Strehl v. Secretary of Health and Human Services
Opinion
01ÿ345ÿ617358ÿ 93ÿ3ÿ 5 ÿ ÿ 3ÿÿ5ÿ ÿ 7 !"#ÿ$%&'()*+ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ -./.001ÿ23-.456ÿ 0M:8Nÿ2J8O:PQÿFPI98=ÿ0;=O;=P<ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ789:9:;<8=6ÿ B:Q8KRÿB8S=TP=UÿVV6ÿWXWYÿ >?ÿ ÿ ÿ 2.0-.31-@ÿABÿ4.1534ÿ1CDÿÿ ÿÿ 4EF1Cÿ2.-GH0.26ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ-8IJ;<K8<9?ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ Z[\]^ÿ̀abcÿd[ecfghÿieffcÿjÿklb[mnfÿoodhÿpb]n[^fnqb][hÿprhÿmaeÿpfs]s]acfetÿ ÿ d[sbfe]cfÿun]v[wfsbÿksan[ehÿxtktÿZfq[esyfcsÿamÿ̀z{s]lfhÿ|[{b]c}sachÿZdhÿmaeÿ ~f{qac^fcstÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ!ÿ !ÿÿ !ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ A<ÿFPUÿV6ÿWXW6ÿ-8S8OOPÿ29=8MQÿN:Q8KÿPÿJ89:9:;<ÿN;=ÿO;J8<IP9:;<ÿT<K8W=ÿ9M8ÿ CP9:;<PQÿGPOO:<8ÿH<T=Uÿ0;J8<IP9:;<ÿ7=;=P6ÿWÿE?2?0?ÿXXPPVX6ÿfsÿ{ftÿ9M8ÿ GPOO:<8ÿ1O9?ÿ789:9:;<8=ÿPQQ88Kÿ9MP9ÿIM8ÿITNN8=8KÿPÿIM;TQK8=ÿ:<T=Uÿ=8QP98Kÿ9;ÿ>POO:<8ÿ PK:<:I9=P9:;<ÿ2H-G1ÿN;QQ;:<ÿP<ÿ:<NQT8<Pÿ>POO:<8ÿIM8ÿ=8O8:>8Kÿ;<ÿ28J98S8=ÿW6ÿ WXWV?ÿ789:9:;<ÿP9ÿV?ÿA<ÿ1J=:Qÿ6ÿWXW6ÿHÿ:IIT8KÿPÿ=TQ:<ÿ;<ÿ8<9:9Q88<9ÿN:<K:<ÿ789:9:;<8=ÿ 8<9:9Q8Kÿ9;ÿO;J8<IP9:;<?ÿ.0BÿC;?ÿV?ÿÿA<ÿAO9;S8=ÿ6ÿWXW6ÿÿHÿ:IIT8KÿPÿK8O:I:;<ÿPP=K:<ÿ KPP8Iÿ9;ÿ789:9:;<8=ÿN;QQ;:<ÿS=:8N:<ÿSUÿ9M8ÿJP=9:8I?ÿ.0BÿC;?ÿ?ÿ Vÿ ÿ /8OPTI8ÿ9M:IÿD8O:I:;<ÿO;<9P:<IÿPÿ=8PI;<8Kÿ8JQP<P9:;<ÿN;=ÿ9M8ÿPO9:;<ÿ9P8<ÿ:<ÿ9M:IÿOPI86ÿ:9ÿTI9ÿS8ÿPK8ÿ JTSQ:OQUÿPOO8II:SQ8ÿP<Kÿ:QQÿS8ÿJ;I98Kÿ;<ÿ9M8ÿE<:98Kÿ29P98Iÿ0;T=9ÿ;NÿB8K8=PQÿ0QP:Iÿ8SI:986ÿP<K;=ÿ P9ÿÿM99JIR?;>:<N;?;>PJJO;QQ8O9:;<TIO;T=9I<P9:;<PQO;NO6ÿ:<ÿPOO;=KP<O8ÿ:9Mÿ9M8ÿ.;>8=<8<9ÿ 1O9ÿ;NÿWXXW?ÿÿE?2?0?ÿÿXVÿ<;98ÿWXVÿB8K8=PQÿFP<P88<9ÿP<Kÿ7=;;9:;<ÿ;Nÿ.Q8O9=;<:Oÿ;>8=<8<9ÿ 28=>:O8I?