in Cleveland sent a letter to petitioner proposing an adjustment of his 1941 gift tax liability which would result in a gift tax deficiency of $ 13,840.52.
On or about August 6, 1942, petitioner employed*260 reputable attorneys to advise him as to the merits of the proposed adjustment and to protect his interests in the matter. The attorneys prepared and filed on petitioner's behalf a protest against the proposed adjustment. By an appropriate notice, dated November 23, 1942, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue notified petitioner that a determination of his gift tax liability for 1941 disclosed a deficiency of $ 13,840.52. At petitioner's request his attorneys prepared and filed in the Tax Court of the United States a petition for redetermination of such deficiency. After petitioner's attorneys had prepared for trial before the Tax Court, a settlement was reached and on December 14, *382 1943, the Tax Court, pursuant to stipulation of the parties, found a deficiency in such gift tax in the amount of $ 6,000. On or about December 29, 1943, petitioner paid such deficiency, together with interest of $ 643.80.
On January 12, 1944, petitioner paid his attorneys the sum of $ 2,260 as fees for their advice and services as attorneys in connection with such gift tax dispute, which amount was reasonable for the services rendered.
The record discloses the following additional facts:
The*261 petitioner's books were kept and his 1944 return was made on a cash receipts and disbursements basis.
Petitioner's income in 1940 was more than $ 51,000. In 1940 the Euclid Avenue property yielded rent to petitioner of approximately $ 20,000. In 1941 the property was occupied for the whole year and petitioner's share of the rental was $ 33,500. In 1940 petitioner was constructing a building on other property he owned, which was leased subsequently to Marshall Drug Co. The indications were that his annual income would increase considerably over the amount received in 1940.
In order to aid his daughters and their families fiancially and to reduce his income taxes, petitioner made the above mentioned gifts to his daughters.
Prior to making the gifts he consulted with one of his attorneys especially experienced in valuation matters with respect to the value of the four one-twelfth interests in the Euclid Avenue property to be reported in his gift tax return.
In order to pay the 1941 gift tax deficiency of $ 6,000, the petitioner sold at a loss income-producing securities. If petitioner had been required to pay the original deficiency claimed, it would have been necessary for him *262 to sell additional income-producing securities.
OPINION.
The sole question presented herein is whether petitioner may deduct from gross income the amount of attorneys' fees paid by him in the taxable year in connection with litigation arising out of a dispute with regard to Federal gift taxes under the facts detailed in our findings. Petitioner contends that they are deductible under the provisions of
*263 It has been held that when expenses have been incurred by reason of contesting income taxes, and these taxes were a proximate result of the holding of property for the production of income, then such expenses are deductible under
In our opinion such expenses can not be deducted. They are not expenses directly connected with or proximately resulting from the production or collection of income, as it might be said concerning expenses incident to disputes involving income tax liability. Cf.
However, the contention is made that any liability of petitioner on account of gift taxes would result in a lien upon his income-producing property, that the payment of attorneys' fees in the gift tax litigation was necessary in order to protect the taxpayer's property *384 from such a lien, and that the satisfaction of the liability asserted on account*265 of gift taxes and the payment of expenses incurred in defending him against the assertion of that liability resulted in petitioner's being forced to sell a part of his income-producing property. Therefore, petitioner reasons, payment of these expenses was directly connected with the management and conservation of income-producing property.
This argument, to paraphrase our language in
As we said in
It should be noted that if petitioner's argument on this point had validity, then it would logically follow that the gift taxes themselves would be deductible, since it is the payment of these taxes that protects *385 petitioner's income-producing property from the lien which would encumber that property if they were not paid. In fact, it would be difficult, as we have already pointed out, to think of any claims made against a taxpayer owning property, or expenses incident to claims, the payment of which would not be deductible under such an argument. A construction of the statute reaching that result is unwarranted and is precluded by prior opinions of this Court.
We conclude that respondent's regulations upon this question, which have been quoted in the footnote,
Van Fossan,
We are not here concerned with expenses incurred in connection with the
It was stipulated by the parties that the amount of $ 2,260 was paid for advice and services of attorneys in connection with the gift tax dispute. The gifts had been completed and the fees were incurred only in connection with the amount of gift taxes due as a result of the completed gifts. In the
*386 The respondent concedes that under the regulations, as amended May 14, 1946, by
Although
* * * the sole purpose and object of the litigation and the proximate cause of the expenditure were to relieve the estate from the payment of the deficiency in income tax determined by the Commissioner, which was the subject matter of the litigation. The effort*271 of petitioners in seeking, through this litigation, to give such relief to the estate was, in our opinion, obviously a factor in the conservation, management, and maintenance of the property of that estate, concededly held for the production of income, since in resisting the imposition of the tax the trustees were performing the required duty of protecting and defending the trust property in their hands against any claim or lien for the tax. * * *
Such statement is equally applicable herein, where the subject of the litigation was a deficiency in gift tax determined by the Commissioner and the taxpayer is an individual instead of a testamentary trust. The difference in tax and taxpayer does not justify a different conclusion. Litigation expenses resulting from a dispute involving a deficiency in gift tax fall within the category of "ordinary and necessary expenses" deductible under
I am unable to agree with the majority's attempt to straight-jacket expenses of the type here involved and to narrow this relief provision (
It is my judgment that, so far as section 29.23 (a)-15 (
Footnotes
1.
SEC. 23 . DEDUCTIONS FROM GROSS INCOME.In computing net income there shall be allowed as deductions:
* * * *
(a) Expenses. --
* * * *
(2) Non-trade or non-business expenses. -- In the case of an individual, all the ordinary and necessary expenses paid or incurred during the taxable year for the production or collection of income, or for the management, conservation, or maintenance of property held for the production of income.↩
2. * * * Expenses paid or incurred by an individual in the determination of liability for taxes upon his income are deductible. If property is held by an individual for the production of income, amounts expended in determining a property tax imposed with respect to such property during the period when so held are deductible. Expenses paid or incurred by an individual in determining or contesting any liability asserted against him do not become deductible, however, by reason of the fact that property held by him for the production of income may be required to be used or sold for the purpose of satisfying such liability. Thus, expenses paid or incurred by an individual in the determination of gift tax liability, except to the extent that such expenses are allocable to interest on a refund of gift taxes, are not deductible, even though property held by him for the production of income must be sold to satisfy an assessment for such tax liability or even though, in the event of a claim for refund, the amount received will be held by him for the production of income.
* * * *↩
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.