May v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- Newcombe v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1970)
- Mitchell v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1966)
- Hobson Motor Co. v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1990)
- Ray v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1989)
- Henry v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1983)
- Jackson v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1981)
- Clancy v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1978)
- Perry v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1977)
- Whitcomb v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1976)
- Beckjord v. Comm'r (United States Tax Court 1973)
- Opper v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1972)
- Schaevitz v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1971)
- John R. Carkhuff Et Ux. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (6th Cir. 1970)
- Cherry v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1967)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*212
Deductions -- Nonbusiness Expenses -- Depreciation. -- A large yacht,
*865 The Commissioner determined income tax deficiencies for the years 1952-1955 as follows: 1952, $ 45,931.93; 1953, $ 25,361.01; 1954, $ 75,569.08; 1955, $ 19,888.19. Petitioner's private yacht was sold in 1955. The issue is whether the yacht was "property held for the production of income" in the taxable years so that expenditures for conservation*214 and maintenance are deductible under
FINDINGS OF FACT.
The petitioner, a resident of the District of Columbia, filed her returns in Baltimore with the district director of internal revenue for the district of Maryland.
The stipulated facts are found as stipulated and are incorporated by reference.
The petitioner continuously owned a private yacht, the
The
The United States Navy leased the yacht in 1942, for a nominal rental, for convoy duty and weather patrol. It was returned to petitioner in 1944. It was conditioned for naval duty which included mounting guns on decks. Reconditioning and refurnishing the ship for private use was completed in 1948.
Clyde B. Ault, a marine engineer, supervised the construction of the yacht and has been employed by petitioner as the chief engineer at all times except during World War II.
Prior to World War II, the petitioner took a cruise around the world on the yacht. After the 1948 reconditioning, petitioner used the yacht for cruises to Bermuda, Palm Beach, and through the Caribbean. During August through November 1950, the yacht went on a Caribbean cruise. That*216 cruise was the last time the
Toward the end of the Caribbean cruise in 1950, Ault flew from the Dominican Republic to Washington for a conference with petitioner at which the future of the yacht was discussed. Petitioner then told Ault that she had decided to sell the
Early in 1951, petitioner offered the
The specifications and equipment of the
While devoted to the petitioner's use, the owner's quarters were furnished in the manner of a comfortable home. In the salon were a library and a marble fireplace. The living room was furnished richly in English style. The dining room was decorated like an old sailing ship with hand hewn oak beams, was furnished in walnut, and rare paintings of seascapes were hung on the walls. The owner's staterooms were furnished with French period furniture; the bath was of rose marble with gold-plated fixtures. Each guest stateroom was handsomely furnished, had an electric heat fireplace, and a tile bath.
The full crew of the
The decommissioning of the yacht which began in January 1951, involved the following: The rigging, sails, and upper yardarms were taken down; 30,000 square feet of sail and 9 miles of rope were stored in one of the forecastles; the deckhouses were covered with canvas for protection against the weather, heat, and humidity. All mirrors, paintings, and furniture were sprayed with protective preparations and covered with French cloth for protection against the humidity. All of the linens were laundered and put away in sealed packages. The stoves in the two galleys were dismantled; the cooking utensils were greased and put into lockers; the refrigerators were disassembled, *221 galvanized, and stored; the upper and lower decks were covered with canvas; the motorboats were disconnected; a coat of oil was put on the engines of the motor launches; the deck furniture was removed; the air-conditioning equipment was emptied and sealed; the radio antennas and radarscopes were taken down; all pumps and motors, except those needed to turn over the propellers, were disconnected; and the pumps and the boiler were blown out, cleaned, and sealed. The main generators remained in operating condition in order to turn over the propellers at 2-week intervals so that they would not remain set in one position. The tanks were emptied of all fuel oil except what was needed to run periodically the auxiliary engines to keep them from deteriorating. The oil was sold for $ 5,273, and no fuel oil was purchased thereafter for use in the main engines. The electrical elements, plates, switches, and other items subject to deterioration from moisture and humidity were taken out. This had never been done before during any period of layup.
From the time the
The yacht has a steel hull. Steel in salt water deteriorates rapidly below and above the waterline unless it is kept painted because salt water corrodes the steelplates and the salt air, humidity, and sun also corrode the steel. It was impossible to "moth-ball" the yacht completely. It was necessary to keep the yacht in salable condition. *869 During the period March 1951 to August 1955, necessary preservation work was done on the yacht for which it was moved by tugboats to drydocks, and men were hired from shipyards and elsewhere to do such necessary maintenance work as the four-man crew could not do.
