United States Court of Federal Claims, 2026

Hager v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

Hager v. Secretary of Health and Human Services
United States Court of Federal Claims · Decided September 15, 2026
Hager v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

Opinion

58ÿ93

01ÿ345ÿ6173 3

5 ÿ 3ÿÿ585 ÿÿ ÿ   ÿ  ÿ 7  ÿ !"#ÿ%%&'()%*ÿ ÿ +ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ,-./0ÿ12/3.45ÿ6478/9ÿ,"93"94:ÿ ;<=!>ÿ?<@>ABÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ

C/8.8.":/9Bÿÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ

D#ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ <EFE78ÿ%)Bÿ%G%Hÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ

1>,A>I<A=ÿJKÿ?><LI?ÿÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿÿ <!Mÿ?N6<!ÿ1>A*O,>1Bÿÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ A/72":P/:8#ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ +ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿÿ ÿ

QRSTUÿQTWXYZ[\]^ÿ___^ÿ1.9.ÿ̀ÿ@5.a784PBÿLLCBÿA.3-a":PBÿ*<Bÿ0"9ÿC/8.8.":/9#ÿÿ ÿ

QbRUÿcTdeSRUÿfYee\X^ÿN#1#ÿM/2498a/:8ÿ"0ÿ;E78.3/Bÿg47-.:F8":BÿM,Bÿ0"9ÿA/72":P/:8#ÿÿ ÿ hiÿj i ijÿiÿ ÿÿ  iÿ ÿ  iklÿÿ ihÿ 'ÿ ÿ ÿ J:ÿ1/28/am/9ÿ%(Bÿ%G%%Bÿ;4n:/ÿ?4F/9ÿ0.5/Pÿ4ÿ2/8.8.":ÿ0"9ÿ3"a2/:74%8.":ÿE:P/9ÿ8-/ÿ!48.":45ÿ *433.:/ÿO:oE9nÿ,"a2/:748.":ÿC9"F94aBÿp%ÿN#1#,#ÿqÿ(GG44&'GBÿ/8ÿ7/r#ÿs8-/ÿt*433.:/ÿ<38uv#ÿ C/8.8.":/9ÿ455/F/Pÿ8-48ÿ7-/ÿ7E00/9/Pÿm.548/945ÿ8.::.8E7Bÿ-/49.:Fÿ5"77Bÿ4:w./8nBÿ4:PÿP/29/77.":ÿ47ÿ4ÿ 9/7E58ÿ"0ÿ9/3/.D.:Fÿ.:05E/:x4ÿ4:Pÿ2:/Ea"3"3345ÿD433.:/7ÿ":ÿ"9ÿ4m"E8ÿ1/28/am/9ÿ%pBÿ%G%G#ÿC/8.8.":ÿ stC/8#uvÿs>,Kÿ!"#ÿ'vyÿ<a/:P/PÿC/8#ÿs>,Kÿ!"#ÿ%Gv#ÿJ:ÿ64nÿ%zBÿ%G%)Bÿ4ÿP/3.7.":ÿ4{49P.:Fÿ 3"a2/:748.":ÿ8"ÿC/8.8.":/9ÿ{47ÿ.77E/Pÿs>,Kÿ!"