ÿ ÿÿÿ¡"ÿ¢££ÿ¤ÿ¥£¤£ÿ"ÿ¦"ÿ¢ÿ¡¡ÿ"ÿÿ§#ÿH<ÿ POO;=KP<O8ÿ:9MÿGPOO:<8ÿ-TQ8ÿVS6ÿ789:9:;<8=ÿMPIÿVÿKPUIÿ9;ÿ:K8<9:NUÿP<Kÿ;>8ÿ9;ÿ=8KPO9ÿ8K:OPQÿ;=ÿ;9M8=ÿ :<N;=P9:;<6ÿ9M8ÿK:IOQ;IT=8ÿ;NÿM:OMÿ;TQKÿO;<I9:9T98ÿP<ÿT<P==P<98Kÿ:<>PI:;<ÿ;NÿJ=:>POU?ÿHN6ÿTJ;<ÿ=8>:86ÿHÿ P=88ÿ9MP9ÿ9M8ÿ:K8<9:N:8KÿP98=:PQÿN:9Iÿ:9M:<ÿ9M:IÿK8N:<:9:;<6ÿHÿ:QQÿ=8KPO9ÿITOMÿP98=:PQÿN=;ÿJTSQ:OÿPOO8II?ÿ ÿ WÿCP9:;<PQÿ0M:QKM;;KÿGPOO:<8ÿH<T=Uÿ1O9ÿ;NÿVY6ÿ7TS?ÿ5?ÿC;?ÿYYX6ÿVXXÿ29P9?ÿ¨?ÿ48=8:<PN98=6ÿN;=ÿ8PI8ÿ ;NÿO:9P9:;<6ÿPQQÿI8O9:;<ÿ=8N8=8<O8Iÿ9;ÿ9M8ÿGPOO:<8ÿ1O9ÿ:QQÿS8ÿ9;ÿ9M8ÿJ8=9:<8<9ÿITSJP=P=PJMÿ;NÿWÿE?2?0?ÿÿ XXPPÿWXV?ÿ ÿ 3456567849ÿ ÿ87 ÿ64ÿÿ75678ÿ79ÿ557984ÿ44ÿ8ÿ75ÿ944568ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ 7ÿ ÿ94!9448568ÿ " ##ÿ79ÿ44ÿ8ÿ$0# ÿ79ÿ75% ÿ3456567849ÿ &!!65678ÿ79ÿ'44ÿ8ÿ(75ÿ64ÿ)44*49ÿÿ0#0"ÿ+('ÿ,7 ÿ ÿ'9549794ÿ 3456567849ÿ64ÿÿ684ÿ554485ÿ94!94 48568ÿ5 5ÿ87ÿ!4978 ÿ75ÿ7ÿ!7-45ÿ4.!484 ÿ 494ÿ68994 ÿ+('ÿ,7 ÿÿ5ÿ 0 ÿÿ ÿ /4 !78485ÿ94 54ÿ57ÿ54ÿ75678ÿ78ÿ)44*49ÿ ÿ0#0"ÿ94!94 48568ÿ5 5ÿ4ÿ6ÿ 5664ÿ5 5ÿ54ÿ55579ÿ94694485ÿ79ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ7ÿ557984ÿ44 ÿ8ÿ75ÿ94ÿ45ÿ 68ÿ56ÿ 4ÿ*5ÿ449968ÿ9475678ÿ7ÿ54ÿ785ÿ57ÿ*4ÿ 94ÿ57ÿÿ6945678 ÿ /4 !78485ÿ/4 !784ÿ57ÿ075678ÿ5ÿ01$ÿ$ÿ8 0ÿ+('ÿ,7 ÿ" ÿ3456567849ÿ64ÿ87ÿ94!ÿ 5494 549 ÿ ÿ 368ÿ786494ÿ54ÿ75678ÿ78ÿ 65ÿ54ÿ683764ÿ8ÿ7549ÿ!977ÿ64ÿ68ÿ 78845678ÿ4ÿ68ÿÿ945678ÿ68ÿ54ÿ785ÿ7ÿ44ÿ57ÿ*4ÿ 94ÿ!!97!9654ÿ79ÿ54ÿ 78ÿ45ÿ795ÿ*47 ÿ ÿ 565789:9ÿ ÿ < 4ÿ= 684ÿ&5ÿ!4965ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ7ÿ94 78 *4ÿ557984ÿ44 ÿ8ÿ75 ÿ>45678ÿ "4% ÿ(784ÿ5ÿ*65ÿ44ÿ944 5ÿ5 5ÿ684ÿ7854!79847ÿ8ÿ!466ÿ *668ÿ9479ÿ686568ÿ54ÿ49364ÿ!49794ÿ54ÿ8*49ÿ7ÿ79ÿ4.!484ÿ78ÿ54ÿ 49364ÿ8ÿ54ÿ8 4ÿ7ÿ54ÿ!4978ÿ!497968ÿ54ÿ49364 ÿ?@@ÿ?BCDEÿCFÿ?@GHIÿJKÿL@BMNOÿ PÿLQRFÿ?