United States Court of Federal Claims, 2026

Baird v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

Baird v. Secretary of Health and Human Services
United States Court of Federal Claims · Decided March 26, 2026 · Brian H. Corcoran
Baird v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

Opinion

01ÿ345ÿ617358ÿ 93ÿ3ÿ 5 ÿ ÿ    3ÿÿ5ÿ   ÿ 7 !"#ÿ$%&'('%)ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +,-./ÿ0,1-23ÿ >L75Mÿ=I5N7OPÿFOH65:ÿ>8:N8:O9ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ456767895:3ÿ B7P5JQÿB5R:SO:TÿUV3ÿWVWXÿ ;<ÿ ÿ ÿ =.>-.?,-@ÿABÿC.,D?Cÿ,/2ÿÿ ÿÿ CEF,/ÿ=.-G1>.=3ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ-5HI89J596<ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ YZ[\]ÿ_[`aZbcÿdeffZbÿgbhi[fcÿYYjcÿkbZl]ZbcÿjmcÿanbÿjZo[o[n`Zbpÿ ÿ dhqZfr`ÿsZZtlcÿupvpÿkZwhboxZ`oÿnaÿyelo[zZcÿshl][`\on`cÿk{cÿanbÿ|Zlwn`qZ`opÿ ÿ ÿ }!ÿ!ÿ  !~ÿÿ !}ÿ %ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ A9ÿ€O9SO:TÿUU3ÿWVWU3ÿ+O:59ÿ0O7:JÿM7P5JÿOÿI5676789ÿM8:ÿN8I59HO6789ÿS9J5W:ÿ6L5ÿ /O6789OPÿGONN795ÿ19‚S:Tÿ>8I59HO6789ÿ4:8ƒ:O3ÿ„WÿE<=<><ÿ†VVOO‡UV3ÿZoÿlZˆpÿ‰6L5ÿ ŠGONN795ÿ,N6‹Œ<ÿ456767895:ÿOPP5ƒ5Jÿ6LO6ÿHL5ÿHSMM5:5JÿOÿHL8SPJ5:ÿ79‚S:Tÿ:5PO65Jÿ68ÿ;ONN795ÿ OJ797H6:O6789ÿ‰Š=1-G,‹ŒÿM8PP879ƒÿO9ÿ79MPS59ŽOÿ;ONN795ÿHL5ÿ:5N57;5Jÿ89ÿAN68R5:ÿUU3ÿ WVU<ÿ45676789ÿO6ÿU<ÿA9ÿAN68R5:ÿW†3ÿWVW†3ÿ1ÿ7HHS5JÿOÿ:SP79ƒÿ89ÿ59676P5596ÿM79J79ƒÿ456767895:ÿ 59676P5Jÿ68ÿN8I59HO6789<ÿ.>Bÿ/8<ÿW<ÿÿA9ÿ/8;5R5:ÿU3ÿWVW‘3ÿÿ1ÿ7HHS5JÿOÿJ5N7H789ÿ OO:J79ƒÿJOOƒ5Hÿ68ÿ456767895:ÿM8PP879ƒÿR:75M79ƒÿRTÿ6L5ÿIO:675H<ÿ.>Bÿ/8<ÿ„<ÿ ÿ Uÿ ÿ 05NOSH5ÿ6L7Hÿ25N7H789ÿN896O79HÿOÿ:5OH895Jÿ5’IPO9O6789ÿM8:ÿ6L5ÿON6789ÿ6O“59ÿ79ÿ6L7HÿNOH53ÿ76ÿSH6ÿR5ÿOJ5ÿ ISRP7NPTÿONN5HH7RP5ÿO9Jÿ7PPÿR5ÿI8H65Jÿ89ÿ6L5ÿE9765Jÿ=6O65Hÿ>8S:6ÿ8MÿB5J5:OPÿ>PO7H”ÿ5RH7653ÿO9J•8:ÿ O6ÿÿL66IHQ••<ƒ8;79M8<ƒ8;•OII•N8PP5N6789•SHN8S:6H•9O6789OP•N8MN3ÿ79ÿONN8:JO9N5ÿ76Lÿ6L5ÿ.