Grumman Aircraft Engineering Corp. v. Renegotiation Board
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- Page-River-Curran v. Renegotiation Board (United States Tax Court 1971)
- Lykes Bros. Steamship Co. v. United States (Court of Claims 1972)
- Wells Marine, Inc. v. United States (Court of Claims 1982)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*143 Motion to strike paragraphs in a petition designed to show Renegotiation Board acted arbitrarily in determining excess profits and acted erroneously with respect to credit for State taxes is granted on the ground that this Court lacks jurisdiction to review the Board's proceedings and lacks jurisdiction to determine tax credits.
*153 OPINION
Respondent filed motion in this action to strike certain subparagraphs from the petition in which petitioner alleged facts designed to show that in the proceedings before the Renegotiation Board, respondent acted erroneously, arbitrarily, and capriciously, in determining that petitioner realized excessive profits in *144 the amount of $ 7,500,000 in 1965. Respondent's motion to strike these subparagraphs is based on the ground that this Court lacks jurisdiction to review the Board's administrative proceedings.
The said motion also moved to strike other paragraphs in which petitioner alleges the Board erred in adjusting its determination of excessive profits of $ 7,500,000 by a credit for State taxes measured by income. Respondent's motion to strike these subparagraphs is on the ground this Court lacks jurisdiction to determine tax credits.
Oral argument has been had on said motion and each party has filed written briefs in support of its position.
Petitioner's syllogistic reasoning in support of its right to plead the Board acted arbitrarily proceeds along these lines: (a) Under
A proceeding before the Tax Court to finally determine the amount, if any, of excessive profits shall not be treated as a proceeding to review the determination of the Board, but shall be treated as a proceeding de novo. For the purposes of this section the court shall have the same powers and duties, insofar as applicable in respect of the contractor, the subcontractor, the Board, and the Secretary, * * * as such court has under section * * * [secs. 1110, 1111, 1113, 1114, 1115(a), 1116, 1117(a), 1118, 1120, and 1121 of title 26] in the case of a proceeding*146 to redetermine a deficiency.
It should be stressed that the above statute provides the Tax Court in a renegotiation case has parallel "powers and duties" in respect of the contractor to those it possesses in a tax case in respect of a taxpayer *154 "
In general, a tax deficiency is the amount by which tax imposed by taxing statutes exceeds the amount shown as the tax on the taxpayer's return.
The doctrine of
Petitioner's argument would dispose completely of the prohibition in
The contractor's burden of proof is not the burden to overcome any presumption of correctness of the Board's order. It is the usual burden resting on one who files the action to go forward with the evidence to sustain his allegations by proof.
*155 In the other two subparagraphs in the petition assailed by respondent's motion petitioner alleges that the Board erred in its determination of the amount of its tax credit.
In determining the amount of excessive profits to be eliminated, proper*149 adjustment shall be made on account of the taxes measured by income, other than Federal taxes, which are attributable to the portion of the profits which are not excessive.
Respondent argues the Tax Court's jurisdiction is limited to the redetermination of the amount of excess profits and this does not include questions relating to the computation of tax credits to be employed in determining the amount of excessive profits to be eliminated.
Respondent is right.
We said in
The jurisdiction of this Court is limited to the redetermination*150 of excessive profits. Section 403(e) (1) and (2);
For the reasons stated above, respondent's motion has been granted.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.