Gooding v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

1234562735893 3 5    5     5 7 !"#$%&''()* ,-./01.,23--45.36 ,K:8L/I8M:NOFNH98=,;=M;=N< 789:9:;<8=6 >? B:O8JPB8Q=RN=STU6VWVX /2,@[email protected] CEF1./2@G5,2/6 @8HI;<J8<9?

YZ[\^Z_`abcZdèfcZdèghdfijfkhllhmfnofpZai`bebeZ\`aq rlsmmhtqi`baZppfuqvqk`whabx`\bZpYymbez`f{hm[e\|bZ\fkjfpZa^`mwZ\}`\bq ~ !!!   ! T -<€ROST6VWV‚6,;<H9N<M83;;J:<ƒL:O8JNI89:9:;<L;=M;„I8<HN9:;<R<J8=9K8 .N9:;<NOGNMM:<85<R=S,;„I8<HN9:;<7=;ƒ=N„6VE?/?,?†‡WWNNˆTW6`bm`‰qV Š9K8 ‹ŒŽŽ‘ “Ž”•–6NOO8ƒ:<ƒ 9KN9HK8 HRLL8=8J N HK;ROJ8=:<R=S =8ON98J 9; >NMM:<8 —˜™”š”›œ‹žŸŒ“•–™—‘¡‘—”¢‘ŒŽŽ‘ž£¤š¥¦§¨‘ ©ª«¬­¬Ÿ¬†TWW?‡6NH 9K8=8HRO9;LN<989N<RHˆJ:IK9K8=:NˆŽ‘¨¤̈¨š®‘š”¤™™™œ‹¦—®•–¯ŽŽ”›š‘Ž‘¯‘—› €ROSTU6VWVV?789:9:;<N9T?0K8MNH8°NHNHH:ƒ<8J9;9K8/I8M:NO7=;M8HH:<ƒE<:9;L9K8 -LL:M8;L/I8M:NOFNH98=H? -<B8Q=RN=ST±6VWVX6@8HI;<J8<9L:O8JK:H@RO8ŠM²@8I;=9:<°K:MKK8 ³"´³µ¶µ·9KN9¸‘””›‘š™‘””¨‘—”›Ž›˜®‘™”›”¢™Ž™‘¬Ÿ‘™®›—‘”¹™Ÿ¤¨‘©œŽ– @8I;=9N9T?/I8M:L:MNOOS6@8HI;<J8<9ºš‘‘™”¢”¸‘””›‘š¹™¨¨‘º‘—£¤š¥™Ž›™™”‘” °:9K/5@G1NHJ8L:<8JQS9K8GNMM:<85<R=S0NQO8?»}qN9Xˆ±ŠM:9:<ƒV,?B?@?††TWW?‡ŠN²6 T½8MNRH89 K:H@RO:<ƒM;<9N:<HN=8NH;<8J8¾ION<N9:;<L;=9K8NM9:;<9N¿8<:<9K:HMNH86:9„RH9Q8„NJ8 IRQO:MOSNMM8HH:QO8N<J°:OOQ8I;H98J;<9K8E<:98J/9N98H,;R=9;LB8J8=NO,ON:„HÀ°8QH:986N<JÁ;= N9K99IHPÁÁ°°°?ƒ;>:<L;?ƒ;>ÁNIIÁM;OO8M9:;<ÁRHM;R=9HÁ<N9:;<NOÁM;LM6:<NMM;=JN<M8°:9K9K82ˆ3;>8=<„8<9 1M9;LVWWV?E?/?,?†‡‚WT<;98ŠVWTU²ŠB8J8=NOFN<Nƒ8„8<9N<J7=;„;9:;<;L2O8M9=;<:M3;>8=<„8<9 /8=>:M8H²? Â÷ĵŴ·Æµ ÇÈÃ́ÉÊÃÈÈ˵ÅÌÅÃÈÅËȵÆ"Å´Í"´µÊÃÆÂų³µ··Æ"ƵÃ́ƵδµÆ#5<NMM;=JN<M8 °:9KGNMM:<8@RO8TUŠQ²6789:9:;<8=KNHTJNSH9;:J8<9:LSN<J„;>89;=8JNM9„8J:MNO;=;9K8=:<L;=„N9:;<6 9K8J:HMO;HR=8;L°K:MK°;ROJM;<H9:9R98N<R<°N==N<98J:<>NH:;<;LI=:>NMS?5L6RI;<=8>:8°65Nƒ=889KN9 9K8:J8<9:L:8J„N98=:NOL:9H°:9K:<9K:HJ8L:<:9:;<65°:OO=8JNM9HRMK„N98=:NOL=;„IRQO:MNMM8HH?

V.N9 :;<NO,K:OJK;;JGNMM:<85<R=S1M9;LTÏUX67RQ?D?.;?ÏψXXW6TWW/9N9?‡±‚‚?C8=8:<NL98=6L;=8NH8 ;LM:9N9:;<6NOOH8M9:;<=8L8=8<M8H9;9K8GNMM:<81M9°:OOQ89;9K8I8=9:<8<9HRQIN=Nƒ=NIK;LVE?/?,?† ‡WWNNŠVWTU²?

3453675589         4   44 48 8 34! 46"353653#5$! 4 663453653%53558 '(*+,- ./0,12.(3,(4512.1+4+.(6(347,,*+3,(8,./9,8.93:'/+(34764 ;<=>=>?@<A>B<@=>=C<D=?E?FG<@BH=>?@I JKJLLMMNOPNPOI BQRA>H@SIT?AE?AH@ #U8V 4 V! 4W