During the years 1952-1955, petitioner warranted in applications for hull and machinery insurance that the yacht would remain laid up at a dock at the Jacksonville shipyard.
The layup of the
During 1952-1955, petitioner maintained residences in Washington, D.C., New York City, and Palm Beach, which is 250 miles from Jacksonville. *224 Petitioner visited the
Ault remained in charge of the
In 1954 the yacht was inspected by Lloyd's of London and received a 100-A-1 rating. In order to put the ship to sea in 1955 another and different inspection would have been required.
*870
Throughout each of the years 1951-1955, petitioner engaged various brokers and agents in New York, Texas, California, and elsewhere to find a buyer. The yacht was listed with several brokers for sale. These included John H. Wells, marine brokers in New York; Perry-Cox & Stevens, Inc., yacht brokers and designers in New York; Victor B. Bendix, Inc., a shipbroker in New York; John G. Alden, Inc., yacht brokers in Boston and New York; Philip L. Rhoades, a naval architect; George Michaud Co., yacht brokers in Los Angeles; Sparkman & Stevens, yacht and shipbrokers in New York; W. A. White, Jr.; and Mary Van Zandt-Williamson in Fort Worth. Petitioner's business manager, William R. Wood, corresponded with brokers. Photographs and description of the
In March 1951, petitioner received an offer*226 through John H. Wells to purchase the yacht for $ 450,000. It was made on behalf of Generalissimo Rafael L. Trujillo. The offer was rejected by petitioner after making an investigation of the required steps and the laws and regulations of the United States Government involved in order to consummate the sale of a yacht to a noncitizen of the United States.
In a letter dated September 13, 1951, addressed to Wood, petitioner (who was then Mrs. Joseph E. Davies) received a conditional offer of $ 1 million for the
During 1951 petitioner was advised that the best market for a luxury yacht was probably in England. On September 4, 1951, petitioner had a form for authorization of sale prepared, which was sent to representatives in England, which stated as follows, in part:
*871 We, the undersigned, hereby agree as follows, that: If, within six months from date (unless an extension hereof is hereafter agreed upon) you secure a purchaser for the barque, Sea Cloud, as described in the Lloyd's Registry of Yachts, and if a sale is completed to such purchaser within the above time, we will, from such consideration as is received, pay you for services as follows: 1. If the yacht is sold -- unfurnished -- for a sum not less than One Million Dollars ($ 1,000,000) a commission of five per cent will be paid to you from and as payment received. 2. If the yacht is sold -- furnished -- for a sum not less than One Million Two Hundred Thousand Dollars ($ 1,200,000), in addition to the commission of five per cent for the first million, a commission*228 will be paid to you as above of ten per cent on the Two Hundred Thousand Dollars ($ 200,000). 3. If the yacht is sold for any sum in excess of these amounts, a bonus of fifty per cent of such excess will be paid to you, in addition to the five per cent and ten per cent commissions on the first Million Two Hundred Thousand Dollars as aforesaid.
In 1952, 1953, and 1954, petitioner's business manager had correspondence and discussions with the brokers and individuals above mentioned, all of which related to persons or Governments who expressed an interest in buying the
The yacht was not offered for charter and no attempt was made to charter it in 1951-1955.
The yacht's original cost was not less than $ 1,225,000. The book value of its furnishings, supplied by petitioner, was $ 267,528 at the end of 1951. From 1946 through 1950, petitioner spent $ 3,145,188 to rehabilitate the yacht after its war service and for maintenance and operations, as follows: 1946, $ 1,144,431; 1947, $ 980,333; 1948, $ 455,214; 1949, $ 218,964; 1950, $ 346,246. In 1951 the total expenses were $ 73,047.
In 1952-1955, petitioner spent for the yacht's preservation and maintenance, including wages, laundry, insurance, fuel, wharfage, pilotage, towing, and sundries, as follows: 1952, $ 42,993.11; 1953, $ 44,935.38; 1954, $ 71,909.10; 1955, $ 40,677.50. It is stipulated that these amounts were ordinary and necessary in the event it is held that deductions are allowable. It is further stipulated that if it is held that depreciation deductions are allowable, the annual allowances are $ 42,857.14 for each year, 1952-1954, and $ 28,568.57 for 1955.
