Brinley v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
5 later published cases cite this decision.
- Eldon D. Brinley and Mary Alice Brinley v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (5th Cir. 1986)
- Raju J. Mukhi (United States Tax Court 2024)
- Cook v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1989)
- Patterson v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1987)
- Budner v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1984)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*59 In
*932 SUPPLEMENTAL OPINION
This case is before us on petitioners' motion for reconsideration 1 of our opinion in the above-entitled case (hereinafter referred to as
*933 The issue 2 before us in
The granting of a motion for reconsideration rests within the discretion of the Court. Such a motion is generally denied unless unusual circumstances or substantial error is shown.
A taxpayer is allowed a deduction for any contribution "to or for the use of" a qualified religious organization.
It is undisputed by the parties that the LDS Church is a qualified donee under
Respondent asserts that petitioners are not entitled to a charitable contribution deduction under
Petitioners contend, however, that the amounts paid by them were "incident to" charitable services because the expenditures were generated by their son's rendition of substantial and valuable services to the LDS Church as a missionary. Therefore, petitioners contend, the expenses are expressly deductible under
Petitioners maintain that charitable service-related expenses are deductible regardless of the personal or family *935 nature of the expenses. In support of this contention, petitioners note that
When faced with the same issue on facts that are indistinguishable from those in
We disagree with
The Tenth Circuit fashioned the following rule of law:
the proper test, we hold, is the same as when the expenditure is for expenses personally incurred -- whether the primary purpose is to further the aims of the charitable organization or to benefit the person whose expenses are being paid. When the payment is for part of the costs of necessary travel and for all of the living expenses of a dependent member of taxpayers' household serving as a full-time church missionary away*69 from home we have no difficulty concluding that the expenditure is deductible because the expenditure primarily serves the church. [
*936 An appeal from this decision would lie in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. Consequently, we are not constrained by the
Although the facts of the
We think the case law that has interpreted
In cases where a taxpayer had unreimbursed expenses incident to rendering services to a charity, our*71 inquiry focused on whether the expenses provided a substantial, direct, personal benefit to the taxpayer or to someone other than the charity.
In cases where a taxpayer donated funds to an individual ostensibly as a representative of a charity (or where a taxpayer earmarked donated funds to a charity for a particular individual), our inquiry focused on whether the taxpayer intended to contribute the funds for the benefit of the charity.
We continue to adhere to our analyses under
Where a taxpayer seeks a charitable contribution for unreimbursed expenses incident to another family member's services to a charity, as occurred in the
First, and of primary importance, the plain meaning of the language used in
Moreover, we think the regulation contemplates a more direct nexus between unreimbursed expenses and charitable service. That is, a taxpayer who has unreimbursed expenses incident*76 to that same taxpayer's services to a charity is allowed a charitable contribution deduction for those expenses. Neither the Tenth Circuit in the
Second, an implication of the Tenth Circuit's analysis in
*78 We see no reason to deviate from the contributions analysis as originally applied in
However, petitioners contend that they contributed funds to their son and the travel agent as representatives of the LDS Church. In support, petitioners cite
In
In reversing this Court, the Fifth Circuit reasoned that such a contribution still would be "to or for the use of" a charitable entity despite the fact that the donor controlled which of the charitable entity's purposes would receive the exclusive benefit of the gift. Petitioners argue that
Proof that the church in Benoit sponsored "Sara Barry Days" for the express purpose of collecting funds for this part of its work,
Petitioners contend that by contributing funds to their son they have satisfied the second element of the
*941 We disagree with petitioners. First, the
Thus, we hold that the contributions analysis is appropriate in the instant case, and since petitioners have not satisfied the "intent to benefit the charity" test as evidenced by the control requirement, petitioners are not entitled to a charitable contribution under
Footnotes
1.
Rule 161, Tax Court Rules of Practice and Procedure.↩ 2. Petitioners' motion for reconsideration is directed exclusively to the charitable contribution issue and not to the two other issues in
Brinley I↩ involving educational travel expense and entertainment expense.3. All section references are to the Internal Revenue Code of 1954 as amended for the years in issue.↩
4.
