Godbehere v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Edwards v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1975)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*15
The petitioner had children by each of two prior marriages. In 1967, he paid $ 975 toward the support of his son by his first wife and $ 1,075 toward the support of his two sons by his second wife. Each of the children was in the custody of his mother for more than half of the year.
*349 OPINION
The respondent determined a deficiency of $ 404.11 in the petitioners' 1967 Federal income tax. The issue for decision is whether a father, who has children by two prior marriages, is entitled to the dependency deduction for such children under
All the facts have been stipulated, and those facts are so found.
The petitioners, Jewell D. and Leah M. Godbehere, are husband and wife, who maintained their residence in Tacoma, Wash., at the time of filing their petition*17 in this case. They filed their joint 1967 Federal income tax return with the district director of internal revenue for the district of Washington in Ogden, Utah. Mr. Godbehere will be referred to as the petitioner.
Prior to his present marriage, the petitioner was married and divorced twice. Of his first marriage, one son, Anthony, was born, and of his second marriage, two sons, David and Matthew, were born. Neither the decree of divorce between the petitioner and his first wife, nor that between the petitioner and his second wife, made any provision allocating the dependency deductions between the parents.
During 1967, each child lived either with his mother or with the petitioner, and each was in the custody of his mother for more than half of the year. In that year, the petitioner provided $ 975 for the support of Anthony and $ 1,075 for the combined support of David and Matthew. The petitioner claimed dependency deductions for each of the children on his 1967 Federal income tax return, and such deductions were disallowed by the respondent.
*350 Ordinarily, to be entitled to a dependency deduction for a child, the taxpayer must establish that he provided more than one-half*18 of the total support for the child.
(e) Support Test in Case of Child of Divorced Parents, Etc. -- (1) General rule. -- If -- (A) a child * * * receives over half of his support during the calendar year from his parents who are divorced * * *, and (B) such child is in the custody of one or both of his parents for more than one-half of the calendar year, such child shall be treated * * * as receiving over half of his support during the calendar year from the parent having custody for a greater portion of the calendar year unless he is treated, under the provisions of paragraph (2), as having received over half of his support * * * from the other parent (referred to in this subsection as the parent not having custody). (2) Special rule -- The child of parents described in paragraph (1) shall be treated as having received over half of his support during the calendar year from the parent not having custody if -- * * * * (B)(i) *19 the parent not having custody provides $ 1,200 or more for the support of such child (or if there is more than one such child, $ 1,200 or more for all of such children) for the calendar year, and (ii) the parent having custody of such child does not clearly establish that he provided more for the support of such child during the calendar year than the parent not having custody.
The legislative history is not directly helpful in deciding this issue. H. Rept. No. 102, to accompany H.R. 6056 (Pub. L. 90-78), 90th Cong., 1st Sess., p. 2-3 (1967). There is no indication that Congress considered how the rules should be applied when the taxpayer has been involved in two*20 prior marriages. Similarly, the respondent's regulations take no position with respect to this issue. See
Although the statute does not provide a clear answer, it seems to indicate that the $ 1,200 rule is to be applied only when that amount *351 is provided for the support of each family. To determine whether
It also seems more reasonable to apply
For these reasons, we hold that
Footnotes
1. All statutory references are to the Internal Revenue Code of 1954.↩
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.