#ÿ)|v#ÿ ÿ 'ÿ ÿ ~/34E7/ÿ8-.7ÿM/3.7.":ÿ3":84.:7ÿ4ÿ9/47":/Pÿ/w254:48.":ÿ0"9ÿ8-/ÿ438.":ÿ84/:ÿ.:ÿ8-.7ÿ347/Bÿ.8ÿaE78ÿm/ÿa4P/ÿ2Em5.35nÿ 433/77.m5/ÿ4:Pÿ{.55ÿm/ÿ2"78/Pÿ":ÿ8-/ÿN:.8/Pÿ1848/7ÿ,"E98ÿ"0ÿK/P/945ÿ,54.a7€ÿ{/m7.8/Bÿ4:P"9ÿ48ÿ -8827‚{ {{#F"D.:0"#F"D4223"55/38.":E73"E987:48.":453"03Bÿ.:ÿ433"9P4:3/ÿ{.8-ÿ8-/ÿ>&@"D/9:a/:8ÿ<38ÿ"0ÿ%GG%#ÿ ppÿN#1#,#ÿqÿ()G'ÿ:"8/ÿs%G'ƒvÿsK/P/945ÿ64:4F/a/:8ÿ4:PÿC9"a"8.":ÿ"0ÿ>5/389":.3ÿ@"D/9:a/:8ÿ1/9D.3/7v#ÿI-.7ÿa/4:7ÿ 8-/ÿM/3.7.":ÿ{.55ÿm/ÿ4D4.54m5/ÿ8"ÿ4:n":/ÿ{.8-ÿ433/77ÿ8"ÿ8-/ÿ.:8/9:/8#ÿO:ÿ433"9P4:3/ÿ{.8-ÿ*433.:/ÿAE5/ÿ'ƒsmvBÿ/43-ÿ2498nÿ -47ÿ0"E98//:ÿs'pvÿP4n7ÿ8"ÿ.P/:8.0nÿ4:Pÿa"D/ÿ8"ÿ9/P438ÿa/P.345ÿ"9ÿ"8-/9ÿ.:0"9a48.":Bÿ8-/ÿP.735"7E9/ÿ"0ÿ{-.3-ÿ{"E5Pÿ 3":78.8E8/ÿ4:ÿE:{4994:8/Pÿ.:D47.":ÿ"0ÿ29.D43n#ÿO0BÿE2":ÿ9/D./{BÿOÿ4F9//ÿ8-48ÿ8-/ÿ.P/:8.0./Pÿa48/9.45ÿ0.87ÿ{.8-.:ÿ8-.7ÿ P/0.:.8.":BÿOÿ{.55ÿ9/P438ÿ7E3-ÿa48/9.45ÿ09"aÿ2Em5.3ÿ433/77#ÿJ8-/9{.7/Bÿ8-/ÿ{-"5/ÿM/3.7.":ÿ{.55ÿm/ÿ4D4.54m5/ÿ8"ÿ8-/ÿ2Em5.3ÿ .:ÿ.87ÿ29/7/:8ÿ0"9a#ÿ ÿ% ÿ!48.":45ÿ,-.5P-""Pÿ*433.:/ÿO:oE9nÿ<38ÿ"0ÿ'zƒHBÿCEm#ÿL#ÿ!"#ÿzz&HHGBÿ'GGÿ1848#ÿ(|))#ÿ?/9/.:408/9Bÿ0"9ÿ/47/ÿ"0ÿ3.848.":Bÿ 455ÿ7/38.":ÿ9/0/9/:3/7ÿ8"ÿ8-/ÿ*433.:/ÿ<38ÿ{.55ÿm/ÿ8"ÿ8-/ÿ2/98.:/:8ÿ7Em2494F942-ÿ"0ÿp%ÿN#1#,#ÿqÿ(GG44ÿs%G'ƒvBÿ"a.88.:Fÿ 8-/ÿ7848E8"9nÿ29/0.w#ÿ 3456567849ÿ9467 ÿ64ÿ8ÿ685496ÿ44ÿ9445ÿÿ7ÿ ÿ 85496ÿ 75! ÿ5"5ÿ#ÿ 875ÿ$54ÿ 78ÿ%4794ÿ5"4ÿ$4&ÿ$7 45678'ÿ8ÿ %4485ÿ64ÿÿ4$78'ÿ 68!ÿ44ÿ9445ÿ ÿ7ÿ(0 ÿ 68ÿ 75! ÿ$74$564'ÿ5"4ÿ 44ÿ 75678! 'ÿ944568)ÿ68ÿ575ÿ*+,' -(0,ÿ 949448568)ÿ*.'.(-+ÿ68ÿ44ÿ8ÿ$75ÿ68$994ÿ%ÿ3456567849&ÿ7949ÿ$784'ÿ ÿ 3"6ÿ/68'ÿ'ÿ ÿ*.'0 .0+ÿ68ÿ44ÿ8ÿ$75ÿ68$994ÿ%ÿ3456567849&ÿ94485ÿ$784ÿ7ÿ 94$79'ÿ09ÿ178ÿ1796)42'ÿ ÿ95"49794'ÿ3456567849ÿ64ÿÿ6)84ÿ554485ÿÿ7ÿ 0 ÿ949448568)ÿ5"5ÿ"4ÿ68$994ÿ4978ÿ753737$445ÿ45484ÿ68ÿ5"4ÿ785ÿ7ÿ*66'0777('ÿ #"64ÿ94944854ÿ%ÿ ÿ/68'ÿ%968)68)ÿ5"4ÿ575ÿ94454ÿ#9ÿ57ÿ89:;<=:>?@:ÿABBÿDEFGÿ 5"6%65ÿ6,ÿÿ7ÿ(036 ÿ 4485ÿ554485ÿ7ÿ3456567849&ÿ4978ÿ$75 HÿIJKÿFBBÿ 85496ÿ 75ÿ5ÿ0737+ÿ$7856868)ÿ449ÿ6)4ÿ7ÿ$"4$4ÿ8ÿ94$465ÿ9454ÿ57ÿ598$5678ÿ 68768)ÿ/68ÿL#ÿ69'ÿLL ÿ ÿ

