Oregon-Washington Plywood Co. v. Commissioner
Opinion
*91
Excess Profits Credit -- Borrowed Invested Capital. --
*816 The respondent has determined an excess profits tax deficiency of $ 19,925.35 against the petitioner for the calendar year 1944.
The issue presented is whether, in determining the excess profits credit based upon the invested capital method, the petitioner's obligation for the balance due under a contract for purchase and sale of timberlands and an alleged promissory note executed pursuant to that contract, constitutes an outstanding indebtedness evidenced by a note or mortgage which may be included in borrowed capital for *817 the years 1944 and 1945, within the meaning of
It is stipulated that, if the Court finds*92 for the petitioner on the issue involved, the amount claimed as representing 50 per cent of the average daily borrowed capital as set forth in each of the petitioner's excess profits tax returns for 1944 and 1945, respectively, is correct and there is no deficiency in excess profits tax for 1944. It is further stipulated that if the deficiency involved herein is sustained, it will result in an overassessment of $ 9,321.80 in income tax for the year 1944.
This proceeding has been submitted upon the pleadings and a stipulation of facts including numerous exhibits made a part thereof.
FINDINGS OF FACT.
The stipulated facts are so found and included herein by reference.
The petitioner is an Oregon corporation which, during the years material herein, was qualified to transact business in the State of Washington, as a foreign corporation. The petitioner's income and excess profits tax returns for the taxable years 1944 and 1945 were filed with the collector of internal revenue for the district of Washington.
At all times material to this proceeding the petitioner owned and operated a plywood manufacturing plant at Tacoma, Washington, and in that vicinity there was a scarcity of raw material, *93 namely, peeler logs.
On July 30, 1941, T. A. Peterman acquired title by deed to approximately 3,500 acres of timberland in Tillamook County, Oregon, and he had not conveyed or encumbered the same prior to the execution of a contract of purchase and sale dated August 30, 1943, hereinafter mentioned. That tract of timberland was cruised in December 1940 and January 1941 and the timber cruiser's report showed an estimated total of 109,528,000 feet of merchantable timber. The tract contained a large amount of dead timber which had been killed by a forest fire and the time for using the dead timber as peeler logs was limited. During 1943 and until November 16, 1944, T. A. Peterman, Katherine Peterman, and Gladys Peterman were partners doing business under the firm name of Peterman Manufacturing Company which owned a large amount of logging equipment and maintained a logging organization in the area of the above-mentioned tract of timberland. The petitioner had no logging equipment or facilities for logging timber.
On August 30, 1943, T. A. Peterman and his wife as owners and the petitioner as purchaser executed a contract of purchase and sale of the above-mentioned 3,500-acre tract*94 of timberland in Tillamook County, Oregon. The agreed purchase price was $ 500,000 payable *818 $ 25,000 on date of the contract, $ 75,000 on or before September 30, 1943, and the balance of $ 400,000 "evidenced by a note made payable" to Peterman Manufacturing Company and delivered thereto on or before September 30, 1943. Payments on the note, plus accrued interest at the rate of 3 per cent per annum on deferred balances, were due on the 15th day of each month beginning November 15, 1943, on the basis of $ 5 per thousand feet, commercial log scale, cut and removed by the purchaser during the previous month. If the purchaser defaulted in the monthly payments logging operations were to cease until the default was made good. The purchaser agreed,
The petitioner made the cash payments totaling $ 100,000 required by the contract of August 30, 1943, and on September 30, 1943, delivered the following note as provided in that contract:
Tacoma, Washington,
$ 400,000.00
As provided in an agreement dated August 30, 1943, the undersigned for value received promises to pay to the order of the Peterman Manufacturing Company the sum of Four Hundred Thousand Dollars ($ 400,000.00) in lawful money of the United States of America. Payments on this note plus accrued interest at the rate of 3% per annum on deferred balances shall be made on the 15th day of each month beginning November 15, 1943.
*819 The basis of such principal payments to be $ 5.00 per thousand feet commercial log scale for all logs except wood logs cut and removed by purchaser or its agents during the previous calendar month as provided in the agreement between T. A. Peterman and Ida C. Peterman, owners, and Oregon-Washington Plywood Company, purchaser, dated August 30, 1943, covering certain timber lands in Tillamook County, Oregon.
OREGON-WASHINGTON PLYWOOD COMPANY
By/S/Philip Garland
*97 Attest/S/Mathilda M. Barrett
On September 18, 1943, the Peterman Manufacturing Company executed a written agreement with the petitioner whereby for certain agreed prices to be paid by the petitioner, the former agreed,
On September 30, 1943, the Peterman Manufacturing Company executed an additional agreement with the petitioner to purchase at certain prices all logs cut other than the fir peeler logs and certain fir sawmill logs needed by the petitioner.
