Manfredonia v. Commissioner
Opinion
*137
*207 OPINION
On April 12, 1968, respondent mailed to petitioner a notice of deficiency for the taxable year ended December 31, 1964, determining a deficiency of $ 8,342.70 and an addition to tax under
On August *139 29, 1968, petitioner filed a petition with this Court which included an allegation that respondent erred in his determination of *208 deficiency for the taxable year 1964 and that the determination of additional income and of additional taxable income from the alleged partnership for the taxable year 1964 "is arbitrary and capricious" and without basis in law or foundation in fact. The only factual allegation with respect to the taxable year 1964 contained in the petition is that for that year "petitioner was not a member of a partnership with Patsy Colarusso, did not have a 50% interest therein or any other interest, did not operate card games nor receive income from the operation of card games and did not fail to report income therefrom on a return."
On October 25, 1968, respondent filed a motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction and to strike as to the taxable year 1964 on the ground that the petition was not timely filed. Petitioner filed objections to the granting of this motion on the ground that an interpretation of
We do not agree with petitioner that the pendency of a criminal action against a taxpayer for alleged violation of statutes imposing a related tax operates generally as a matter of law to extend the time provided in
*209 However, even if there might exist circumstances under which the time of a taxpayer to file a petition should be considered to be held in abeyance by the pendency of a criminal proceeding against him, such circumstances are not present in the instant case.
The facts here show that on November 10, 1966, petitioner was indicted on six counts, and Patsy P. Colarusso on four counts, of failure to pay tax imposed on wagers by section 4401 and occupational tax on persons engaged in receiving wagers imposed by section 4411, and failure to register*142 with the district of internal revenue while engaged in the business of receiving wagers. Both defendants pleaded not guilty, were tried and convicted on all counts. Judgment was filed in the U.S. District Court on June 22, 1967, and both defendants appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. On March 14, 1968, that court rendered its decision reversing the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York and remanding the case for entry of judgments of acquittal.
The docket entry of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York in the criminal case against petitioner and Patsy P. Colarusso, No. 66-Cr. 920, under date of April *143 4, 1968, is as follows:
BOTH DEFTS. Filed USCA Order & Opinion that the judgment of said Dist. Court be and it hereby is reversed and that the action be and it hereby is remanded for entry of judgments of acquittal in accordance with the opinion of this Court. -- Judgment entered -- Clerk 4-8-68
To hold that on April 12, 1968, when respondent mailed to petitioner a notice of deficiency in income tax for the taxable year 1964, the technical pendency of the criminal action against petitioner might cause it to be necessary for him to make statements in a petition filed in this Court which would tend to incriminate him with respect to that prosecution, "would be in extreme if not extravagant application of the
It is not amiss to note that there was no statement relating to the year 1964 made by petitioner in the petition he did file in this Court on August 29, 1968, which could in any way be considered to incriminate him in connection with an alleged failure to pay taxes imposed under sections 4401 and 4411, or to register with the district director of internal revenue as being engaged*144 in receiving wagers.
*210 An appropriate order will be entered granting respondent's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction and to strike as to the taxable year 1964.
Footnotes
1. All references are to the Internal Revenue Code of 1954.↩
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.