14 78485ÿ"ÿ94$54ÿ57ÿ5"4ÿ44ÿ 75678'ÿ9479568)ÿ5"5ÿ"4ÿ6ÿ5664ÿ5"5ÿ5"4ÿ55579ÿ 94694485ÿ79ÿÿ44ÿ#9ÿ94ÿ45ÿ68ÿ5"6ÿ$4'ÿ%5ÿ449968)ÿ9475678ÿ7ÿ5"4ÿ785ÿ57ÿ%4ÿ #94ÿ57ÿÿ6$945678ÿ14 78485&ÿ14 784ÿÿ7ÿ6ÿOÿ(, ÿ3456567849ÿ64ÿÿ94ÿ 946549568)ÿ"49ÿ749ÿ9445ÿ3456567849&ÿ14ÿÿ7ÿ( ÿ ÿ ÿ"4ÿ9464#4ÿ5"4ÿ%668)ÿ94$79ÿ %6554ÿ#65"ÿ3456567849&ÿ9445ÿ8ÿ68ÿÿ94$5678ÿ 68ÿ5"4ÿ785ÿ7ÿ44ÿ57ÿ%4ÿ#94ÿ 979654'ÿ79ÿ5"4ÿ9478ÿ45ÿ795"ÿ%47#ÿ ÿ ÿ

PQPRSTUTÿ ÿ

V"4ÿW$$684ÿX$5ÿ4965ÿ8ÿ#9ÿ7ÿ9478%4ÿ557984&ÿ44ÿ8ÿ$75ÿ79ÿ $$4 ÿ $685ÿY4$5678ÿ64 ÿ784ÿ 5ÿ %65ÿ44ÿ9445ÿ5"5ÿ68$4ÿ$7854 79847 ÿ8ÿ 4$66$ÿ%668)ÿ94$79ÿ686$568)ÿ5"4ÿ496$4ÿ49794'ÿ5"4ÿ8%49ÿ7ÿ"79ÿ45484ÿ78ÿ5"4ÿ 496$4'ÿ8ÿ5"4ÿ84ÿ7ÿ5"4ÿ4978ÿ497968)ÿ5"4ÿ496$4ÿABBÿADZ[\ÿZ]ÿAB^_`ÿGaÿbBDEKcÿdÿbJeD\ÿ ABfZF]'ÿ.ÿ4ÿÿ767'ÿ76(36.ÿ0 . ÿ784ÿ"7ÿ875ÿ68$4ÿ68ÿ5"469ÿ44ÿ9445ÿ"79ÿ5"5ÿ 94ÿ 45$4 64'ÿ94885'ÿ79ÿ75"49#64ÿ884$4 9!ÿADgKG\ÿZ]ÿAB^_`ÿGaÿbBDEKcÿdÿbJeD\ÿABfZF]'ÿ 7ÿ7ÿ66-'ÿ606ÿ4ÿ69ÿ6++7 ÿ7568)ÿbB\FEB`ÿZ]ÿh^iBfcDfK'ÿ,(6ÿjYÿ,0,'ÿ,7,ÿ6+.7 ÿ 5ÿ 6ÿ #4ÿ#65"68ÿ5"4ÿ 4$6ÿ549&ÿ6$945678ÿ57ÿ94$4ÿ5"4ÿ"79ÿ57ÿÿ8%49ÿ5"5'ÿ68ÿk"49lÿ 4549648$4ÿ8ÿm)485'ÿk6lÿ9478%4ÿ79ÿ5"4ÿ#794ÿ784!ÿnoÿ5ÿ606300ÿ95"49794'ÿ5"4ÿ 4$6ÿ549ÿÿ94$4ÿÿ44ÿ9445ÿFJDÿFpG\KB'ÿ95ÿ97ÿ7%m4$5678ÿ964ÿ%ÿ94 78485ÿ 8ÿ#65"75ÿ97668)ÿ456567849ÿ8756$4ÿ8ÿ7 795865ÿ57ÿ94 78ÿABBÿADIBEEDÿZ]ÿAB^_`ÿGaÿbBDEKcÿ dÿbJeD\ÿABfZF]'ÿ.(ÿ4ÿÿ0 6'ÿ0 +ÿ0 + ÿXÿ 4$6ÿ549ÿ844ÿ875ÿ48))4ÿ68ÿÿ6843%3684ÿ 86ÿ7ÿ456567849&ÿ44ÿ 6$5678ÿ#"48ÿ94$68)ÿ44ÿqfGBiBEF^cB\ÿZ]ÿAB^_`ÿGaÿbBDEKcÿdÿ bJeD\ÿABfZF]'ÿ6 0ÿ4ÿÿ-6+'ÿ-0+ÿ0 66 ÿ ÿ

