Hirshfield v. Commissioner
Opinion
*160
The corporations of which petitioners are transferees were classified as personal holding companies under provisions of the Internal Revenue Code added by the Revenue Act of 1964. Sec. 225(h)(1) of the Act permitted a corporation which was classified as a personal holding company under the broader definitions of the new provisions to avoid taxation as a personal holding company by liquidating.
*104 OPINION
Respondent determined deficiencies in income tax of Jacrob Realty Corp. (Jacrob) for the taxable periods ending August 31, 1965, August 31, 1966, and December 31, 1966, in the amounts of $ 37,793.72, $ 116,319.01, and $ 27,781.83, respectively. Respondent also determined deficiencies in income tax of Anco, Inc. (Anco), for the taxable periods ending September 30, 1965, September 30, 1966, and December 31, 1966, in the amounts of $ 41,911.10, $ 180,876.88, and $ 80,421.85, respectively. Respondent determined that petitioners were liable as transferees for these deficiencies. Petitioners concede they are transferees within the meaning of
The sole issue for decision is the date on which the transferor corporations were required to liquidate in order to avoid taxation as personal holding companies.
All of the facts have been stipulated and are incorporated herein along with accompanying exhibits.
Petitioner in docket Nos. 7235-71 and 7238-71, Jack Hirshfield, was a resident of New Haven, Conn., at the time the petitions in these cases were filed. Petitioner in docket Nos. 7236-71 and 7237-71, Robert L. Hirshfield, was a resident of New York, N.Y., at the time the petitions in these cases were filed. 3
*163 Jacrob, transferor in docket Nos. 7235-71 and 7237-71, was incorporated under the laws of the State of New Jersey. It filed its corporate income tax returns for the years in issue with the District Director of Internal Revenue, Newark, N.J. On November 30, 1966, petitioners, the two equal shareholders of Jacrob, resolved to liquidate the corporation. Certified resolutions and the appropriate internal revenue liquidation forms were filed with the District Director of Internal Revenue, Newark, N.J., on December 1, 1966. On the same date, petitioners also elected shareholder treatment under
Anco, the transferor in docket Nos. 7236-71 and 7238-71, was incorporated under the laws of the State of North Carolina. It filed its corporate income tax returns for the years ending September 30, 1965, and September 30, 1966, with the District Director of Internal Revenue, Greensboro, N.C., and for the period ending December 31, 1966, with the Internal Revenue Southeast Service Center. On November 30, 1966, petitioners, the two equal shareholders of Anco, *164 likewise resolved to liquidate this corporation, and filed certified resolutions and the appropriate internal revenue liquidation and shareholder election forms with the District Director of Internal Revenue, Greensboro, N.C., on December 1, 1966. All of the corporate assets and liabilities of Anco were distributed equally to the shareholders.
Jacrob and Anco were subsequently dissolved under the respective laws of the States of New Jersey and North Carolina.
Section 225(a) through (d) of the Revenue Act of 1964 4 expanded the class of corporations which are characterized as personal holding companies. Pursuant to these amendments, many corporations which were not previously classified as personal holding companies were subjected to the personal holding company provisions of the Internal Revenue Code. In order to ameliorate the impact of the new provisions on corporations and shareholders of corporations not formerly subject to the personal holding company provisions, and to facilitate liquidation of these corporations to avoid the impact of the new provisions, Congress included two distinct relief measures. The first relief measure, section 225(h)(1) provides that, in the case*165 of corporations newly subjected to the personal holding company act, the new provisions "shall not apply if there is a complete liquidation of such corporation and if the distribution of all the property under such liquidation occurs before
*166 The
*167 Petitioners argue that we should read both section 225(h), providing relief at the
Unfortunately petitioners have confused the two provisions designed to ameliorate*168 the effect of the broader personal holding company definitions added to the Code by the Revenue Act of 1964. Section 225(h)(1), which governs this case, was aimed at
Since the deficiencies asserted here are based on taxation as a personal holding company rather than on the tax consequences of a liquidating distribution from a personal holding company, petitioners' reliance on section 225(g) is misplaced. The pertinent section of the Revenue Act of 1964 is section 225(h) and the applicable date is clearly January 1, 1966. Since neither of the transferor corporations liquidated before January 1, 1966, both were subject to tax as personal holding companies. *108 Consequently, *169 petitioners are liable as transferees for the deficiencies here determined.