T. A. Peterman died on November 16, 1944. Thereafter the surviving partners, the decedent's wife and executors of the decedent's estate, desired to be relieved of the agreements mentioned in the next two preceding paragraphs as to logging operations and the purchase of logs, and they were terminated by a cancellation*98 agreement dated January 4, 1946, between the interested parties and the petitioner. Also, on January 4, 1946, the same interested parties and the petitioner executed an amendment to the above mentioned contract dated August 30, 1943, whereby,
*820 On January 4, 1946, the petitioner*99 entered into a contract with the firm of Yunker and Wiecks for the cutting of timber on the above-mentioned 3,500-acre tract.
The petitioner's records show that 90,933,000 feet of timber were logged from the land between August 30, 1943, and August 31, 1952. The petitioner's above mentioned note for $ 400,000 dated September 30, 1943, was paid in full sometime prior to December 22, 1949, on which date the petitioner acquired legal title to the 3,500-acre tract of timberland by warranty deed from the heirs of T. A. Peterman.
OPINION.
The issue presented is whether under the facts herein the petitioner had, during the years 1944 and 1945, an "outstanding indebtedness" which was "evidenced by" a "note" or "mortgage" within the meaning of
*100 The petitioner contends that, during 1944 and 1945, its obligation to pay the balance due on the agreed purchase price of timberland constituted an unconditional outstanding indebtedness which was evidenced by a promissory note secured by a land purchase contract which was a form of mortgage under the laws of Oregon. The petitioner further contends that title to the land was retained by the seller only as security and that, in Oregon, the land purchase contract created a lien on the property equivalent to the common form of mortgage.
The respondent contends that the transaction involved herein did not create an outstanding indebtedness evidenced by either a note or a mortgage within the meaning of
In each of the above cited cases the taxpayer's obligation to pay a sum of money was evidenced by a written contract. In the first two cited cases it was held that the contract did not constitute either a "mortgage" or a "note" and in the third cited case it was held that the contract did not constitute a "note" or otherwise qualify as evidence of indebtedness, within the intent of Congress in enacting
The concept of including in invested capital certain amounts of outstanding indebtedness as borrowed capital and the restricted character of the permissible evidence of such indebtedness which Congress has prescribed in
In the instant case the agreement of August 30, 1943, wherein the seller retained title to the land and standing timber thereon until payment in full of the agreed purchase*103 price by the petitioner, was a conditional land contract. The purchase price of $ 500,000 was payable $ 100,000 in cash and the balance during an indefinite period of time by monthly payments conditioned upon the quantity of timber cut and removed by the petitioner. In addition to the conditional monthly payments, there were numerous other conditions which the petitioner was required to meet in order to fulfill the terms of the contract. Default in any of those conditions gave the seller the option to declare the contract terminated and all payments forfeited as liquidated damages, or, declare the unpaid sums plus interest immediately due and payable and bring suit therefor. Under the contract the petitioner was obligated to pay the balance of the purchase price but that obligation was not unconditional for at any time a breach of the terms and the seller's election to terminate the contract would have relieved *822 the petitioner of any further liability. Even though the land contract may be the equivalent of a mortgage for certain remedial purposes under the laws of Oregon, as contended by the petitioner, the controlling fact here is that the contract was conditional and*104 therefore does not qualify as a "mortgage" within the meaning and for the purpose of
The petitioner further contends that even if the contract fails to qualify as a "mortgage," the instrument executed as a note pursuant to the contract is an entirely separate instrument which qualifies as a "note" under
We conclude that the petitioner's obligation during the years 1944 and 1945, under the instruments involved herein, was not an outstanding indebtedness evidenced by a note or mortgage within the meaning of
Footnotes
1.
SEC. 719 . BORROWED INVESTED CAPITAL.(a) Borrowed Capital. -- The borrowed capital for any day of any taxable year shall be determined as of the beginning of such day and shall be the sum of the following:
(1) The amount of the outstanding indebtedness (not including interest) of the taxpayer which is evidenced by a bond, note, bill of exchange, debenture, certificate of indebtedness, mortgage, or deed of trust, plus,
* * * *
(b) Borrowed Invested Capital. -- The borrowed invested capital for any day of any taxable year shall be determined as of the beginning of such day and shall be an amount equal to 50 per centum of the borrowed capital for such day.↩
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.