‡–8;5:9596ÿ ,N6ÿ8MÿWVVW<ÿ„„ÿE<=<><ÿÿ†‘VUÿ9865ÿ‰WVUŒÿ‰B5J5:OPÿFO9Oƒ5596ÿO9Jÿ4:886789ÿ8Mÿ.P5N6:897Nÿ–8;5:9596ÿ =5:;7N5HŒ<ÿ —˜™ÿš›œ™ÿž—›ÿ}›Ÿ˜™˜"ÿ ˜¡¡ÿ¢›ÿœ£œ˜¡œ¢¡›ÿž"ÿœ¤"›ÿ ˜ž—ÿœŸŸ›™™ÿž"ÿž—›ÿ˜ž›¥›ž#ÿ19ÿ ONN8:JO9N5ÿ76LÿGONN795ÿ-SP5ÿU‰RŒ3ÿ456767895:ÿLOHÿU„ÿJOTHÿ68ÿ7J5967MTÿO9Jÿ8;5ÿ68ÿ:5JON6ÿ5J7NOPÿ8:ÿ86L5:ÿ 79M8:O67893ÿ6L5ÿJ7HNP8HS:5ÿ8MÿL7NLÿ8SPJÿN89H676S65ÿO9ÿS9O::O965Jÿ79;OH789ÿ8MÿI:7;ONT<ÿ1M3ÿSI89ÿ:5;753ÿ1ÿ Oƒ:55ÿ6LO6ÿ6L5ÿ7J5967M75JÿO65:7OPÿM76Hÿ76L79ÿ6L7HÿJ5M79767893ÿ1ÿ7PPÿ:5JON6ÿHSNLÿO65:7OPÿM:8ÿISRP7NÿONN5HH<ÿ ÿ Wÿ/O6789OPÿ>L7PJL88JÿGONN795ÿ19‚S:Tÿ,N6ÿ8MÿUX3ÿ4SR<ÿD<ÿ/8<ÿ‡XXV3ÿUVVÿ=6O6<ÿ†¦‘‘<ÿC5:579OM65:3ÿM8:ÿ5OH5ÿ 8MÿN76O67893ÿOPPÿH5N6789ÿ:5M5:59N5Hÿ68ÿ6L5ÿGONN795ÿ,N6ÿ7PPÿR5ÿ68ÿ6L5ÿI5:679596ÿHSRIO:Oƒ:OILÿ8Mÿ„WÿE<=<><ÿÿ †VVOOÿ‰WVUŒ<ÿ ÿ 3456567849ÿ ÿ87 ÿ64ÿÿ75678ÿ79ÿ557984ÿ44ÿ8ÿ75ÿ944568ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ 7ÿ0 ÿ94!9448568ÿ"#$ "ÿ79ÿ44ÿ8ÿ"%"" ÿ79ÿ75& ÿ3456567849ÿ '!!65678ÿ79ÿ(44ÿ8ÿ)75ÿ64ÿ*44+49ÿÿ00 ÿ,)(ÿ-7 ÿ $ ÿ(9549794ÿ 784ÿ79ÿ3456567849ÿ94!94485ÿ5 5ÿ87ÿ!4978 ÿ75.7.!7/45ÿ40!48 4ÿ494ÿ68994 ÿ ,)(ÿ-7 ÿ $ÿ5ÿ0 ÿÿ ÿ !78485ÿ94 54ÿ57ÿ54ÿ75678ÿ78ÿ28 9ÿ"ÿ00#ÿ94!9448568ÿ5 5ÿ4ÿ6ÿ 5664ÿ5 5ÿ54ÿ55579ÿ94694485ÿ79ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ7ÿ557984ÿ44 ÿ8ÿ75ÿ94ÿ45ÿ 68ÿ56ÿ 4ÿ+5ÿ449968ÿ9475678ÿ7ÿ54ÿ785ÿ57ÿ+4ÿ 94ÿ57ÿÿ6945678 ÿ !78485ÿ14 !784ÿ57ÿ375678ÿ5ÿ0.ÿÿ8 0ÿ,)(ÿ-7 ÿ ÿ3456567849ÿ64ÿ87ÿ94!ÿ 5494 549 ÿ ÿ 568ÿ786494ÿ54ÿ75678ÿ78ÿ 65ÿ54ÿ685764ÿ8ÿ7549ÿ!977ÿ64ÿ68ÿ 78845678ÿ6ÿ68ÿÿ945678ÿ68ÿ54ÿ785ÿ7ÿ44ÿ57ÿ+4ÿ 94ÿ!!97!9654ÿ79ÿ54ÿ 78ÿ45ÿ795ÿ+47 ÿ ÿ 7879:;<;ÿ ÿ > 4ÿ? 684ÿ'5ÿ!4965ÿ8ÿ 9ÿ7ÿ94 78 +4ÿ557984ÿ44 ÿ8ÿ75 ÿ@45678ÿ " 4& ÿ)784ÿ5ÿ+65ÿ44ÿ944 5ÿ5 5ÿ684ÿ7854!79847ÿ8ÿ!466ÿ +668ÿ9479ÿ686568ÿ54ÿ49564ÿ!49794ÿ54ÿ8+49ÿ7ÿ79ÿ40!484ÿ78ÿ54ÿ 49564ÿ8ÿ54ÿ8 4ÿ7ÿ54ÿ!4978ÿ!497968ÿ54ÿ49564 ÿABBÿADEFGÿEHÿABIJKÿLMÿNBDOPQÿ RÿNSTHÿABUEVHÿ ÿ(4 ÿ) ÿ"ÿ"#." ÿ0 & ÿ)784ÿ 7ÿ875ÿ684ÿ68ÿ5469ÿ44ÿ 944 5ÿ79ÿ5 5ÿ94ÿW404 654ÿ948 85ÿ79ÿ754964ÿ8844 9 XÿADYPLGÿEHÿ ABIJKÿLMÿNBDOPQÿRÿNSTHÿABUEVHÿÿ( ÿ" " ÿ" 0"ÿ(4 ÿ)69 ÿ"%%&ÿ7568ÿNBGVOBKÿEHÿ ZI[BUQDUPÿ$#"ÿ\ @ ÿ$0$ÿ$$ÿ"% && ÿ65ÿ6ÿW4ÿ6568ÿ54ÿ!46ÿ 549ÿ6945678ÿ57ÿ 944ÿ54ÿ79ÿ57ÿÿ8+49ÿ5 5ÿ68ÿ]49^ÿ40!496484ÿ8ÿ_485ÿ]6^ÿ94 78 +4ÿ79ÿ 54ÿ79/ÿ784 XÿàHÿ5ÿ" 00 ÿ(9549794ÿ54ÿ!46ÿ 549ÿ ÿ944ÿÿ44ÿ9445ÿ VSDÿVbLGPBÿ! 95ÿ97ÿ7+_45678ÿ964ÿ+ÿ94!78485ÿ8ÿ6575ÿ!975668ÿÿ!456567849ÿ 87564ÿ8ÿ7!!795865ÿ57ÿ94!78 ÿABBÿADcBOODÿEHÿABIJKÿLMÿNBDOPQÿRÿNSTHÿABUEVHÿ #ÿ(4 ÿ ) ÿ0"ÿ0%ÿ0%& ÿ'ÿ!46ÿ 549ÿ844ÿ875ÿ48 4ÿ68ÿÿ684.+.684ÿ8 6ÿ7ÿ !456567849ÿ44ÿ!!65678ÿ 48ÿ9468ÿ44 ÿdULB[BOVIQBGÿEHÿABIJKÿLMÿNBDOPQÿRÿNSTHÿ ABUEVHÿ"0ÿ(4 ÿ) ÿ "%ÿ 0%ÿ0""& ÿ ÿ > 4ÿ!456567849ÿW+4 9ÿ54ÿ+948ÿ7ÿ45+6 68ÿ54ÿ79ÿ40!484ÿ54ÿ954ÿ  94ÿ8ÿ54ÿ40!484ÿ68994 XÿeDVVLGÿEHÿABIJKÿLMÿNBDOPQÿRÿNSTHÿABUEVHfÿ0$ÿ) ÿ )5 ÿ$ 0ÿ$ $ÿ"%%"& ÿ> 4ÿ3456567849ÿW 7ÿ!94 485ÿ4 54ÿ!977ÿ]7ÿ54ÿ557984ÿ44ÿ 8ÿ75ÿ7 5^ÿ 5ÿ54ÿ564ÿ7ÿ54ÿ+6 678 XÿeDVVLGfÿ0$ÿ) ÿ)5 ÿ 5ÿ$ $ÿ8 " ÿ 3456567849ÿ78 4ÿW 7ÿ /4ÿÿ77ÿ65ÿ4795ÿ57ÿ404ÿ97ÿÿ44ÿ944 5ÿ79ÿ 0ÿ ÿ 3453ÿ567ÿ7897 7ÿ6753ÿ6ÿ3476 7ÿ797 56ÿ3ÿ5ÿ5ÿ576ÿÿ6537ÿ 659397ÿ73495ÿ ÿ537ÿ3ÿ7897ÿ94ÿ46ÿ6ÿ4 ÿ77ÿ  ÿ ! "ÿ #$%ÿ&'ÿ53ÿ#0#ÿ ÿ ())*+,-.ÿ0--1ÿ ÿ 247ÿ6537 ÿ673737ÿ6ÿ64ÿ7667ÿ3464ÿ5657ÿ567ÿ67557ÿ5ÿ 9 373ÿ34ÿ6ÿ66ÿ737653 ÿ5ÿÿ3476767ÿ7ÿ5567ÿ4767ÿÿ ÿ 8756ÿ347ÿ76ÿÿ46ÿ7ÿ9ÿ77ÿ347ÿ:;:<!ÿ53ÿÿ37ÿ737ÿ3ÿ 67ÿÿ557ÿ3ÿ7ÿ7897 7ÿ>ÿ5344ÿ3ÿ5ÿ767ÿÿ? ÿ@73376Aÿ B67ÿÿ'63ÿÿC557 ÿ7ÿDÿ%7ÿ565#ÿEFGÿHÿ##Iÿ@73376Aÿ87ÿ3ÿ 73Aÿ877ÿ3ÿB67ÿÿ'63ÿÿC557 ÿ7ÿ'73ÿ%Jÿ565#ÿEFGÿHÿ #Jÿ@73376Aÿ97ÿ7877ÿ5685307ÿ%7Jÿ46ÿ653ÿ347ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ 5ÿ%6%ÿ46ÿ653ÿ347ÿ67ÿ335ÿ57Kÿ46ÿEFGÿHÿ7#ÿ53ÿ%LM%Jÿ ÿ Nÿ5 7ÿ95953ÿ7 ÿ3ÿ97ÿ37ÿ73ÿ6756ÿ347ÿ35ÿ75ÿ 494ÿÿ457ÿ67ÿ34 ÿ5376ÿ64ÿ5ÿ9ÿ5ÿ3476767ÿ556ÿ77ÿ5 9537ÿ 34ÿ3453ÿ354ÿÿÿEFGÿHÿ7#ÿ53ÿ%0ÿ5ÿ%$ÿH6ÿ5ÿ9ÿ93ÿ37ÿ 73ÿ 9953ÿ34ÿ@73376ÿ5ÿ6756ÿ535ÿ63ÿ97353ÿ94ÿ ÿ55 3ÿ6ÿ7ÿ795653 ÿ494ÿÿ5ÿ7ÿ5567ÿÿÿ? Oÿ7ÿPQRÿ53ÿ %%ÿS7367ÿ537ÿ%6T%LT5655ÿ%%TKT5655ÿ%%T%6T5655Uÿ ÿ 93ÿ ÿ67557ÿ6ÿ97ÿ3ÿ7ÿÿ94ÿ37ÿ67ÿ347ÿ53376ÿÿ 557ÿÿ34 ÿ95 7ÿ9ÿ457ÿ737#ÿ76 ÿ95 7ÿS494ÿ5ÿ6755ÿ7ÿ 9567ÿ3ÿ37 ÿ73ÿÿ34 ÿ53376Uÿÿ494ÿ53367ÿ457ÿ59947ÿ34 ÿ35 4ÿ 67ÿ79737ÿÿ 0ÿ ÿ ÿ335ÿÿ959537ÿ5 ÿ Vÿ57Kÿ46ÿ7ÿÿLT%7T565#ÿS%$ÿ7367Uÿ5ÿKT%JT565#ÿS%#ÿ7367Uÿ ÿ53367ÿW74ÿG76ÿ53ÿ5ÿ6537ÿÿX06666ÿÿEFGÿHÿ7#ÿ53ÿ%LM%Jÿ ÿ# ÿ'795ÿ5 376ÿ5ÿ7ÿ956 ÿ3ÿ53367ÿ766 ÿ 56ÿ354ÿ3ÿ7376 7ÿÿ46ÿ567ÿ 7897 7ÿ? ÿ?<Y:; ÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ <!:^ÿ_ÿ `aRÿ? bZRÿ0ÿG0ÿ%7%Lÿ%7%JM%75%ÿSG7ÿF6ÿ%KK0Uÿ ÿ 7ÿ? Oÿ RcOÿdP![;YÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ <!:^ÿ_ÿ `aRÿ? bZROÿHÿ5%M%#5%eÿSH ÿ5#ÿ5657UÿS%56ÿ5ÿL6ÿ46ÿ 7ÿ6ÿ653ÿ5ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ5ÿ67  7ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ677937UIÿf[g! !!< QÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ <!:^ÿ_ÿ `aRÿ? bZROÿHÿ5#M6$67eÿSD7ÿ5#ÿ5657UÿSKLÿ5ÿ7Kÿ46ÿ7ÿ6ÿ653ÿ5ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ 5ÿ67  7ÿ557ÿ67ÿ67 7937UIÿh;<: ÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ <!:^ÿ_ÿ `aRÿ? bZROÿHÿ55M6J5LeÿSD7ÿ %Jÿ5657UÿSL$ÿ5ÿ0%ÿ46ÿ7ÿ6ÿ653ÿ5ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ5ÿ67 7ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ67 7937UIÿ i!