Section 170 provides, in part, as follows:(a) Allowance of Deduction. --
(1) General rule. -- There shall be allowed as a deduction any charitable contribution (as defined in subsection (c)) payment of which is made within the taxable year. A charitable contribution shall be allowable as a deduction only if verified under regulations prescribed by the Secretary.
* * * *
(c) Charitable Contribution Defined. -- For purposes of this section, the term "charitable contribution" means a contribution or gift to or for the use of --
* * * *
(2) A corporation, trust, or community chest, fund, or foundation --
* * * *
(B) organized and operated exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, literary, or educational purposes * * *↩
5.
Sec. 1.170A-1(g) .Contributions of services . No deduction is allowable undersection 170↩ for a contribution of services. However, unreimbursed expenditures made incident to the rendition of services to an organization contributions to which are deductible may constitute a deductible contribution. For example, the cost of a uniform without general utility which is required to be worn in performing donated services is deductible. Similarly, out-of-pocket transportation expenses necessarily incurred in performing donated services are deductible. Reasonable expenditures for meals and lodging necessarily incurred while away from home in the course of performing donated services also are deductible. * * *6.
Sec. 1.262-1 . Personal, living and family expenses.(a)
In general . In computing taxable income, no deduction shall be allowed, except as otherwise expressly provided in chapter 1 of the Code, for personal, living, and family expenses.(b)
Examples of personal, living, and family expenses . Personal, living, and family expenses are illustrated in the following examples:* * * *
(5) Expenses incurred in traveling away from home (which include transportation expenses, meals, and lodging) and any other transportation expenses are not deductible unless they qualify as expenses deductible under
section 162 , sec 1.162-2, and paragraph (d) ofsec. 1.162-5 (relating to trade or business expenses),section 170 and paragraph (a)(2) of sec 1.170-2 or paragraph (g) ofsec. 1.170A-1 (relating to charitable contributions) * * ** * * *
(c) * * * Certain items of personal, living, or family nature are deductible to the extent expressly provided under the following sections, and the regulations under those sections:
* * * *
(5)
Section 170↩ (charitable, etc., contributions and gifts).7.
SEC. 262 . PERSONAL, LIVING, AND FAMILY EXPENSES.Except as otherwise expressly provided in this chapter, no deduction shall be allowed for personal, living, or family expenses.↩
8.
, affd.Golsen v. Commissioner , 54 T.C. 742 (1970)445 F.2d 985↩ (10th Cir. 1971) .9. Hereinafter sometimes referred to as the contributions analysis.↩
10. Hereinafter sometimes referred to as the unreimbursed expenses analysis.↩
11. See
;MacMichael v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1982-703 ;Sampson v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1982-276 ;Self v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1981-232 ;Babilonia v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1980-207 ;Churukian v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1980-205 ;De Vitto v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1979-185 .McCollum v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1978-435↩12. See cases cited in note 11
supra↩ .13. See also
;Gibson v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1981-668 , affd. without published opinionDiab v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo 1979-475688 F.2d 842 (7th Cir. 1982) ; ;Lesslie v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1977-111 .Davenport v. Commissioner , T.C. Memo. 1975-369↩14. See also cases cited in note 13
supra↩ .15. See
Lesslie v. Commissioner, supra↩ .16. We have found only one case dealing with a parent seeking a charitable contribution deduction for unreimbursed expenses incident to her son's services to a charity.
. InTate v. Commissioner , 59 T.C. 543 (1973)Tate , we held that "the 46-day expedition to Europe was primarily a vacation, sightseeing, and cultural trip for the teenagers. It was so advertised."59 T.C. at 550 . Thus our analysis turned on who primarily benefited from the unreimbursed expenses. We did not consider the attenuated connection between the unreimbursed expenses and the charitable services. We choose not to followTate↩ to the extent it is inconsistent, if at all, with our holding in the instant case.17. The
White↩ opinion implies that the taxpayer parents incurred the unreimbursed expenses. We disagree. We think it more accurate to describe such expenses as being incurred by the taxpayers' son.18. Having found the Fifth Circuit's decision in
Winn↩ to be distinguishable, we need not express our views as to whether we agree with that decision.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.