@SCTFÿ "ÿ'4 ÿ( ÿ$ $ÿ$ 1 ÿ0## % ÿ(784ÿ 7ÿ875ÿ684ÿ68ÿ5469ÿ44ÿ 944 5ÿ79ÿ5 5ÿ94ÿU4.4 634ÿ948 85ÿ79ÿ754964ÿ8844 9 Vÿ?BWNJEÿCFÿ ?@GHIÿJKÿL@BMNOÿPÿLQRFÿ?@SCTFÿ$ÿ' $ÿ " ÿ "0 ÿ'4 ÿ(69 ÿ XX$%ÿ7568ÿL@ETM@IÿCFÿ YGZ@SOBSNÿ ÿ[ > ÿ0ÿ$ÿ X $%% ÿ45ÿ6ÿU4ÿ6568ÿ54ÿ!46ÿ 549ÿ6945678ÿ57ÿ 944ÿ54ÿ79ÿ57ÿÿ8*49ÿ5 5ÿ68ÿ\49]ÿ4.!496484ÿ8ÿ^485ÿ\6]ÿ94 78 *4ÿ79ÿ 54ÿ79-ÿ784 Vÿ_`Fÿ5ÿ "00 ÿ'9549794ÿ54ÿ!46ÿ 549ÿ ÿ944ÿÿ44ÿ9445ÿ TQBÿTaJEN@ÿ! 95ÿ97ÿ7*^45678ÿ964ÿ*ÿ94!78485ÿ8ÿ6575ÿ!973668ÿÿ!456567849ÿ 87564ÿ8ÿ7!!795865ÿ57ÿ94!78 ÿ?@@ÿ?Bb@MMBÿCFÿ?@GHIÿJKÿL@BMNOÿPÿLQRFÿ?@SCTFÿ ÿ'4 ÿ ( ÿ0# ÿ0#Xÿ0##X% ÿ&ÿ!46ÿ 549ÿ844ÿ875ÿ48 4ÿ68ÿÿ6841*1684ÿ8 6ÿ7ÿ !456567849ÿ44ÿ!!65678ÿ 48ÿ9468ÿ44 ÿcSJ@Z@MTGO@EÿCFÿ?@GHIÿJKÿL@BMNOÿPÿLQRFÿ ?@SCTFÿ #0ÿ'4 ÿ( ÿ Xÿ 0Xÿ0# % ÿ ÿ < 4ÿ!456567849ÿU*4 9ÿ54ÿ*948ÿ7ÿ45*6 68ÿ54ÿ79ÿ4.!484ÿ54ÿ954ÿ 94ÿ8ÿ54ÿ4.!484ÿ68994 VÿdBTTJEÿCFÿ?@GHIÿJKÿL@BMNOÿPÿLQRFÿ?@SCTFeÿ0ÿ( ÿ (5 ÿ 0ÿ ÿ XX % ÿ< 4ÿ3456567849ÿU 7ÿ!94 485ÿ4 54ÿ!977ÿ\7ÿ54ÿ557984ÿ44ÿ 8ÿ75ÿ7 5]ÿ 5ÿ54ÿ564ÿ7ÿ54ÿ*6 678 VÿdBTTJEeÿ0ÿ( ÿ(5 ÿ 5ÿ ÿ8 ÿ 3456567849ÿ78 4ÿU 7ÿ -4ÿÿ77ÿ65ÿ4795ÿ57ÿ4.4ÿ97ÿÿ44ÿ944 5ÿ79ÿ 0ÿ ÿ 3453ÿ567ÿ7897 7ÿ6753ÿ6ÿ3476 7ÿ797 56ÿ3ÿ5ÿ5ÿ576ÿÿ6537ÿ 659397ÿ73495ÿ ÿ537ÿ3ÿ7897ÿ94ÿ46ÿ6ÿ4 ÿ77ÿ ÿ ! "ÿ #$%ÿ&'ÿ53ÿ#0#ÿ ÿ ())*+,-.ÿ0--1ÿ ÿ 247ÿ6537 ÿ673737ÿ6ÿ64ÿ7667ÿ3464ÿ5657ÿ567ÿ67557ÿ5ÿ 9 373ÿ34ÿ6ÿ66ÿ737653 ÿ5ÿÿ3476767ÿ7ÿ5567ÿ4767ÿÿ ÿ 8756ÿ347ÿ76ÿÿ46ÿ7ÿ9ÿ77ÿ347ÿ:;:<!ÿ53ÿÿ37ÿ737ÿ3ÿ 67ÿÿ557 ÿ3ÿ7ÿ7897 7ÿ> ÿ?73376@ÿA67ÿÿ'63ÿÿB557 ÿ7ÿ Cÿ55ÿ565#ÿDEFÿGÿ5$Hÿ?73376@ÿ87ÿ3ÿ87 73@ÿ877ÿ3ÿA67ÿÿ '63ÿÿB557 ÿ7ÿGÿ57ÿ565#ÿDEFÿGÿ0%Hÿ?73376@ÿ'79ÿ87ÿ3ÿ 73@ÿ877ÿ3ÿA67ÿÿ'63ÿÿB557 ÿ7ÿC6ÿ5Iÿ5657ÿDEFÿGÿ 0Jÿ?73376@ÿ97ÿ7877ÿ568537ÿ%J6ÿ46ÿ653ÿ347ÿ5570 ÿ67ÿ %##ÿ46ÿ653ÿ347ÿ67ÿ5ÿ#5ÿ46ÿ653ÿ347ÿ79ÿ67ÿ335ÿ07$ÿ46ÿ DEFÿGÿ##ÿ53ÿ5$K05ÿ ÿ Lÿ5 7ÿ95953ÿ7 ÿ3ÿ97ÿ37ÿ73ÿ6756ÿ347ÿ35ÿ75ÿ 494ÿÿ457ÿ67ÿ34 ÿ5376ÿ64ÿ5ÿ9ÿ5ÿ3476767ÿ556ÿ77ÿ5 9537ÿ 