< [;ÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ <!:^ÿ_ÿ `aRÿ? bZÿHÿ55M677KeÿSD7ÿ%$ÿ5657UÿSJ7ÿ5ÿ#$ÿ46ÿ7ÿ6ÿ653ÿ 5ÿ557ÿ67ÿ5ÿ67 7ÿ557ÿ67ÿ677937UIÿg;^ ÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ <!:^ÿ_ÿ `aRÿ? bZROÿHÿ 50M%6$6eÿSD7ÿ%%ÿ5657UÿS#5ÿ5ÿJ6ÿ46ÿ7ÿ6ÿ653ÿ5ÿ557ÿ67ÿ5ÿ67  7ÿ557 ÿ 67ÿ677937UIÿdPbc ÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ <!:^ÿ_ÿ `aRÿ? bZROÿHÿ%KM%$L6eÿSC79ÿ5Lÿ565#UÿS%$Jÿ5ÿL7ÿ 46ÿ7ÿ6ÿ653ÿ5ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ5ÿ67  7ÿ557 ÿ67ÿ67 7937UIÿ?:;!j ÿZRÿ? [\"ÿ;]ÿ 0ÿ ÿ ÿ 34ÿ56789 ÿ ÿ8ÿÿ9ÿ5 9 ÿÿ4 9ÿ 8ÿ9ÿ  8ÿ868ÿ ÿ 6 ÿ0 ÿ7ÿ ÿ!5ÿ 8"9ÿ6ÿÿ 8ÿ64ÿÿ#$%&'(%)*$ÿ%,'-(.ÿ'/ÿ68 09ÿ 9 ÿ!5568ÿ1ÿÿ875ÿ ÿ97"ÿ68ÿ2 ÿ 8 ÿ468ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ6ÿ64ÿ ÿ6789ÿ68ÿ56667 77 6ÿ2ÿ.$(ÿ 85 ÿ975ÿÿ58699: :26 8ÿ8756ÿ 5ÿ1ÿ "ÿ"6 8ÿ6ÿ6 ÿ48ÿ5 789ÿ ÿ6 82ÿ 5ÿ2ÿ9ÿ68;ÿ67ÿ 8<78ÿ" ÿ6ÿ5ÿ9ÿÿ=8 ÿ:9  ÿ5567>ÿÿ 4ÿÿ9 545ÿ 5ÿ 62?56 2ÿ9;ÿ8ÿ6ÿ9ÿT6 ÿ972:8 ÿ64ÿ68;ÿ 8468" ÿ6ÿ ÿ59 ÿABCDÿ EFDGHIDÿCJÿKÿEFLGMICNJÿNOÿPQQQRSSRÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ U$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ3[:7 80\ÿ 6 ÿ33ÿ3730 ÿ[[ ]ÿÿ6 3ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ 284ÿÿ8969 ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ^ÿ_%Zà&'(ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ37: [8[6\ÿ 6 ÿ33ÿ3730 ÿ[0 ÿÿe ]ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969 ÿ "  9ÿ 284ÿ89 5  ^ÿU%(&*$#fg'`(.ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ3[:7704\ÿh 8 ÿ38ÿ3730 ÿ 8ÿÿ ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ^ÿ_-*%($dÿZXÿY$bcdÿ '/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xiÿ 6 ÿ37:[0]]\ÿh 8 ÿ38ÿ3730 ÿ8 8ÿÿ7 4ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ 284ÿÿ8969 ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5 ^ÿY.'j$&ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xiÿ 6 ÿ[ :7643\ÿ  2 ÿ3 ÿ3730 ÿ[4 eÿÿ] [ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969 ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ 89 5 ^ÿkb̀V%#a&'(ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xiÿ 6 ÿ37:7860\ÿ 2 ÿ ÿ3730 ÿ 3ÿÿ8 eÿ6789ÿ 2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5 ^ÿlam%#a&ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.Vÿ WÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xiÿ 6 ÿ3[:7748\ÿ 2 ÿ4ÿ3730 ÿ[[ eÿÿ6 3ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ 8969 ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ^ÿn`**%ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ37:748 \ÿ 2 ÿ4ÿ 3730 ÿ8 7ÿÿ4 8ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ^ÿ o%p$#-&ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ37:[e08\ÿ35 ÿ[6ÿ373e ÿ[[ 7ÿÿ0 8ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ 84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ^ÿq$&.($#ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,Xÿ Y$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ37:7734\ÿr7 ÿ33ÿ373e ÿ8 77ÿÿ0 [7ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ 8969ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ^ÿs-('ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xÿ 6 ÿ[]:780e\ÿr7 ÿ[0ÿ 373e ÿ4 ]ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284 ^ÿla,`(`&.$#ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xÿ 6 ÿ[ : 7[]0\ÿh ÿe7ÿ373e ÿ[4 eÿÿe 4ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969 ÿ "  9ÿ 284ÿ89 5  ^ÿtV',&'(ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ33:73e0\ÿh ÿ[]ÿ373e ÿ 4ÿÿ3 4ÿ 6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ284ÿÿ8969 ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ^ÿkb̀$fU%(&$(ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ '/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z& ÿ 