Footnotes
1. The following cases are consolidated herewith: Robert L. Hirshfield, Transferee (Anco, Inc., Transferor), docket No. 7236-71; Robert L. Hirshfield, Transferee (Jacrob Realty Corp., Transferor), docket No. 7237-71; Jack Hirshfield, Transferee (Anco, Inc., Transferor), docket No. 7238-71.↩
2. The Internal Revenue Code of 1954 will hereinafter be referred to as the Code.↩
3. Jack Hirshfield and Robert L. Hirshfield will hereinafter be referred to as petitioners.↩
4. Pub. L. 88-272, 78 Stat. 19 (Feb. 26, 1964). Unless otherwise indicated, all section references are to the Revenue Act of 1964.↩
5. Sec. 225(h)(1) provides in full:
SEC. 225. PERSONAL HOLDING COMPANIES.
(h) Exception for Certain Corporations. --
(1) General rule. -- Except as provided in paragraph (2), in the case of a corporation referred to in
section 333(g)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954 (as added by subsection (g) of this section), the amendments made by this section (other than subsections (f) and (g)) shall not applyif there is a complete liquidation of such corporation and if the distribution of all the property under such liquidation occurs beforeJanuary 1, 1966 . [Emphasis added.]SEC. 333 . ELECTION AS TO RECOGNITION OF GAIN IN CERTAIN LIQUIDATIONS.(q) Special Rule --
* * *
(3) Corporations referred to. -- * * * [A] corporation referred to in this paragraph is a corporation which for at least one of the two most recent taxable years ending before the date of the enactment of this subsection was not a personal holding company under section 542, but would have been a personal holding company under section 542 for such taxable year if the law applicable for the first taxable year beginning after December 31, 1963, had been applicable to such taxable year.↩
6. The relevant language of
sec. 333(g) of the Code provides:(g) Special Rule. --
(1) Liquidations before January 1, 1967. -- In the case of a liquidation occurring before January 1, 1967, of a corporation referred to in paragraph (3) --
(A) the date "December 31, 1953" referred to in subsections (e)(2) and (f)(1) shall be treated as if such date were "December 31, 1962", and
(B) in the case of stock in such corporation held for more than 6 months, the term "a dividend" as used in subsection (e)(1) shall be treated as if such term were "long-term capital gain".
Subparagraph (B) shall not apply to any earnings and profits to which the corporation succeeds after December 31, 1963, pursuant to any corporate reorganization or pursuant to any liquidation to which section 332 applies, except earnings and profits which on December 31, 1963, constituted earnings and profits of a corporation referred to in paragraph (3), and except earnings and profits which were earned after such date by a corporation referred to in paragraph (3).
* * *
(3) Corporations referred to. -- For purposes of paragraphs (1) and (2), a corporation referred to in this paragraph is a corporation which for at least one of the two most recent taxable years ending before the date of the enactment of this subsection was not a personal holding company under section 542, but would have been a personal holding company under section 542 for such taxable year if the law applicable for the first taxable year beginning after December 31, 1963, had been applicable to such taxable year.↩
7. Petitioners contend that the Senate amended the House bill to extend the Jan. 1, 1966, date specified in sec. 225(h) to Jan. 1, 1967, and that the House receded in the Senate amendment. Again, the amendment petitioners refer to related only to sec. 225(g), providing shareholder relief. The provisions reflected in sec. 225(h), dealing with
corporations↩ , were identical in both the House and Senate passed bills. Compare sec. 216(h) of H.R. 8363 (p. 142 of the House passed bill) with sec. 226(h) (p. 198 of the Senate passed bill.) See also Conf. Rept. No. 1149, 88th Cong., 2d Sess., p. 44 (1964).
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.