34ÿ3453ÿ354ÿÿÿDEFÿGÿ##ÿ53ÿ56ÿ5ÿ5%ÿG6ÿ5ÿ9ÿ93ÿ37ÿ 73ÿ 9953ÿ34ÿ?73376ÿ5ÿ6756ÿ535ÿ63ÿ97353ÿ94ÿ ÿ55 3ÿ6ÿ7ÿ795653 ÿ494ÿÿ5ÿ7ÿ5567ÿÿÿ> Mÿ7ÿNOPÿ53ÿ %JK57ÿQ7367ÿ537ÿ#R%IR5650ÿ#R%SR5650ÿ#R5IR5650ÿ7R56R5650ÿ7R5$R5650ÿJR%5R565#ÿ JR%7R565#ÿJR56R565#ÿJR5$R565#ÿJR5IR565#Tÿ ÿ 93ÿ ÿ67557ÿ6ÿ97ÿ3ÿ7ÿÿ94ÿ37ÿ67ÿ347ÿ53376ÿÿ 557ÿÿ34 ÿ95 7ÿ9ÿ457ÿ737ÿ76 ÿ95 7ÿQ494ÿ5ÿ6755ÿ7ÿ 9567ÿ3ÿ37 ÿ 7 3 ÿ ÿ ÿ5 3376T#ÿÿ 494ÿ53367ÿ457ÿ59947ÿ34 ÿ35 4ÿ 67ÿ7973ÿÿ 0ÿ ÿ ÿ335ÿÿ959537ÿ5ÿ Uÿ0Jÿ46ÿ7ÿÿ#R57R5657ÿ#R5JR5657ÿ#R5IR5657ÿÿ53367ÿB5 ÿ E567ÿ53ÿ5ÿ6537ÿÿV#J766ÿ5ÿ0%Sÿ46ÿ7ÿÿIR%7R565#ÿIR%$R565#ÿIR%JR565#ÿIR%IR565#ÿ IR%SR565#ÿIR56R565#ÿIR5%R565#ÿIR55R565#ÿ%%R%7R565#ÿ%%R%$R565#ÿ%%R%JR565#ÿ%%R5%R565#ÿ %%R55R565#ÿ%%R50R565#ÿ%%R57R565#ÿ%5R%0R565#ÿÿ53367ÿB5 ÿE567ÿ53ÿ5ÿ6537ÿÿV#7666ÿÿDEFÿGÿ ##ÿ53ÿ5$K05ÿ ÿ #ÿ'795 ÿ5 376ÿ5ÿ7ÿ956 ÿ3ÿ53367ÿ766 ÿ 56ÿ354ÿ3ÿ7376 7ÿÿ46ÿ567ÿ 7897 7ÿ> ÿ><W:; ÿXPÿ> YZ"ÿ;[ÿ <!:\ÿ]ÿ ^_Pÿ> `XPÿ0ÿF0ÿ%7%Jÿ%7%IK%75%ÿQF7ÿE6ÿ%SS0Tÿ ÿ 7ÿ> Mÿ PaMÿbN!Y;WÿXPÿ> YZ"ÿ;[ÿ <!:\ÿ]ÿ ^_Pÿ> `XPMÿGÿ5%K%#5%cÿQG ÿ5#ÿ5657TÿQ%56ÿ5ÿJ6ÿ46ÿ 7ÿ6ÿ653ÿ5ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ5ÿ67 7ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ677937THÿdYe! !!< OÿXPÿ> YZ"ÿ;[ÿ 0ÿ ÿ ÿ 34ÿ56789 ÿ ÿ8ÿÿ9ÿ5 9 ÿÿ4 9ÿ 8ÿ9ÿ 8ÿ868ÿ ÿ 6 ÿ ÿ!7ÿ ÿ"5ÿ 8#9ÿ6ÿÿ 8ÿ64ÿÿ$%&'()&*+%ÿ&-(.)/ÿ(0ÿ68 19ÿ 9 ÿ"5568ÿ2ÿÿ875ÿ ÿ97#ÿ65ÿ3 ÿ 8 ÿ468ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ6ÿ64ÿ 5ÿ6789ÿ68ÿ675778 49<ÿ3ÿ/%)ÿ 85 ÿ:75ÿÿ58699; ;36 8ÿ8756ÿ 5 ÿ2ÿ #ÿ#6 8ÿ6ÿ6ÿ48ÿ5 789ÿ ÿ6 83ÿ 5ÿ3ÿ9ÿ68=ÿ67ÿ 8>78ÿ# ÿ6ÿ5ÿ9ÿÿ?8 ÿ;9 ÿ5567@ÿÿ 4ÿÿ9 545ÿ 5ÿ ÿ A%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ80;9594HÿI7 ÿ80ÿ8984ÿ <ÿÿ4 ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ ÿ8969ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 