6 ÿ37:[ee]\ÿh ÿ[6ÿ373e ÿ[3 ÿÿ8 [ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ468ÿ84ÿÿ "  9ÿ 284ÿÿ8969ÿ "  9ÿ284ÿ89 5  ÿu 9 ÿ 5969ÿ5 ÿ68ÿ ÿ2 ÿ467ÿ6ÿ ÿvÿ 99ÿ 678ÿ 64ÿ   8ÿ "9ÿ  29 ÿ w68ÿ ÿ 9xww 646 6ww5656w7956789w 6 w5645 ÿ ÿ 8ÿ 5 79 ÿ  ÿ"67ÿ64ÿy599ÿ6789ÿ 9ÿ6ÿ9ÿ8679ÿ9ÿÿ6 8ÿ599ÿ1ÿÿ875 ÿ ÿ6789ÿ 2ÿ2ÿÿ6 8ÿ"67ÿ ÿ1ÿ6 89ÿ67ÿ ÿY$$iÿ  ÿU%Z`&ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xiÿ ÿ3[:74]e\ÿ3734ÿz{ÿ34e] 7eÿ  ÿ ÿ9 5 ÿh98 ÿr7ÿe[ÿ3734 ÿÿÿe7ÿ 85 ÿ8756 ÿÿ ÿ6 ÿ9 5ÿ" 989ÿ8ÿ 8"ÿ6ÿ"6ÿ 85  ÿ87569ÿ6ÿ6789ÿ2ÿ86 ÿ ÿ8756ÿ9ÿ 97445ÿy  ÿY$$iÿ  ÿ|))'..ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&Xiÿ[e4ÿ  ÿ ÿ[76ÿ[[[ÿ37[6 ^ÿ k%d,'ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿU-,XÿY$#Z&iÿ[3 ÿ  ÿ ÿ8 [ÿ673:670ÿ37[8 ^ÿY%)$**%ÿZXÿY$bcdÿ'/ÿU$%*.VÿWÿ U-,XÿY$#Z&Xiÿ]8ÿ  ÿ ÿ37[ÿ3[0ÿ377 ÿÿ ÿ] ÿu 9ÿ"67ÿ9ÿ5 57ÿ9ÿ4669xÿ34 ÿ89 ÿyÿ5e77 77ÿyÿ [7 ÿ}ÿ5666 77 ÿ ÿ 0ÿ ÿ 34456789ÿ5 4 ÿÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ  ÿ ÿÿ  ÿ !ÿ "#$ÿ%!ÿ0&ÿÿ''()*!ÿ+ÿ ÿÿ   ÿ,- ÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ  !ÿ.ÿ ÿÿ/ÿ ÿ,ÿÿ,0ÿÿ ÿÿ !ÿ ÿ 12 357ÿ ÿ 4ÿ5 ÿ6 ÿ ÿÿÿ ÿ,ÿ07ÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿ   ÿ  !ÿ8 ÿ90:;!ÿ6  0<ÿ.ÿ,0ÿ=+6%4<ÿÿ<ÿ7ÿ >ÿ ÿ07ÿ ÿÿ !ÿ.ÿÿÿÿ ÿ?@ABCDEFEGÿHIJKIJLJMNOMPÿ ?CDB@EQFARÿSTIÿSJJLÿUMVÿ?ABDAAFQGÿSTIÿWTLNLXÿNTÿYJÿKUOVÿNZIT[PZÿUMÿ3 \ÿVJKTLONÿNTÿ ]JNONOTMJI^LÿWT[MLJ_^Lÿ35143ÿUWWT[MNÿSTIÿKIT`KNÿVOLY[ILJ`JMNFÿ.ÿÿ, ÿ ÿÿ  0( ÿ ÿ ÿÿ:ÿ6aÿbÿÿÿ+eÿ ÿÿ#;<ÿÿ#cÿ ÿ #ÿÿÿ- ÿÿ  ÿÿÿd !ÿ ÿ 34ÿ3ÿ5ÿ56f868fFÿ LghIOUMÿ\FÿTIWTIUMÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ bÿi!ÿ# ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ # ÿ8 ÿ>ÿ eÿ  ÿ ÿÿ5 ÿ+ÿ99:;<ÿÿÿ 0ÿaÿ0ÿ ÿ- ÿ,0ÿ  ÿÿ-ÿ ÿ   ÿÿ ÿÿcÿ!ÿ 0ÿ ÿ

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.