Dhillon v. Commissioner
Opinion
*252 An appropriate order of dismissal will be entered.
R filed a motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction on the ground that Ps did not file their petition for redetermination within the time prescribed by
sec. 6213(a), I.R.C. Ps, 50- percent partners in E, contend that their petition was timely filed. Ps argue that the extended time for filing a petition undersec. 6226(b)(1), I.R.C. , of the partnership audit and litigation procedures,secs. 6221- 6232, I.R.C. , enacted as part of the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982, Pub. L. 97-248, sec. 402(a), 96 Stat. 648 (TEFRA partnership procedures), governs the period for filing the petition because R's adjustments in the notice of deficiency relate to adjustments of flow-through partnership items of E.HELD: E is a "small partnership" under sec.
6231(a)(1)(B)(i), I.R.C. , and is therefore not a partnership covered by the TEFRA partnership procedures. Thus, the extended period for filing a petition for redetermination under sec.6226(b)(1), I.R.C. , does not apply in this case.HELD, further, since Ps did not file their petition within *253 the time prescribed by
sec. 6213(a), I.R.C. , R's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction is granted.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
*255 NIMS, JUDGE: This matter is before the Court on respondent's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction on the ground that petitioners did not file their petition within the time prescribed by
BACKGROUND
*256 The relevant facts are not in dispute and may be summarized as follows. Petitioners resided in San Jose, California, when they filed their petition.
Petitioners were general partners in a partnership named B&R Dhillon Et Al Ptrs, d.b.a. Executive Inn (Executive Inn). Petitioners' Schedules K-1, Partner's Share of Income, Credits, Deductions, Etc., attached to their 1994 and 1995 Federal income tax returns, indicate that they held an aggregate 50-percent interest in profits, losses, and capital of Executive Inn during the 1994 and 1995 taxable years. Kenneth*257 and Rosemary Manrao were the other general partners and held the remaining 50-percent interest in profits, losses, and capital during the 1994 and 1995 taxable years. Executive Inn operated a motel in Campbell, California.
Petitioners filed their 1994 and 1995 Federal income tax returns on September 6 and October 30, 1996, respectively. On June 2, 1998, respondent mailed to petitioners a Form 4605, Examination Changes - Partnerships, Fiduciaries, Small Business Corporations, and Interest Charge Domestic International Sales Corporations, which proposed adjustments to Executive Inn's 1994, 1995, and 1996 taxable years. Respondent timely mailed the notice of deficiency for petitioners' 1994 and 1995 taxable years on July 17, 1998. Petitioners mailed their petition on October 16, 1998; the petition was filed on October 20, 1998.
DISCUSSION
*258
Petitioners argue, however, that
Under the TEFRA partnership procedures, "the tax treatment of any partnership item shall be determined at the partnership level."
Pursuant to
(a) Petition by Tax Matters Partner. -- Within 90 days after the day on which a notice of a final partnership administrative adjustment is mailed to the tax matters partner, the tax matters partner may file a petition for a readjustment of the partnership items for such taxable year with --
(1) the Tax Court,
(a) Secretary Must Give Partners Notice of Beginning and Completion of Administrative Proceedings. -- The Secretary shall mail to each partner whose name and address is furnished to the Secretary notice of --
(1) the beginning of an administrative proceeding at the partnership level with respect to a partnership item, and
(2) the final partnership administrative adjustment resulting from such proceeding.
A partner shall not be entitled to any notice under this subsection unless the Secretary has received (at least 30 days before it is mailed to the tax matters partner) sufficient information to enable the Secretary to determine that such partner is entitled to such notice and to provide such notice to such partner.
Subsections (b)(2) and (e)(1)(B) of section 6223 involve special rules relating to partnerships with more than 100 partners and are not pertinent here. Since petitioners have furnished their names*262 and address to the Secretary, petitioners fit within the definition of a "notice partner" if the TEFRA partnership procedures apply. See
Therefore, if the TEFRA partnership procedures apply, then petitioners would have no less than 90 days after respondent mails the notice of final partnership administrative adjustment (FPAA) to file their petition.
Respondent argues that the TEFRA partnership procedures do not cover Executive Inn because Executive Inn falls within the "small partnership" exception. See
(I) such partnership has 10 or fewer partners each of whom is a natural person (other than a nonresident alien) or an estate, and
(II) each partner's share of each partnership item is the same as his share of every other item. For purposes of the preceding sentence, a husband and wife (and their estates) shall be treated as 1 partner.
[Sec. 6231(a)(1)(B)(i) . 1]
*263 Congress enacted the small partnership exception in TEFRA to ensure that only "simple" partnerships would be excepted. See
A small partnership may elect to have the TEFRA partnership procedures apply. See
In this case, under
The remaining question, therefore, is whether the second requirement that each partner's share of each partnership item was the same as his share of every other item has been satisfied. See
(3) "Same share." The requirement of section
6231(a)(1)(B)(i)(II) is satisfied for a taxable year if
during all periods within that taxable year each partner's
share of each of the partnership items specified in section
301.6231(a)(3)-1(a)(1)(i) through (iv) is the *265 same as that
partner's share of each of the other partnership items
specified in that section during that period (even though
the partner's share of all such specified partnership items
changes from period to period within that taxable year)
* * *
The partnership items referred to in these regulations are:
(i) Items of income, gain, loss, deduction, or credit of the partnership;
(ii) Expenditures by the partnership not deductible in computing its taxable income (for example, charitable contributions);
(iii) Items of the partnership which may be tax preference items under
section 57(a) for any partner;(iv) Income of the partnership exempt from tax. [Sec. 301.6231(a)(3)-1(a)(1), Proced. & Admin. Regs.]
The "same share" requirement is determined annually, see sec. 301.6231(a)(1)-1T(a)(4), Temporary Proced. & Admin. Regs.,
Based on the foregoing, we hold that Executive Inn falls within the small partnership exception under
Petitioners argue that Congress could not have intended that the small partnership exception would apply under these circumstances. According to petitioners, respondent is abusing the small partnership exception by using it as an excuse to abandon a complex "partnership level examination and then to issue a deficiency notice at the partner level (i.e., effectively limiting challenge to the 'modifications' of partnership income)". We disagree.
Furthermore, petitioners had the right, which they have attempted to exercise in this case, to challenge respondent's determinations resulting from modifications to partnership income by filing a petition for redetermination within 90 days of the mailing of the notice of deficiency. See
Petitioners further argue that the provisions of subchapter K (sections 701 through 761) and the definitions set forth in section 7701(a)(2) (defining the terms "Partnership and Partner") and (14) (defining the term "Taxpayer") somehow mandate the application of the TEFRA partnership procedures in this case. As noted above, the TEFRA partnership procedures "provide a method for uniformly adjusting items of partnership income, loss, deduction, or credit that affect each partner".
Furthermore, the definitions set forth in section 7701(a) apply only "where not otherwise distinctly expressed or manifestly incompatible with the intent thereof --". In this case, the term "partnership" has been specifically defined for purposes of the TEFRA partnership procedures in
Petitioners' remaining arguments are either meritless or are mooted by our holding that the TEFRA partnership procedures do not apply.
Since petitioners filed their petition more than 90 days after the mailing of the deficiency notice, respondent's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction will be granted.
To reflect the foregoing,
An appropriate order of dismissal will be entered.
Footnotes
1. The above version of the statute applies to the tax years 1994 and 1995 involved here. The Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, Pub. L. 105-34, sec. 1234(a), 111 Stat. 788, 1024, amended
sec. 6231(a)(1)(B)(i)↩ , effective for partnership tax years ending after Aug. 5, 1997.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.