JÿK(&/%%ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ88;9O8<HÿI7 ÿ 7Oÿ8984ÿ< 5ÿÿ 7ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 Jÿ P+&)L(ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ88;944 HÿI7 ÿ75ÿ8984ÿO 4ÿÿ0 5ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿ ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5JÿQ(B%)ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ ;7959HÿI7 ÿ77ÿ8984ÿ0 8ÿÿO 9ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ 384ÿ89 5 JÿRS$T%'ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ7 ;75<9HÿU 5 ÿ8<ÿ8980ÿ75 Oÿÿ< 4ÿ 6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5JÿE/(+V%ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿ A%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ87;9 50Hÿ 6 ÿ88ÿ8980ÿ77 Oÿÿ< 8ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ 384ÿÿ8969ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 JÿW&FSX'()ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ89; 757<Hÿ 6 ÿ88ÿ8980ÿ70 ÿÿ Oÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ 384ÿ89 5 JÿA&)'+%$YZ(S)/ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ87;9904Hÿ[ 8 ÿ85ÿ8980ÿ 5ÿÿ ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5JÿW.+&)%NÿFDÿE%LMNÿ (0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ89;70OOHÿ[ 8 ÿ85ÿ8980ÿ5 5ÿÿ9 4ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ 384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5JÿE/(\%'ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ7 ;9<48Hÿ 3 ÿ8 ÿ8980ÿ74 ÿÿO 7ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ 89 5Jÿ]SLB&$X'()ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ89;95<0Hÿ 3 ÿ ÿ8980ÿ 8ÿÿ5 ÿ6789ÿ 