Cameron v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Schaefer v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1983)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*60
Petitioners received family allowance distributions from their father's estate for the years in issue. The estate had distributable net income in excess of all estate distributions for those years. Petitioners failed to include the distributions in gross income.
*745 OPINION
The Commissioner determined the following deficiencies in the petitioners' income taxes:
| Taxable | ||
| Petitioner | year | Deficiency |
| Scott D. Cameron | 1967 | $ 8,554.74 |
| 1968 | 14,868.89 | |
| Catherine C. Cameron | 1967 | 5,260.00 |
| 1968 | 2,113.45 | |
| Arthur A. Cameron, Jr. | 1967 | 8,802.21 |
| 1968 | 335.00 |
These cases were fully stipulated pursuant to
The only issue to be decided is whether the petitioners must include in gross income under
At the time of the filing of the petition in docket No. 2194-75, petitioner Scott D. Cameron resided in Los Angeles, Calif., and filed his 1967 and 1968 Federal income tax returns with the Internal Revenue Service Center at Fresno, Calif. At the time of the filing of the petition in*63 docket No. 2195-75, petitioner Catherine C. Cameron resided in Rockport, Maine. She filed no Federal income tax returns for the periods involved in her petition, taxable years 1967 and 1968. Finally, petitioner Arthur A. Cameron, Jr., resided in Pittsboro, N.C., when he filed the petition in docket No. 2196-75. His Federal *746 income tax return for 1967 was filed with the Internal Revenue Service Center at Fresno, Calif.; he filed no return for 1968.
The petitioners are all children of Arthur A. Cameron, who died on March 1, 1967. During the taxable years in question, each petitioner was a minor, and the Estate of Arthur A. Cameron, deceased (estate), was properly probated before the Superior Court of the State of California for the County of Los Angeles (Probate Court) under the laws of the State of California. At various times during 1967 and 1968, the Probate Court ordered the estate to pay to the guardians of each of the decedent's minor children various monthly and lump sum amounts "for the support and maintenance of said minor(s)." Pursuant to those orders, the following amounts were received on behalf of the petitioners by their guardians: the guardian for petitioner*64 Scott D. Cameron received $ 24,750 in 1967 and $ 33,000 in 1968; the guardian for petitioner Catherine C. Cameron received $ 19,800 in 1967 and $ 10,800 in 1968; and the guardian for Arthur A. Cameron, Jr., received $ 26,100 in 1967 and $ 2,900 in 1968. During those taxable years, the estate had distributable net income (DNI), as defined in section 643, in excess of the amounts paid to the petitioners as family support allowances. Moreover, the amounts paid to the petitioners were deducted on the estate's Federal fiduciary income tax returns and not on its Federal estate tax return.
In
(1) Amounts required to be distributed currently. -- The amount of income for the taxable year required to be distributed currently (2) Other amounts distributed. -- All other amounts properly paid, credited, or required to be distributed [Emphasis added.]
The widow, widower, minor children, and adult children who have been declared incompetent by order of court are entitled to such reasonable allowance out of the estate as shall be necessary for their maintenance according to their circumstances, during the progress of the settlement of the estate, which, in case of an insolvent estate, must not continue longer than one year after granting letters. Such allowance must be paid in preference to all other charges, except funeral charges, expenses of the last illness and expenses of administration, and may, in the discretion of the court or judge granting it, take effect from the death of the decedent.
Because family allowances are paid in preference to all other estate charges (except funeral and administration expenses and expenses of last illness), the petitioners feel that their position with respect to the distributions involved is entirely different from that of a beneficiary. 4
The term "beneficiary" is defined by section 643(c). "For purposes of this part [part I of subch. J], the term 'beneficiary'
Like the widow in
Moreover, the fact that under California law the payments may be made from either income or corpus does not affect their taxability in this case.
Finally, the petitioners argue that the Commissioner abused his discretion by making his amendments to
Clearly, the Commissioner has the discretion to limit the retroactive application of his regulations. Sec. 7805(b). And we do not find the limitations stated in T.I.R. 1226 to be unreasonable or an abuse of discretion. The limitations were obviously designed to protect, in an equitable manner, those who had in good faith relied upon the Commissioner's prior, erroneous explanation of the law without unnecessarily prejudicing the Government's rights. Again, we find this to be neither unreasonable nor arbitrary.
Footnotes
1. Cases of the following petitioners are consolidated herewith: Catherine C. Cameron, docket No. 2195-75; and Arthur A. Cameron, Jr., docket No. 2196-75.↩
2. All statutory references are to the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, as amended, unless otherwise stated.↩
3. Neither the stipulated facts nor the petitioners' briefs state that there were any other distributions by the estate for the years in question which, together with the above listed family allowance distributions, might have picked up a share of DNI and affected the petitioners' potential tax liabilities.↩
4. In further support of their position, the petitioners cite
In , andRe Wiedemann's Estate , 39 Cal. Rptr. 496 (1st Dist. Ct. App. 1964)In , which generally hold that family allowances take priority over most other estate charges and are unrelated to inheritance rights.Re Woodward's Estate , 40 Cal. Rptr. 781↩ (3d Dist. Ct. App. 1964)
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.