Graham v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

01ÿ345ÿ617358ÿ 93ÿ3ÿ 5 ÿ ÿ    3ÿÿ5ÿ   ÿ 7 !"#ÿ$%&'%()ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +,-+.,ÿ/012134ÿ >K86Lÿ-H6M8NOÿ3NG76;ÿ>9;M9;N:ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ B8O6IPÿB6Q;RN;SÿTU4ÿTVTWÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ5678789:6;4ÿ ÿ <=ÿ ÿ ÿ -,>0,?10@ÿABÿ2,1+?2ÿ1CDÿÿ 2E31Cÿ-,0F.>,-4ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ06GH9:I6:7=ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ XYZ[\]ÿ_ÿ̀a]bccYcdÿa]bccYcÿebfÿghYi\dÿ_j̀d̀ÿkYYlhmln[dÿoedÿpYhÿ_[qmqmYc[hÿ̀ ÿ XYZ[\]ÿrYinsbZÿe[btmqqdÿuàÿ̀r[\bhqv[cqÿYpÿXiZqmw[dÿkbZ]mcnqYcdÿrjdÿpYhÿx[Z\Ycl[cq̀ÿ ÿ y!ÿ!ÿ  !z{ÿÿ !yÿ (ÿ ÿ ÿ A:ÿ3N;MKÿ|V4ÿTVT}4ÿ+6GO86ÿ/;NKN~ÿL8O6IÿNÿH678789:ÿL9;ÿM9~H6:GN789:ÿR:I6T̀;ÿ7K6ÿ CN789:NOÿFNMM8:6ÿ.:R;Sÿ>9~H6:GN789:ÿ5;9€;N~4ÿTÿE=-=>=ÿ‚UVVNNƒ|V4ÿ[qÿZ[„ ÿ7K6ÿ †FNMM8:6ÿ1M7‡ˆ=ÿ5678789:6;ÿNOO6€6Iÿ7KN7ÿGK6ÿGRLL6;6IÿNÿGK9ROI6;ÿ8:R;Sÿ;6ON76Iÿ79ÿ<NMM8:6ÿ NI~8:8G7;N789:ÿL9OO9‰8:€ÿN:ÿ8:LOR6:ŠNÿ<NMM8:6ÿGK6ÿ;6M68<6Iÿ9:ÿC9<6~Q6;ÿ|V4ÿTVTU=ÿ 5678789:4ÿ,>BÿC9=ÿ|=ÿA:ÿC9<6~Q6;ÿ|4ÿTVT}4ÿ.ÿ8GGR6IÿNÿI6M8G89:ÿN‰N;I8:€ÿM9~H6:GN789:ÿ 79ÿ5678789:6;ÿQNG6Iÿ9:ÿ7K6ÿ06GH9:I6:7‹GÿH;9LL6;=ÿ,>BÿC9=ÿTW=ÿÿ |Œ6MNRG6ÿ ÿ 7K8GÿD6M8G89:ÿM9:7N8:GÿNÿ;6NG9:6Iÿ6HON:N789:ÿL9;ÿ7K6ÿNM789:ÿ7NŽ6:ÿ8:ÿ7K8GÿMNG64ÿ87ÿ~RG7ÿQ6ÿ~NI6ÿ HRQO8MOSÿNMM6GG8QO6ÿN:Iÿ‰8OOÿQ6ÿH9G76Iÿ9:ÿ7K6ÿE:876Iÿ-7N76Gÿ>9R;7ÿ9LÿB6I6;NOÿ>ON8~Gÿ‰6QG8764ÿN:I9;ÿN7ÿ K77HGP‰‰‰=€9<8:L9=€9<NHHM9OO6M789:RGM9R;7G:N789:NOM9LM4ÿ8:ÿNMM9;IN:M6ÿ‰87Kÿ7K6ÿ,ƒ/9<6;:~6:7ÿ1M7ÿ9Lÿ TVVT=ÿÿE=-=>=ÿ‚ÿU}V|ÿ:976ÿTV|‘ˆÿB6I6;NOÿ3N:N€6~6:7ÿN:Iÿ5;9~9789:ÿ9Lÿ,O6M7;9:8Mÿ/9<6;:~6:7ÿ -6;<8M6Gˆ=ÿÿ ’“”ÿ•–—˜”ÿ™’–ÿy–š“”“"˜ÿ›“œœÿ–ÿ—ž—“œ—œ–ÿ™"ÿ—˜Ÿ"˜–ÿ›“™’ÿ—šš–””ÿ™"ÿ™’–ÿ“˜™–˜–™=ÿ.:ÿ NMM9;IN:M6ÿ‰87KÿFNMM8:6ÿ0RO6ÿ|‘Qˆ4ÿ5678789:6;ÿKNGÿ|ÿINSGÿ79ÿ8I6:78LSÿN:Iÿ~9<6ÿ79ÿ;6INM7ÿ~6I8MNOÿ9;ÿ97K6;ÿ 8:L9;~N789:4ÿ7K6ÿI8GMO9GR;6ÿ9Lÿ‰K8MKÿ‰9ROIÿM9:G787R76ÿN:ÿR:‰N;;N:76Iÿ8:<NG89:ÿ9LÿH;8<NMS=ÿ.L4ÿRH9:ÿ;6<86‰4ÿ.ÿ N€;66ÿ7KN7ÿ7K6ÿ8I6:78L86Iÿ~N76;8NOÿL87Gÿ‰87K8:ÿ7K8GÿI6L8:8789:4ÿ.