Achanzar v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

358ÿÿ 01ÿ345ÿ61793ÿ 35 ÿ  ÿ 3ÿ  ÿ585  ÿ  ÿ 7  ÿ !"#ÿ$%&$'(()ÿ ÿ +ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ,-./-.01ÿ-23-45-.6ÿÿ ÿ +ÿ 2789:ÿ;<9=8>?ÿ,>@A9Bÿ2CB=CB>Dÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ E9A8A8CD9B6ÿ ÿ +ÿÿ F8?9GHÿ-IJI@AÿK6ÿLMLNÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ OPÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ;02.01-.QÿRFÿ30-S13ÿÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ -4Tÿ3U,-4ÿ;0.VW20;6ÿÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ .9@<CDG9DAPÿÿ +ÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ +ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ XYZ[\]^ÿ̀ab[ac]ÿdc`effge\h6ÿ,I??9BÿiB>j8?6ÿSSE6ÿTB9@79B6ÿE-6ÿ:CBÿE9A8A8CD9BPÿ kal]]mÿngeYglh6ÿUP;PÿT9<>BAo9DAÿC:ÿpI@A8=96ÿq>@78DJACD6ÿT26ÿ:CBÿ.9@<CDG9DAPÿ ÿ ÿ r!ÿ s r!tÿr tuÿ ÿ RDÿR=ACv9BÿLM6ÿLMLu6ÿ,@Pÿ,>BJ>B9Aÿ-=7>Dj>Bÿ:8?9Gÿ>ÿ<9A8A8CDÿ@99w8DJÿL=Co<9D@>A8CDÿIDG9Bÿ A79ÿ4>A8CD>?ÿV>==8D9ÿWDxIByÿ2Co<9D@>A8CDÿEBCJB>oÿz{V>==8D9ÿEBCJB>o|}Pÿ179ÿ<9A8A8CDÿ@99w@ÿ =Co<9D@>A8CDÿ:CBÿ8DxIB89@ÿ>??9J9G?yÿB9?>A9GÿACÿ79BÿR=ACv9BÿLu6ÿLMu~ÿB9=98<AÿC:ÿ>ÿ7Io>Dÿ <><8??Co>O8BI@ÿz{3EV|}ÿO>==8D96ÿ78=7ÿ8@ÿ=CDA>8D9Gÿ8DÿA79ÿV>==8D9ÿWDxIByÿ1>v?9ÿzA79ÿ{1>v?9|}6ÿ€Lÿ 2PFP.PÿÿuMMP‚z>}PÿE9A8A8CD9Bÿ>??9J9@ÿA7>Aÿ@79ÿ@I@A>8D9Gÿ>ÿ@7CI?G9Bÿ8DxIByÿB9?>A9GÿACÿO>==8D9ÿ >Go8D8@AB>A8CDÿz{;W.V-|}ÿ>@ÿ@9Aÿ:CBA7ÿ8DÿA79ÿ1>v?9ÿ>DGƒCBÿ>Dÿ>„8??>ByÿD9BO9ÿoCDCD9IBC<>A7yÿ >DGƒCBÿ@8JD8:8=>DAÿ>JJB>O>A8CDÿC:ÿ>ÿ=CDG8A8CDPÿ,CB9CO9B6ÿE9A8A8CD9Bÿ>??9J9@ÿA7>Aÿ@79ÿ9„<9B89D=9Gÿ B9@8GI>?ÿ9::9=A@ÿC:ÿA79ÿ=CDG8A8CDÿ:CBÿoCB9ÿA7>Dÿ@8„ÿoCDA7@Pÿÿ uÿ ÿ i9=>I@9ÿA78@ÿG9=8@8CDÿ=CDA>8D@ÿ>ÿB9>@CD9Gÿ9„<?>D>A8CDÿ:CBÿoyÿ>=A8CD@ÿ8DÿA78@ÿ=>@96ÿWÿ8??ÿ<C@Aÿ8AÿCDÿA79ÿUD8A9Gÿ;A>A9@ÿ 2CIBAÿC:ÿF9G9B>?ÿ2?>8o@ÿ9v@8A96ÿ8Dÿ>==CBG>D=9ÿ8A7ÿA79ÿ0/CO9BDo9DAÿ-=AÿC:ÿLMML6ÿ€€ÿUP;P2Pÿÿ‚†MuÿzLMuL}Pÿ-@ÿ <BCO8G9Gÿvyÿ€LÿUP;P2Pÿÿ‚MM>>uLzG}z€}zi}6ÿ7C9O9B6ÿA79ÿ<>BA89@ÿo>yÿCvx9=AÿACÿA79ÿG9=8@8CD‡@ÿ8D=?I@8CDÿC:ÿ=9BA>8Dÿ w8DG@ÿC:ÿ=CD:8G9DA8>?