Osenbach v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
22 later published cases cite this decision.
- Nahey v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1998)
- Rivers v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1968)
- Smith v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1967)
- Garrow v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1965)
- Lowe v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1965)
- Jones v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1963)
- McCullough v. Comm'r (United States Tax Court 1962)
- Estate of Goldstein v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1960)
- Chamberlin v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1959)
- Lentz v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1957)
- Wood v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1955)
- Bradford v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1954)
- Brian L. and Carole J. Nahey v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1998)
- Johnson v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1991)
- Sutphin v. United States (Court of Claims 1988)
- Westphal v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1984)
- Barr v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1980)
- Brown v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1969)
- Slater v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1964)
- McCullough v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1962)
- Anthony Campagna and Marie P. Campagna v. United States (2d Cir. 1961)
- Lentz v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1957)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*41
Petitioner, as stockholder in a corporation liquidating under the provisions of
*797 This case involves income tax liability for the calendar year 1944. The Commissioner determined a deficiency of $ 1,717.05, all of which is involved. The case was presented under Rule 30 of this Court's Rules of Practice on a stipulation of facts, including exhibits, without a hearing. The only issue presented is whether the petitioner received ordinary income, or on the other hand capital gain, from collections made upon certain loans and discounts, real estate mortgages, securities, life insurance policies, and*43 claims, received by him in liquidation of a corporation of which he was a stockholder, in connection with which liquidation the stockholders had filed election under
*798 FINDINGS OF FACT.
The stipulated facts are found as stipulated.
Petitioner is a promoter and is constantly on the lookout for businesses to purchase either to operate for a short time and sell out or to liquidate.
The American Bank & Trust Company of Richmond, Richmond, Virginia, a Virginia corporation, was incorporated in 1928 and conducted a banking business until it was placed in receivership on January 9, 1933, on which date its assets and affairs were turned over to receivers who gradually liquidated the assets until December 1, 1941.
Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, which had its principal office in Richmond, Virginia, was incorporated under the laws of the State of Virginia on December 1, 1941. The outstanding capital stock of this corporation consisted of 80 shares of common stock, without par value, of which 40 shares were acquired by Mace D. Osenbach, petitioner herein, for promotional services and 40 shares were acquired by Eugene Carbaugh, Jr., *44 of Newark, New Jersey, for promotional services.
The directors of Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, were:
Mace D. Osenbach
Eugene Carbaugh, Jr.
The officers of Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, were:
Mace D. Osenbach, President
Eugene Carbaugh, Jr., Vice President
While the Certificate of Incorporation of Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, gave, as is customary, broad general powers, the corporation was organized for the purpose of purchasing and collecting the assets of the American Bank & Trust Company of Richmond, and engaged in no other business or operation between the date of its incorporation and its dissolution.
Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, submitted a bid to the Circuit Court of the City of Richmond, Virginia, offering to purchase the remaining assets of the American Bank & Trust Company of Richmond, whereupon a decree was entered on October 16, 1941, and on December 1, 1941, a final decree was entered whereby the Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, purchased, with borrowed funds, the remaining assets of the American Bank & Trust Company of Richmond.
On November 29, 1944, the board of directors of Federal Service Bureau, *45 Incorporated, met and passed a resolution adopting a plan of liquidation. The resolution recited, in substance, that it was adopted pursuant to the provisions of
Pursuant to such plan Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, liquidated on December 1, 1944, all the corporation's assets being distributed to the stockholders pro rata in cancellation or redemption of all their stock.
The two stockholders and Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, filed elections and information returns on Forms 964 and 966, prescribed by the Treasury Department, within the provisions of
On December 1, 1944, the corporation had no accumulated earnings or profits, no cash, and no stock or securities acquired subsequent to December 10, 1943, except for 40 shares of Virginia-Georgia Realty Corporation stock which stock had a par market value at that time of $ 2 a share.