*872 The stipulated facts are*230 found as stipulated and are incorporated herein by this reference.
OPINION.
The petitioner contends that during 1951 she took affirmative action which converted the status of her yacht, the
In the event the petitioner's contention is sustained, it is agreed that the amounts of the deductions now claimed may be allowed. 1 No question is presented about the amounts of allowances for depreciation, and the respondent does not contend that the nature and amounts of the expenses were not ordinary and necessary.
*231 The claim for deductions for nonbusiness expenses is made under
Personal expenses are not deductible*232 and expenses incurred in maintaining and preserving property devoted to personal use fall within that class.
This case is unusual in *233 that the property involved is a yacht, and the yacht itself is unique. Another unusual aspect is that the petitioner contends that it was not feasible to charter (rent) the
Both parties rely on the regulations, as amended. Petitioner argues that subparagraph (h) of section 39.23(a)-15, Regulations 118, which first was promulgated as an amendment by
After
even though the taxpayer makes efforts to sell the property at a profit or to convert it to income-producing purposes, and even though the property is not occupied by the taxpayer as a residence unless prior to the time that such expenses are incurred the property has been rented
In
The petitioner places considerable stress upon the present wording of subparagraph (h), arguing that the "change in the regulations evidently left open in each case the question whether the facts therein indicated that the property was no longer held for use as a residence [personal use] but was held for the production of income*236 through rental, efforts to sell, or otherwise." She also contends that it is significant that no reference is made in the amendment of the regulations "to property which was not held for use as a residence but was held for the production of income by sale." Petitioner's arguments dealing with the amended regulations lead to her contentions that the
The petitioner's contentions are, first, with respect to the facts, that she permanently abandoned the
The respondent takes issue with the petitioner's chief fact contention about permanent abandonment in 1951, and he argues that if at any time from the date of the layup until the yacht was sold, the petitioner had decided to resume using it for personal purposes, she could have done so, in spite of the cost of returning the yacht to seagoing condition, the factor of cost not being a problem to the petitioner; *875 and that even if she had abandoned it for personal use, that fact is not sufficient under the statute because the yacht remained available for her personal use. With respect to the question of law, it is the respondent's position that there must be *238 an unmistakable conversion of property to income-producing purposes, that efforts to sell and offering for sale are not sufficient to appropriate property to the required status of property held for the production of income; and that this rule has been established in the
Neither party has cited any case having substantially similar facts, and we find none. This case is distinguishable on its facts from the leading cases cited above in that those cases involved residential*239 property, whereas here the property was designed for petitioner's pleasure and recreation; for entertainment, vacations, and travel; and, in a broad sense, it constituted a hobby. See the dissenting opinion of Judge Disney in the
*240 *876 The meaning of the term "income" in the phrase "held for the production of income" has been considered with some frequency, within the context of the facts of each case, and in the regulations. 5 See the
*241 The regulations (see footnotes 4 and 5) incorporate the language of the report of the Ways and Means Committee. The
In the matter of the alleged abandonment of all personal use of the
In
The mere abandonment of such use [as a personal residence] does not mean that thereafter the property was held for the production of income. But when efforts are made to rent the property as were made by petitioner herein, the property is then being held for the production of income and this may be so even though no income is in*243 fact received from the property, * * * and even though the property is at the same time offered for sale.
In the case of
The petitioner had the burden of proving that the respondent's determination was erroneous. She did not sustain that burden simply by showing that the
In explanation of the absence of making efforts to charter the yacht, Ault's testimony was that it was not feasible to offer it for charter or negotiate a charter party because the monthly charge for a charter would have been large and there was not a market therefor. However, it is admitted that petitioner did not *244 wish to charter the yacht, and it was not offered for charter in 1951 before the decommissioning, the taking down of the equipment, and the discharge of the full crew because of petitioner's disinclination to offer it for charter. Obviously, there would not have been as great cost to have prepared the yacht for charter late in 1950, after the cruise that year, or early in 1951, as there would have been after the ship was decommissioned and the crew dismissed, which Ault testified would have cost about $ 189,500, at least, after the ship had been decommissioned for 1 year.
