Faltesek v. Commissioner
Cases that cite this one
8 later published cases cite this decision.
- UNION CARBIDE CORP. v. COMMISSIONER (United States Tax Court 1998)
- Letourneau v. Comm'r (United States Tax Court 2012)
- Joseph D. Specking v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 2001)
- Union Carbide Corporation and Subsidiaries v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1998)
- Elena Lea Morgan Weschenfelder & Frederick Burkhart Weschenfelder v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 2019)
- Redfield v. Comm'r (United States Tax Court 2017)
- Gerencser v. Comm'r (United States Tax Court 2016)
- Fodor v. Commissioner (United States Tax Court 1991)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*82
T, an American citizen working abroad, failed to file timely income tax returns for 1982 and 1983 under the mistaken impression that he was not required to do so by reason of liberalized benefits in respect of foreign earned income provided by the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981. However, those liberalized exemption provisions, embodied in
T argues alternatively that his purported election filed in 1987 should be treated as a request for an extension of time to make the election pursuant to
*1205 The Commissioner determined deficiencies in petitioner's Federal income tax and additions to tax as follows:
| Additions to tax | ||||
| Year | Deficiency | Sec. 6651(a)(1) | 1 Sec. 6653(a) | Sec. 6654(a) |
| 1982 | $ 30,932.00 | $ 7,733.00 | $ 3,016.92 | |
| 1983 | 17,248.60 | 4,312.15 | 1,055.48 | |
The facts have been stipulated.
Petitioner, a U.S. citizen, owns a residence in Houston, Texas, as well as a condominium*84 in Conroe, Texas. He is an engineer, employed by IMCO Services (a subsidiary of Halliburton Co.) having an address in Houston, Texas. He has been a bona fide resident of one or more foreign countries continuously since August 17, 1974, through the date of the filing of his petition. As an employee of IMCO, he was a resident of Scotland for the first 2 months of 1982, and thereafter continuously at least through 1983 of the United Arab Emirates (UAE). His tax homes during those 2 years were Aberdeen, Scotland, and Dubai, UAE, respectively. Petitioner's spouse, Marisa R. Faltesek, resided with him abroad, but was treated as a "resident" alien by reason of an election under section 6013(g) that was made by both of them in their 1976 return and remains in effect for the years 1982 and 1983.
*1206 Petitioner did not timely file his Federal income tax returns for the years 1982 and 1983, due to his belief that the
On July 25, 1986, prior to petitioner's filing any returns for the years 1982 and 1983, the Commissioner mailed the statutory notice of deficiency to him, in which the principal item for each year was "wages." Petitioner then timely filed his petition herein on December 22, 1986. Only thereafter, namely, on January 26, 1987, did petitioner and his spouse file their original 1982 and 1983 joint returns. These returns were accompanied by IRS Forms 2555 in which petitioner attempted to elect to receive the benefits of the
For tax years beginning after December 31, 1981, ERTA did in fact substantially increase the tax benefits for American citizens working abroad. To the extent relevant here,
(a) Exclusion From Gross Income. -- At the election of a qualified individual (made separately with respect to paragraphs (1) and (2)), there shall be excluded from the gross income of such individual, and exempt from taxation under this subtitle, for any taxable year -- *1207 (1) the foreign earned income of such individual, and (2) the housing cost amount of such individual.
*87 As the first three words of
Provisions relating to the election required to bring
(1) In general. -- An election under subsection (a) shall apply to the taxable year for which made and to all subsequent*88 taxable years unless revoked under paragraph (2).
(2) Revocation. -- A taxpayer may revoke an election made under paragraph (1) for any taxable year after the taxable year for which such election was made. Except with the consent of the Secretary, any taxpayer who makes such a revocation for any taxable year may not make another election under this section for any subsequent taxable year before the 6th taxable year after the taxable year for which such revocation was made.
*1208 However,
* * * *
(8) Regulations. -- The Secretary shall prescribe such regulations as may be necessary or appropriate to carry out the purpose of this section * * *
It was subsequently redesignated
The applicable provisions of the regulations here involved are found in
(a)
* * * *
(2)
(A) With an income tax return that is timely filed (including any extensions of time to file),
*1209 (B) With a later return filed within the period prescribed in
(C) With an original income tax return that is filed within one year after the due date of the return (determined without regard to any extension of time to file); this one year period does not constitute*91 an extension of time for any purpose -- it is merely a period during which a valid election may be made on a late return.
(ii)
Petitioner certainly did not file a timely return on any theory, nor did he in any other manner comply with any of the other possible alternative conditions of these regulations for making a valid election. Petitioner does not contend otherwise. His sole argument is that the regulations themselves are invalid, and that his belated attempt in 1987 to elect the benefits of
The sole issue to be decided by the Court is as follows:
Whether the provisions of
We hold that the foregoing provisions of
It is quite true, as contended by petitioner, that Congress in 1981 was troubled about the growing competitive pressures that American businesses faced abroad, and we recognize that it wanted to improve our foreign trade by providing increased inducements for the conduct of business abroad and the rendition of services beyond the boundaries of the United States. See General Explanation of the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, prepared by the staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation (December 21, 1981), p. 43. In this connection, it substantially increased the tax benefits available in respect of foreign earned income. And we agree with petitioner that the statute must be construed in the light of the legislative objective. But Congress made *1210 it abundantly plain that the extended benefits that it was conferring were not open-ended. It did not open the flood gates. At the very beginning of
As to the election itself,
Provisions establishing rules for the timing and making the
In this very case, petitioner did not attempt to make his election for 1982 until 1987. To permit a taxpayer to make such a belated election would open the door to ex post facto or retroactive tax planning. We think Congress could hardly have intended to authorize any such potential maneuvering, notwithstanding its interest in promoting foreign trade and encouraging the rendition of services abroad. The regulations, *1211 which would prevent any such easy freewheeling are, we think, manifestly reasonable. They certainly should not be condemned as unreasonable, particularly when it is kept in mind that the burden is upon the taxpayer*95 to establish that a regulation is unreasonable rather than upon the Government to prove affirmatively that it is reasonable.