3456567849ÿ %49ÿ5"4ÿ%948ÿ7ÿ45%6"68)ÿ5"4ÿ"79ÿ45484'ÿ5"4ÿ954ÿ$"9)4'ÿ8ÿ5"4ÿ 45484ÿ68$994!ÿrDFFG\ÿZ]ÿAB^_`ÿGaÿbBDEKcÿdÿbJeD\ÿABfZF]'ÿ0,ÿÿ5ÿ,.0'ÿ,.,ÿ6++6 ÿ 3456567849ÿ "7ÿ94485ÿ454ÿ977ÿk7ÿ5"4ÿ557984&ÿ44ÿ8ÿ$75ÿ7)"5lÿ5ÿ5"4ÿ564ÿ7ÿ 345ÿ678966 ÿÿ3ÿÿÿ533 56ÿ765ÿ647ÿ9 5ÿÿ ÿ 34ÿ5 3ÿ3ÿ5 75ÿ 9ÿÿ 55ÿ57563ÿ476ÿ343ÿ5ÿ5 566!5"ÿ573"ÿÿ345#65ÿ7 5566$"ÿ%763ÿ6ÿÿ#$5ÿ ÿ&!35ÿ&35ÿ534$ÿ6ÿ8 35ÿ3ÿ5 75ÿ674ÿ476ÿ 9ÿ46ÿ 55ÿ678966 ÿ'()*+(,"ÿ -ÿ./ÿ3ÿ0ÿ ÿ

01123456ÿ8559ÿ ÿ :45ÿ47$ÿ356ÿ575635ÿ ÿ67&&3 ÿ&5 6ÿ5ÿ56 85ÿÿ 66353ÿ#34ÿ & ÿ5359 3 6ÿÿ64ÿ85ÿ#5ÿ; #5!5"ÿ345ÿ356ÿ ÿ<6ÿ= 9ÿÿ>ÿ?  75@ÿ 5ÿ 3ÿ 7$ÿ 66353ÿ#34ÿ#43ÿ345$ÿ4!5ÿ855ÿ&5! 76$ÿ#5ÿ ÿ