Petitioner did not testify. The record does not show to what extent, if any, the fact that the yacht's furnishings consisted of petitioner's personal belongings entered into her lack of inclination to offer the
In each case, the question whether the statutory requirement is met depends upon the taxpayer's proof of conversion to income-producing uses. The test, "held for the production of income," is to be applied within the limitations of the related statutory restriction which denies the deduction of personal expenses. In this case, there is the unusual factor that the kind of property involved, a sea-going luxury yacht, required substantial maintenance expenses under all circumstances as long as it was owned by petitioner. Petitioner reduced the costs of holding the property by the steps taken in 1951 below the amount ordinarily*246 expended when the ship was laid up in between cruises, but that action did not serve to convert the property from personal and recreational property to property held for the production of income, even though a substantial amount of the petitioner's furnishings were removed in 1951 and succeeding years. Nor is the question whether the statutory test is met established solely by petitioner's intention to sell the property. Petitioner did not testify. Intent is a subjective matter. The record does not show why petitioner wanted to sell the
The respondent has conceded that payments to the Florida Unemployment Compensation Fund were taxes paid and, therefore, are deductible.
*248
Footnotes
1. The total amounts of the deductions claimed for the 4 taxable years are as follows:
↩ Year Maintenance Depreciation Total claimed expenses deductions 1952 $ 42,993.11 $ 42,857.14 $ 85,850.25 1953 44,935.38 42,857.14 87,792.52 1954 71,909.10 42,857.14 114,766.24 1955 40,677.65 28,568.37 69,246.02 Total 200,515.24 157,139.79 357,655.03 2.
Sec. 23(a)(2) . Non-trade or non-business expenses. -- In the case of an individual, all the ordinary and necessary expenses paid or incurred during the taxable year * * * for the management, conservation, or maintenance of property held for the production of income.Sec. 23(l) . Depreciation. -- A reasonable allowance for the exhaustion, wear and tear (* * *) --* * * *
(2) of property held for the production of income.↩
3. (h) Ordinary and necessary expenses paid or incurred in connection with the management, conservation, or maintenance of property held for use as a residence by the taxpayer are not deductible. However, ordinary and necessary expenses paid or incurred in connection with the management, conservation, or maintenance of property held by the taxpayer as rental property are deductible even though such property was formerly held by the taxpayer for use as a home.↩
4.
Sec. 1.212-1 Nontrade or Nonbusiness Expenses. -- * * ** * * *
(c) Expenses of carrying on transactions which do not constitute a trade or business of the taxpayer and are not carried on for the production or collection of income or for the management, conservation, or maintenance of property held for the production of income, but which are carried on primarily as a sport, hobby, or recreation are not allowable as nontrade or nonbusiness expenses.
The question whether or not a transaction is carried on primarily for the production of income or for the management, conservation, or maintenance of property held for the production or collection of income, rather than primarily as a sport, hobby, or recreation, is not to be determined solely from the intention of the taxpayer but rather from all the circumstances of the case. For example, consideration will be given to the record of prior gain or loss of the taxpayer in the activity, the relation between the type of activity and the principal occupation of the taxpayer, and the uses to which the property or what it produces is put by the taxpayer↩ . [The part in italics represents an addition to the regulations in the 1954 Code Income Tax Regulations, which was not in Regulations 118.]5.
Sec. 1.212-1 Nontrade or Nonbusiness Expenses. -- * * ** * * *
(b) The term "income" for the purpose of
section 212 includes not merely income of the taxable year but also income which the taxpayer has realized in a prior taxable year or may realize in subsequent taxable years; and is not confined to recurring income but applies as well to gains from the disposition of property. For example, if defaulted bonds, the interest from which if received would be includible in income, are purchased with the expectation of realizing capital gain on their resale, even though no current yield thereon is anticipated, ordinary and necessary expenses thereafter paid or incurred in connection with such bonds are deductible. Similarly, ordinary and necessary expenses paid or incurred in the management, conservation, or maintenance of a building devoted to rental purposes are deductible notwithstanding that there is actually no income therefrom in the taxable year, and regardless of the manner in which or the purpose for which the property in question was acquired. Expenses paid or incurred in managing, conserving, or maintaining property held for investment may be deductible undersection 212↩ even though the property is not currently productive and there is no likelihood that the property will be sold at a profit or will otherwise be productive of income and even though the property is held merely to minimize a loss with respect thereto.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.