The assets distributed in liquidation on December 1, 1944, except as hereinafter indicated, consisted of loans and discounts, real estate mortgages, securities, life insurance policies and claims and other items. Such assets were of the fair market value of $ 157,374.03. During*47 1944 collections of $ 12,034.45 were made upon various items having a total cost of $ 4,588.59, leaving an amount realized of $ 7,445.86 in addition to items totaling $ 377.97, making a gross income from business of $ 7,823.83. Interest was paid on bank loans in the amount of $ 976.42, leaving net income of $ 6,847.41 which was distributed, equally between petitioner and Eugene Carbaugh, Jr., the petitioner receiving $ 3,423.71.
Petitioner and Eugene Carbaugh, Jr., continued collecting the former remaining assets of the American Bank & Trust Company during the period 1945 to 1950.
*800 The corporation income and declared value excess-profits tax returns of Federal Service Bureau, Inc., for the years ending September 30, 1943, and September 30, 1944, also ending November 30, 1944, recite that its business is "Purchasing Assets of closed banks for investment or sale."
In his individual income tax return for the calendar year 1944 the petitioner returned $ 3,374.60 under Schedule D "Gains and Losses From Sales or Exchanges of Capital Assets," of which $ 1,679.55 was reported as short term capital gains and $ 1,695.05 as long term capital gains. All of this income except $ 2,582.17*48 was identified as other than from assets received in liquidation of Federal Service Bureau, Inc. A schedule of assets acquired in liquidation of that company, showing amounts and fair market value, and collections, is attached to the return showing net collections of $ 5,084.33, plus an item of $ 80, fair market value of the 40 shares of Virginia-Georgia Realty Corporation stock received in liquidation, making a total of $ 5,164.33, which is shown to have been distributed to petitioner $ 2,582.17 and to Eugene Carbaugh $ 2,582.16. Petitioner included the $ 2,582.17 with other items to make a total of $ 3,390.09 long term capital gains and reported one-half thereof, that is, $ 1,695.05, which with the $ 1,679.55, above referred to, reported as short term capital gains makes the total $ 3,374.60 above referred to as reported as total capital gains.
In the determination of the deficiency the Commissioner in addition to other adjustments not in issue decreased petitioner's capital gains by $ 1,291.09 (one-half of the $ 2,582.17) and determined that he realized taxable gain of $ 3,423.71 "in the disposition of assets received upon liquidation of the Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated." *49 This with other adjustments not in issue resulted in the determination of deficiency of $ 1,717.05.
OPINION.
The amounts of income here involved were collections upon various items, loans, discounts, real estate mortgages, securities, life insurance policies, claims, and other items, distributed to the petitioner as a stockholder of Federal Service Bureau, Incorporated, in complete liquidation of that corporation. The liquidation was one of those covered by
The substance of the petitioner's contention is that, as indicated in the Senate Finance Committee Report when
We first examine the first contention, in substance, that the application of capital gain rates to the income involved requires, what is absent here, a sale or exchange. The petitioner, in effect, argues that the sale or exchange is furnished by the exchange of corporate stock for the assets distributed in liquidation. It is, of course, well settled, in fact by the statute, that such exchange of stock for liquidated assets is an exchange and a capital transaction.
The gist of the petitioner's argument is, as above seen, that the intent of
This conclusion makes it unnecessary for us also to consider the respondent's contention that the amounts received were ordinary income because the petitioner received them in the course of his regular business, that of a promoter seeking businesses to purchase, to operate*60 for a short time, or sell, or liquidate.
Turner,
To say that an exchange of corporate stock for assets in kind in a corporate liquidation is a closed transaction with respect to such assets as have a fair market value at the time of liquidation, but is not a closed transaction with respect to assets which at the time of liquidation do not have a fair market value, is, it seems to me, wholly artificial. The transaction is a closed and completed transaction in each instance. The erstwhile stockholder of the corporation, in each instance, has finally and completely disposed of his stock, has *61 received assets of the corporation in full and complete satisfaction therefor, and there is thereafter no obligation on the part of any one to pay or transfer to him anything further in payment or exchange for his stock. The transaction is just as much a closed transaction as if he had paid cash in full for the property, instead of stock.
Undoubtedly a major factor contributing to the erroneous decisions in the
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.