ÿ8D:CBo>A8CDPÿ;<9=8:8=>??y6ÿIDG9BÿV>==8D9ÿ.I?9ÿuˆzv}6ÿ9>=7ÿ<>BAyÿ7>@ÿ:CIBA99DÿG>y@ÿ8A78Dÿ78=7ÿ ACÿB9‰I9@AÿB9G>=A8CDÿ{C:ÿ>Dyÿ8D:CBo>A8CDÿ:IBD8@79GÿvyÿA7>Aÿ<>BAyHÿzu}ÿA7>Aÿ8@ÿ>ÿAB>G9ÿ@9=B9AÿCBÿ=Coo9B=8>?ÿCBÿ:8D>D=8>?ÿ 8Dÿ@Iv@A>D=9ÿ>DGÿ8@ÿ<B8O8?9J9GÿCBÿ=CD:8G9DA8>?ŠÿCBÿzL}ÿA7>Aÿ8D=?IG9@ÿo9G8=>?ÿ:8?9@ÿCBÿ@8o8?>Bÿ:8?9@6ÿA79ÿG8@=?C@IB9ÿC:ÿ78=7ÿ CI?Gÿ=CD@A8AIA9ÿ>ÿ=?9>B?yÿID>BB>DA9Gÿ8DO>@8CDÿC:ÿ<B8O>=yP|ÿV>==8D9ÿ.I?9ÿuˆzv}PÿRA79B8@96ÿA79ÿ7C?9ÿG9=8@8CDÿ8??ÿ v9ÿ>O>8?>v?9ÿACÿA79ÿ<Iv?8=Pÿ‹[Œÿÿ ÿ Lÿ179ÿV>==8D9ÿEBCJB>oÿ=Co<B8@9@ÿE>BAÿLÿC:ÿA79ÿ4>A8CD>?ÿ278?G7CCGÿV>==8D9ÿWDxIByÿ-=AÿC:ÿu~ˆN6ÿEIvPÿSPÿ4CPÿ~~NNM6ÿ uMMÿ;A>APÿ‚K†ˆ6ÿ=CG8:89Gÿ>@ÿ>o9DG9Gÿ>Aÿ€LÿUP;P2Pÿÿ‚MM>>uMÿA7BCIJ7ÿ‚€ÿzLMuL}ÿz{V>==8D9ÿ-=A|ÿCBÿ{A79ÿ-=A|}Pÿ WDG8O8GI>?ÿ@9=A8CDÿB9:9B9D=9@ÿ79B9>:A9Bÿ8??ÿv9ÿACÿÿ‚MM>>ÿC:ÿA79ÿ-=AÿzvIAÿ8??ÿCo8AÿA7>Aÿ@A>AIACByÿ<B9:8„}Pÿ ÿ 2345678379ÿ83734ÿ9 9ÿ399673ÿ449738ÿÿ3ÿ7ÿ6ÿ7ÿ693ÿ7ÿ83734ÿ9 9ÿ 93ÿ73ÿ438ÿ53996734ÿ338ÿ4683ÿ7ÿ6ÿ7ÿ693ÿ7ÿ83734ÿ9 9ÿ93ÿ73ÿ 4779ÿ938ÿ7ÿ678967ÿ78ÿ83734ÿ9 9ÿ53996734ÿ379ÿ678967ÿ4ÿÿ43 3ÿ 6ÿÿ73 3938ÿ7 ÿ 67393344ÿ69ÿ5934ÿ 3ÿ! 7977ÿ93ÿ63 49938ÿ 5649674ÿ338ÿ7ÿÿ495967ÿ"#49ÿ$ÿ0%0&'ÿ9 9ÿ93ÿ4434ÿ39337ÿ93!ÿ68ÿ3ÿ439938ÿ 78ÿ9 9ÿÿ83467ÿ468ÿ3ÿ379338ÿ 87ÿ399673ÿ6!5374967 ÿÿ ÿ (ÿ 3ÿ33 38ÿ93ÿ3ÿ78ÿ438ÿ567ÿ9 9ÿ33 ÿ(ÿ6783ÿ9 9ÿ93ÿ5934ÿ495967ÿ "4ÿ9938ÿ3396ÿ4ÿ#55378)ÿ#'ÿ4ÿ34673 ÿ(ÿ93363ÿ8659ÿ9ÿ4ÿ!ÿ83467ÿ7ÿ 87ÿ 8! 34ÿ67ÿ93ÿ93!4ÿ439ÿ69ÿ9337 ÿ ÿ  3ÿ495967ÿ 84*ÿ ÿ +ÿ#ÿ!5ÿ4!ÿ6ÿ-./0///1//ÿ96ÿ3ÿ5 8ÿ96ÿ7ÿ#23ÿ835649ÿ96ÿ3996734ÿ67434ÿ (45#ÿ679ÿ6ÿ56!59ÿ8443!379ÿ96ÿ399673 ÿÿ ÿ 695967ÿ7ÿ8 ÿ 4ÿ!679ÿ35343794ÿ6!5374967ÿ6ÿÿ8! 34ÿ9 9ÿ 68ÿ3ÿ 3ÿ 783ÿ63967ÿ9:"'ÿ6ÿ93ÿ#9 ÿÿÿ ÿ (ÿ5563ÿÿ; 73ÿ6!ÿ 8ÿ7ÿ93ÿ3 34938ÿ!679ÿ439ÿ69ÿ63ÿ96ÿ3ÿ! 83ÿ96ÿ 399673 ÿ(7ÿ93ÿ4373ÿ6ÿÿ!6967ÿ6ÿ33 ÿ?38ÿ5479ÿ96ÿ22<2ÿ#55378)ÿ=ÿ93ÿ23>ÿ6ÿ 93ÿ269ÿ4ÿ83938ÿ96ÿ3793ÿ8!379ÿ33 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ @Aÿ@CÿCDÿDEFGEGF1ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿH4Hÿ=7ÿ3 ÿ2667ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ=7ÿ3 ÿ2667ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ2 3ÿ653 ÿI 493ÿ ÿ

?ÿ ÿ 479ÿ96ÿ; 73ÿ23ÿ99"'ÿ93ÿ5934ÿ! ÿ3)53893ÿ379ÿ6ÿ8!379ÿÿ3ÿ7ÿ"393ÿ679ÿ6ÿ43593'ÿ ÿ7693ÿ37677ÿ93ÿ9ÿ96ÿ433>ÿ33 ÿ 0ÿ ÿ