Aÿ<6ÿ= 9"ÿ533 5ÿ575636ÿBCCCCÿ&5ÿ47ÿ ÿ395ÿ85ÿÿDCDDEÿBDCCCÿ&5ÿ 47ÿ ÿ395ÿ85ÿ ÿDCD0EÿBCCCÿ&5ÿ47ÿ ÿ395ÿ85ÿ ÿDCDEÿÿBFCCCÿ&5ÿ47ÿ ÿ 395ÿ85ÿÿDCDFÿG359ÿ< 3ÿ3ÿ0ÿ:45ÿ&&65ÿDCDDHD0ÿ356ÿ5ÿ56 85ÿÿ 66353ÿ #34ÿ& ÿ5359 3 6"ÿÿ#ÿ3455 5ÿ85ÿ&35ÿ455 ÿGÿ345ÿI 5ÿ 9ÿ93356"ÿ 4#5!5"ÿ<6ÿ= 9ÿ46ÿ855ÿ598765ÿBFCCCÿ&5ÿ47ÿ ÿ#  ÿ&5 95ÿ ÿDCD"ÿÿ BCCCÿ&5ÿ47ÿ ÿ#  ÿ&5 95ÿÿDCDFÿJ((ÿK(L)M)(NÿPQÿJ(RS,ÿTUÿ'(M+VWÿXÿ'YZM)ÿJ(LP*Q"ÿ [ ÿDDH\]I"ÿDCDFÿ=^ÿ]FFD"ÿ3ÿ_Dÿ`A5ÿaÿ/&5ÿ<63ÿA58ÿD-"ÿDCDFbEÿcLRW(LÿPQÿJ(RS,ÿTUÿ '(M+VWÿXÿ'YZM)ÿJ(LP*Q"ÿ[ ÿD0H]C\I"ÿDCDFÿ=^ÿ0-\]CD\"ÿ3ÿ_Dÿ̀A5ÿaÿ/&5ÿ<63ÿ[ !ÿ\"ÿ DCDFbEÿdMRRMÿPQÿJ(RS,ÿTUÿ'(M+VWÿXÿ'YZM)ÿJ(LP*Q"ÿ[ ÿD0H0I"ÿDCDFÿ=^ÿ0-0F"ÿ3ÿ_Dÿ̀A5ÿ aÿ/&5ÿ<63ÿ[ !ÿ\"ÿDCDFbÿ ÿ :455ÿ6ÿÿ9&85ÿ65&$ÿ853#55ÿ345ÿ35ÿ3ÿ#44ÿ>ÿ?  75@ÿ46ÿ855ÿ 598765ÿÿ345ÿ93356ÿ̀ 5ÿBF\CCÿ&5ÿ47ÿ ÿ#  ÿ&5 95ÿÿDCDFbÿÿ345ÿ35ÿ67 43ÿ 455 ÿ̀BF-0ÿ&5ÿ47bÿA ÿ< 3ÿ3ÿEÿ*((eÿ(QfQ"ÿgTLhM+(ÿPQÿJ(RS,ÿTUÿ'(M+VWÿXÿ'YZM)ÿJ(LP*Q"ÿ[ ÿ DHC0DI"ÿDCD-ÿ=^ÿ\0FC"ÿ3ÿ_ÿ̀A5ÿaÿ/&5ÿ<63ÿi ÿ-"ÿDCD-bEÿcLfY(VMÿPQÿJ(RS,ÿTUÿ'(M+VWÿ Xÿ'YZM)ÿJ(LP*Q"ÿ[ ÿDHCC\DI"ÿDCD-ÿ=^ÿ]-C"ÿ3ÿ_Dÿ̀A5ÿaÿ/&5ÿ<63ÿi ÿDC"ÿDCD-bÿÿ ÿ