The timing requirements were generous, allowing as one alternative a grace period of one year from the original due date of the return. And even as to the years 1982 and 1983 in respect of which the time for filing the returns (June 15, 1983, and 1984) had already expired when the regulations were finally promulgated (January 23, 1985), 4 an additional period of 6 months (up to July 23, 1985) was allowed within which to make the election.
The very process undertaken by the Treasury in the formulation and development of these regulations emphasizes its concern for the fairness*96 that characterized the regulations as finally issued. The Secretary first published his proposed regulations on July 20, 1983, in the Federal Register.
Although it is quite true that a regulation will not survive judicial scrutiny if it is perceived to be unreasonable and "fundamentally at odds with the manifest congressional design" (
These regulations command our respect, for Congress has delegated to the Secretary of the Treasury, not to this Court, the task "of administering the tax laws of the Nation."
We hold that the regulations before us,
A word on the application of the regulations to the facts of this case. Regardless of the election necessary to exempt petitioner's foreign earned income from tax, he was required*100 to file a timely income tax return for each of the years 1982 and 1983 in any event. The record discloses that he received $ 9,225 in rents from his two Texas properties in 1982, and $ 9,600 in rents from those properties as well as $ 1,523 in interest in 1983. He thus had gross income in each of those years that was substantially in excess of the maximum amount of gross income that he could receive in either year without being required by the then applicable provisions of section 6012(a) to file a return. The mere fact that he had deductions chargeable against his rentals that would reduce his
Further, the mere fact that the regulations indicate that the election "may be made on Form 2555 or a comparable form" accompanying the income tax return is not unreasonable. The information thus sought for the IRS is to enable it to make sure that the statute is properly complied with. The substance of Form 2555 was set forth in specific detail in the regulations, 5 and only the substance was required to *1214 be filed with the return, not necessarily Form 2555 itself. However, even if Form 2555 itself were absolutely required, rather than merely its substance, such requirement would be valid. Cf.
*102 We have carefully examined various other contentions made by petitioner, particularly those based upon comparisons with other provisions of the Code, but find them too remote to be of any persuasive force here. We do not find it necessary or useful to comment upon them.
Finally, petitioner makes a contention on brief, based upon an issue not heretofore raised, either in the pleadings or elsewhere so far as we have been informed -- namely, that the Commissioner abused his discretion in refusing to use his authority pursuant to
We think that there is no substance whatever to the point.
(a)
(1) The time for making such election or application is not expressly prescribed by law;
(2) Request for the extension is filed with the Commissioner before the time fixed by the regulations for making such election or application, or within such time thereafter as the Commissioner may consider reasonable under the circumstances; and
*1215 (3) It is shown to the satisfaction of the Commissioner that the granting of the extension will not jeopardize the interests of the Government.
For purposes of this section, an application for an extension of time for filing a return under
Subparagraph (a)(2) requires that the request for the extension be filed "
In view of the fact that the parties have settled all other issues and have stipulated various items to be taken into account in determining petitioner's liability for the years involved as well as the amounts of resulting tax in the event of decision either for petitioner or respondent, and in order to reflect the conclusions reached herein,
Footnotes
1. Plus 50 percent of interest due pursuant to section 6653(a)(2).↩
1. Secs. 111(a) and 115 of Pub. L. 97-34, 95 Stat. 172, 190, 196.↩
2.
Sec. 911(b)(2)(A)↩ as amended by sec. 1233(a) of the Tax Reform Act of 1986, Pub. L. 99-514, 100 Stat. 2085, 2564.3. Although
sec. 911(d)(7) was originally effective for taxable years beginning after Dec. 31, 1981 (sec. 111(a) of the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, Pub. L. 97-34, 95 Stat. 172, 194), it was redesignatedsec. 911(d)(8) by sec. 101(c)(1) of the Technical Corrections Act of 1982, Pub. L. 97-448, 96 Stat. 2365, 2366, and as such was effective for taxable years after Dec. 31, 1981. Subsequently,sec. 911(d)(8) was further redesignatedsec. 911(d)(9)↩ by sec. 1233(b) of the Tax Reform Act of 1986, Pub. L. 99-514, 100 Stat. 2085, 2564, which was effective for tax years beginning after Dec. 31, 1986.4. The regulations were approved on behalf of the Secretary on Dec. 21, 1984, filed by the Office of the Federal Register on Jan. 17, 1985, and published in the issue of the Federal Register for Jan. 23, 1985. See
1985-1 C.B. 246↩ .5. See
sec. 1.911-7(a)(1), Income Tax Regs.↩
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.