3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5Jÿ^X_&$X'ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/Bÿ CÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ 6 ÿ87;9945Hÿ 3 ÿ4ÿ8980ÿ77 ÿÿ< 8ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ 8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 Jÿ`S++&ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ89;945 Hÿ 3 ÿ4ÿ 8980ÿ5 9ÿÿ4 5ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 Jÿ a&b%$.'ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ89;7 05Hÿ35 ÿ7<ÿ898 ÿ77 9ÿÿ0 5ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ 84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 Jÿc%'/)%$ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-Dÿ E%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ89;9984HÿI7 ÿ88ÿ898 ÿ5 99ÿÿ0 79ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ 8969ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 Jÿd.)(ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'Dÿ 6 ÿ7O;950 HÿI7 ÿ70ÿ ÿ4 Oÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384Jÿ^X-S)S'/%$ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'Dÿ 6 ÿ7 ; 97O0Hÿ[ ÿ 9ÿ898 ÿ74 ÿÿ 4ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ 384ÿ89 5 JÿeB(-'()ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ88;98 0Hÿ[ ÿ7Oÿ898 ÿ 4ÿÿ8 4ÿ 6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 Jÿ]SL%YA&)'%)ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ (0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F' ÿ 6 ÿ89;7 OHÿ[ ÿ7<ÿ898 ÿ78 ÿÿ5 7ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ # 9ÿ 384ÿÿ8969 ÿ # 9ÿ384ÿ89 5 ÿf 9 ÿ 5969ÿ5 ÿ68ÿÿ3 ÿ467ÿ6ÿ ÿgÿ :9ÿ 678ÿ 64ÿ 8ÿ #9ÿ 39 ÿ h68ÿ ÿ 9ihh 646 6hh5656h7956789h 6 h5645 ÿ ÿ 5ÿ ! 