Gÿ ÿ ÿ56 ÿ3ÿ5!35ÿ 9ÿ3465ÿ& ÿ5359 3 6"ÿÿ3ÿ345#65ÿ6ÿ 3ÿ345ÿ &35ÿ ÿj/<ÿ3ÿ%763ÿ& ÿ35ÿ5359 3 6ÿ7&#ÿ ÿ67865753ÿ656ÿ J((ÿk(UU(L*T)ÿ!ÿJ(RS,ÿTUÿ'(M+VWÿXÿ'YZM)ÿJ(LP*"ÿ[ ÿ]HDI"ÿDCD0ÿ=^ÿ0\CFÿ̀A5ÿaÿ/&5ÿ <63ÿi ÿ]"ÿDCD0bÿl $"ÿGÿ4558$ÿ575ÿ834ÿl335$6ÿ356ÿ3ÿ85ÿ 66353ÿ#34ÿ345ÿ  59530 5ÿ56 6ÿl&&3 ÿ ÿ3465ÿ575ÿ356ÿ56736ÿ ÿÿ!5ÿ573 ÿ ÿ B"0\C ÿ[ ÿ%7639536ÿ5ÿ95ÿ3ÿ395ÿ85ÿ ÿ345ÿ9335"ÿ4#5!5ÿ:45ÿ33ÿ9 73ÿ ÿ 0ÿ ÿ :46ÿ9 73ÿ 6636ÿ ÿ57 ÿ<6ÿ= 96ÿÿ>ÿ?  75@6ÿ47$ÿ356ÿAÿ<6ÿ= 9"ÿ345ÿ573 ÿ 6ÿ735ÿ6ÿ #6mÿ̀`BCÿHÿBFCÿnÿB0Cbÿ ÿ0D0ÿ476ÿ85ÿÿDCDbÿoÿ̀`BFCÿHÿBCÿnÿB0Cbÿ ÿF\Fÿ476ÿ85ÿ ÿDCDFbÿnÿB"FCÿ573 ÿAÿ>ÿ?  75@"ÿ345ÿ573 ÿ6ÿ735ÿ6ÿ #6mÿ̀BF-0ÿHÿBF\ÿnÿB-bÿ ÿD\ÿ 476ÿ85ÿÿDCDFbÿnÿBDC0DCÿ573 ÿÿ 3445ÿ67ÿ84ÿ9 9 4ÿ5ÿÿ7 5 0 ÿ !"#$%&ÿ9 9 4ÿ37ÿ'5$ÿ( 9 )5ÿ3445ÿ*+5ÿ #,%0$,&ÿ9 9 4ÿ37ÿ-$ÿ.7 +4/)5ÿ3445$ÿ ÿ

0121342156ÿ85929ÿ ÿ :4667 4ÿ;95ÿ7< 4ÿ5+76 ÿ7+4 6967 ÿ37ÿ9**ÿ*94ÿ7565$ÿ= 64ÿ'76$ÿ96ÿ > 0,ÿ? <745ÿ9 ÿ7565ÿ73ÿ( 9 ÿ@9 ÿA ÿ@@Bÿ9 ÿ:4667 4)5ÿ7565CDÿEF;86ÿ0Gÿ?EBAÿH7$ÿ G">"Cÿ? <745ÿ9 ÿ7565ÿ73ÿI ÿJÿK*569ÿ@@:C$ÿ.457 4 6ÿ73344ÿ 7ÿ543ÿ78L467 ÿ67ÿ 6;4ÿ9645ÿ7ÿ97+ 65ÿ57+ ;6$ÿ(;*4ÿ=ÿ 4 49**Mÿ3 ÿ6;4ÿ7565ÿ4957 98*4ÿ9 ÿ94N+964*Mÿ 7+4 64ÿ?4$ $ÿ6;4ÿ3* ÿ344ÿ469 4ÿ3445ÿ9 ÿ7565ÿ9557964ÿ 6;ÿ7869 ÿ4 9*ÿ47 5Cÿ 7456ÿ4+67 5ÿ94ÿ9 9 64ÿ 6;ÿ4546ÿ67ÿ6;4ÿ7565ÿ9557964ÿ 6;ÿO ÿPQ89 ÿ:;$-$ÿ9ÿ 734557ÿ73ÿ'4  4ÿ9 ÿP**4 Mÿ9 ÿ=+ 7*7 Mÿ95ÿ 4**ÿ95ÿ6;754ÿ9557964ÿ 6;ÿP 4 ÿ E5;9 ;ÿ'-ÿ'IÿAPBIÿ9ÿ734557ÿ73ÿR74 9*ÿE 44 ÿH4+7*7 9*ÿI+ 4Mÿ9 ÿ O67*9M 7*7 MÿS49ÿ9 ÿH4QÿI+ 4M$ÿTUUÿ= 64ÿ'76$ÿ96ÿ00>0,$ÿ ÿ