ÿ‰8OOÿ;6INM7ÿGRMKÿ~N76;8NOÿL;9~ÿHRQO8MÿNMM6GG=ÿ ÿT ÿCN789:NOÿ>K8OIK99IÿFNMM8:6ÿ.:R;Sÿ1M7ÿ9Lÿ|¡‘W4ÿ5RQ=ÿ+=ÿC9=ÿ¡¡ƒWWV4ÿ|VVÿ-7N7=ÿU¢} }=ÿ26;68:NL76;4ÿL9;ÿ6NG6ÿ 9LÿM87N789:4ÿNOOÿG6M789:ÿ;6L6;6:M6Gÿ79ÿ7K6ÿFNMM8:6ÿ1M7ÿ‰8OOÿQ6ÿ79ÿ7K6ÿH6;78:6:7ÿGRQHN;N€;NHKÿ9LÿTÿE=-=>=ÿ‚ÿ UVVNNÿTV|‘ˆ=ÿ ÿ ÿ 3456567849ÿ ÿ87 ÿ64ÿÿ75678ÿ79ÿ557984ÿ44ÿ8ÿ75ÿ944568ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ 7ÿ   ÿ94!9448568ÿ " #$ÿ68ÿ44ÿ! ÿ""0 % ÿ68ÿ75& ÿ'!!65678ÿ79ÿ '557984ÿ(44ÿ8ÿ)7 5ÿ*+75678,&ÿ64ÿ-44.49ÿ""ÿ0$0ÿ/)(ÿ07 ÿ$ ÿ(9549794ÿ 784ÿ79ÿ3456567849ÿ94!94485ÿ5 5ÿ87ÿ!4978 ÿ75171!7245ÿ43!48 4ÿ494ÿ68994ÿ .ÿ54ÿ3456567849 ÿ/)(ÿ07 ÿ$ÿ5ÿ0 ÿ ÿ !78485ÿ94 54ÿ57ÿ54ÿ75678ÿ78ÿ-44.49ÿ"ÿ0$0ÿ686568ÿ5 5ÿ4ÿ6ÿ 5664ÿ54ÿ55579ÿ94694485ÿ79ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ7ÿ557984ÿ44ÿ8ÿ7 5ÿ94ÿ45ÿ68ÿ 56ÿ 4ÿ.5ÿ449968ÿ9475678ÿ7ÿ54ÿ785ÿ57ÿ.4ÿ 94ÿ57ÿÿ6945678 ÿ44!784ÿ 5ÿ0ÿ ÿ/)(ÿ07 ÿ" ÿ3456567849ÿ64ÿ87ÿ94!ÿ5494 549 ÿ ÿ 5ÿ 64ÿ94664 4ÿ54ÿ.668ÿ9479 ÿ.6554ÿ65ÿ3456567849ÿ9445 ÿ7 4ÿ954ÿ 944 54ÿ79ÿ792ÿ!49794ÿ597 ÿ0$0ÿ94ÿ94 78 .4ÿ8ÿ7865485ÿ65ÿ79ÿ!9679ÿ 454968 5678ÿ8ÿ6ÿ5494794ÿ.4ÿ 94ÿ49468 ÿ'8ÿÿ564ÿ.64ÿ57ÿ54ÿ 5549ÿ ÿ 78 .ÿ68994 ÿ ÿ (9549794ÿ3456567849ÿ ÿ!97664ÿ!!79568ÿ74855678ÿ79ÿÿ64ÿ 7 5 ÿ/)(ÿ07 ÿ$1ÿ5ÿ"1"" ÿ5ÿ68ÿ54ÿ94454ÿ75ÿ94 78 .4ÿ8ÿ494.ÿ 9ÿ 54ÿ68ÿ ÿ ÿ 4ÿ8 684ÿ'5ÿ!4965ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ7ÿ94 78 .4ÿ557984ÿ44ÿ8ÿ75ÿ79ÿ 4 ÿ6 85 ÿ945678ÿ"4& ÿ'7968ÿ5ÿ494.ÿ:4'07ÿ3456567849ÿ+75678ÿ79ÿ 557984ÿ44ÿ8ÿ75 ÿ;<=>=>?@<Aÿ>CÿDEDAF<FÿD==?A@<GCHÿI<<CÿD@FÿJ?C=Cÿ>@ÿ=K<ÿ=?=DLÿ DM?N@=ÿ?IÿOPQRSQTUQVÿWA<XA<C<@=>@YÿOPVRZVSU[\ÿ>@ÿI<<CÿXLNCÿOZRQZ]U^Vÿ>@ÿJ?C=C_ÿ=?ÿ `<ÿXD>Fÿ=KA?NYKÿD@ÿabcÿF<X?C>=ÿ=?ÿX<=>=>?@<AHCÿJ?N@C<LHCÿdefgaÿDJJ?N@=ÿI?AÿXA?MX=ÿ F>C`NAC<M<@=Uÿ58ÿ54ÿ.484ÿ7ÿÿ564164ÿ75678ÿ79ÿ94664 ÿ 44ÿ'!!4863ÿhÿ57ÿ54ÿ 44 ÿ7ÿ54ÿ)795&ÿ54ÿ)492ÿ7ÿ)795ÿ ÿ48549ÿi485ÿ68ÿ79 84ÿ 65ÿ56ÿ 46678 ÿ ÿ dgÿdjÿjeÿeklmkmlUÿ CnoA>D@ÿcUÿb?AJ?AD@ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ h968ÿp ÿ)79798ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ) 64ÿ9!46ÿ+ 549ÿ

ÿ39 85 ÿ ÿ57ÿ8 684ÿ44ÿ"" &ÿ54ÿ! 9564 ÿ ÿ43!4654ÿ4859ÿ7ÿi485ÿ.ÿ668ÿÿi7685ÿ87564ÿ 9487868ÿ5469ÿ96 5ÿ57ÿ442ÿ94664 ÿ ÿ 0ÿ