5 79ÿ ÿ#67ÿ64ÿj599ÿ6789ÿ 9ÿ6ÿ9ÿ8679ÿ9ÿÿ6 8ÿ599ÿ2ÿÿ875 ÿ ÿ6789ÿ 3ÿ3ÿÿ6 8ÿ#67ÿ ÿ2ÿ6 89ÿ67ÿ ÿE%%Gÿ ÿA&FS'ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ ÿ87;94O Hÿ8984ÿklÿ84 O 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ: 5 ÿ[98 ÿI7ÿ 7ÿ8984ÿÿÿ 9ÿ 85 ÿ8756 ÿÿ ÿ< ÿ: 5ÿ# 989ÿ8ÿ 8#ÿ6ÿ#6ÿ 85 ÿ87569ÿ6ÿ6789ÿ3ÿ86 ÿ ÿ8756ÿ9ÿ 97445ÿj ÿE%%Gÿ ÿm**(//ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'DGÿ7 4ÿ ÿ ÿ79<ÿ777ÿ897<Jÿ ]&N-(ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿA.-DÿE%$F'Gÿ78 ÿ ÿ ÿ5 7ÿ<98;<90ÿ8975JÿE&*%++&ÿFDÿE%LMNÿ(0ÿA%&+/BÿCÿ A.-DÿE%$F'DGÿO5ÿ ÿ ÿ897ÿ870ÿ899 ÿÿ ÿ 0ÿ ÿ 34567893 46ÿ8 ÿ66 8ÿ83ÿ89ÿ316ÿ46 ÿ3ÿ3ÿ636ÿ3 ÿ86ÿ7 6ÿ ÿ !"# ÿ $ÿ%ÿ &!'# ($ÿ()ÿ*+,-++./0.ÿ ÿ ÿ 234567ÿ8399ÿÿ ÿ :689893 6ÿ ÿ38696ÿ396ÿ389;ÿ376 8893 ÿ3ÿ ÿ7 96ÿ73 8ÿ <=>ÿ?3ÿ@@ÿ8ÿABCDÿE63 6 8ÿ366ÿ3ÿ67997ÿ34567893 ÿ83ÿ86ÿ86ÿ3ÿ3 8ÿ 3;8ÿFÿ9ÿ86ÿ6G686ÿ738ÿ6 3 46ÿ ÿ664Hÿ ÿ86ÿ9ÿÿ ÿ 8358IJ9K35ÿ ÿ L6ÿM 7796ÿN78ÿ698ÿ ÿ ÿ3ÿ6 3 46ÿ8836HOÿ66ÿ ÿ738ÿ3ÿ 776 ÿ7 9 8ÿP67893 ÿD0Q6RÿN7739;HSÿFÿ664HÿTEN?LSÿ9ÿ 8Sÿ:689893 6Oÿ U3893 ÿ3ÿ 8836HOÿ66ÿ ÿ73 8ÿFÿ ÿ ÿ838ÿ3ÿ*-V,+WV.V-ÿX Y $# $Zÿ *0[,[-0.W0ÿ)( ÿ) ÿ%$&ÿ*V,/\W.-+ÿ)( ÿ'( # ]ÿ#(ÿ^ ÿY% &ÿ# (!Z ÿ%$ÿ28_ÿ& Y( #ÿ#(ÿ ` # # ($ a ÿ'(!$ "a ÿK3I2ÿ%''(!$#ÿ)( ÿY (bY#ÿ& ^! b $#.ÿFÿ86ÿ46 76ÿ3ÿÿ 896H96ÿ3893 ÿ3ÿ696ÿQ66ÿN6 9cÿdÿ83ÿ86ÿE6fÿ3ÿ86ÿ=38RSÿ86ÿ=6ÿ3ÿ =38ÿ ÿ6 86ÿ5;6 8ÿ9ÿ773 76ÿ98ÿ89ÿe67993 ÿ ÿ KÿK9ÿ93ÿ34g646g.ÿ hi %$ÿ_.ÿ8( '( %$ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ d9 ÿjÿ=373 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ =96ÿP679ÿU 86ÿ kÿ ÿ L9ÿ3 8ÿ9ÿ7 7 86ÿ ÿ33 lÿQACÿÿcÿm@C0nnÿoÿADfÿÿcÿm@0nnnÿcÿDnRÿpÿmDSBDDq0ÿ ÿf ÿ: 8ÿ83ÿM 7796ÿE6ÿDDQRSÿ86ÿ 896 ÿ Hÿ6c6986ÿ6 8Hÿ3ÿ5;6 8ÿ4Hÿ99;ÿÿ5398ÿ38976ÿ 6 3 79;ÿ869ÿ9;8ÿ83ÿ66ÿ696ÿ 0ÿ ÿ
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.