WXYÿZ[\]X^ÿ ÿ :4667 4ÿ544Q5ÿ48+544 6ÿ37ÿ-$ÿPQ89)5ÿ7Qÿ96ÿ9 ÿ;7+*Mÿ964ÿ73ÿ %%&$ÿ= 64ÿ '76$ÿ96ÿ00>0G$ÿ-$ÿPQ89ÿ;7 4<4ÿ;95ÿ44964*Mÿ844 ÿ9 9 4ÿ %&&ÿ4ÿ;7+ÿ37ÿ;5ÿ7Qÿ ÿ 6;4ÿ_9 4ÿ:7 9$ÿ̀YaYÿbUc[^cdÿeYÿTUfghÿijÿkU]lmnÿoÿkpq]cÿTUXedYÿH7$ÿ!>,0G_ÿ"&"%ÿ(@ÿ ""!! &ÿ96ÿrGÿ?A4$ÿB*$ÿI4$ÿ'56$ÿs+*Mÿ ÿ"&"%Cÿ?549*ÿ9564ÿ3 ÿ9 ÿ;7+*Mÿ964ÿ73ÿ %&&ÿ 67ÿ84ÿ97 964ÿ <4 ÿ-$ÿPQ89)5ÿ4F44 4ÿ9 ÿ44 69*5CDÿtia]cÿeYÿTUfghÿijÿkU]lmnÿoÿ kpq]cÿTUXedYÿH7$ÿ">!0#_ÿ"&"%ÿ(@ÿ"%&%%0%ÿ96ÿr%ÿ?A4$ÿB*$ÿI4$ÿ'56$ÿs+*Mÿ"0ÿ"&"%Cÿ ?549*ÿ9564ÿ*56 ÿ 7ÿ9545ÿ ÿ;;ÿ-$ÿPQ89ÿ;95ÿ844 ÿ9 9 4ÿ9 ÿ;7+*Mÿ964ÿ73ÿ %&&ÿ ÿ 6;4ÿ_9 4ÿ:7 9ÿ9 ÿ5+854N+4 6*Mÿ4+ ÿ;5ÿ;7+*Mÿ964ÿ67ÿ6;5ÿ97+ 6CDÿZquijivZwwiÿeYÿ TUfghÿijÿkU]lmnÿoÿkpq]cÿTUXedYÿH7$ÿ">" _ÿ"&"%ÿ(@ÿ0&G """ÿ96ÿr ÿ?A4$ÿB*$ÿI4$ÿ'56$ÿ -4$ÿ#ÿ"&"%CDÿx^llUXÿeYÿTUfghÿijÿkU]lmnÿoÿkpqYÿTUXedYÿH7$ÿ,>,!%ÿ"&"Gÿ(@ÿ,&G 0%ÿ96ÿr ÿ ?A4$ÿB*$ÿI4$ÿ'56$ÿs+ 4ÿÿ"&"GC$ÿÿ ÿ (;*4ÿ=ÿ9ÿ 76ÿ9<454ÿ67ÿ9 9 ÿ-$ÿPQ89ÿ9ÿ; ;4ÿ;7+*Mÿ964ÿ ÿ3+6+4ÿ9545ÿ6;4ÿ7Qÿ ;4ÿ4374ÿ7 ÿ6;5ÿ9664ÿ7+ 4ÿ ÿ9ÿ7 64F6ÿ ÿ;;ÿ;4ÿ74ÿ6M9**Mÿ44<4ÿ6;4ÿ5* ;6*Mÿ *4554ÿ5+ÿ9 ÿ:4667 4ÿ;95ÿ 76ÿ7< 4ÿ4< 4 4ÿ5+334 6ÿ67ÿ45698*5;ÿ6;96ÿ9ÿ; ;4ÿ964ÿ5ÿ 4957 98*4ÿ;44$ÿP7 *Mÿ6;4ÿ964ÿ67ÿ84ÿ9 9 4ÿ;44 ÿ **ÿ84ÿ4+4ÿ67ÿ %&&$&&ÿ4ÿ;7+$ÿ ÿ

Pÿ3+6;4ÿ4+67 ÿ ÿ6;4ÿ;7+5ÿ8**4ÿ5ÿ9*57ÿ9 9 64$ÿ-$ÿPQ89ÿ*7 4ÿ0!$!ÿ;7+5ÿ ÿ 6;5ÿ9664ÿ574ÿ73ÿ;;ÿ4%4ÿ54 6ÿ7 *79 ÿ; ;* ;6 ÿ9 ÿ37966 ÿ4344 45ÿ7ÿ ÿ 49 ÿ;5ÿ8** ÿ569644 6$ÿ= 64ÿ'76$ÿ96ÿ00>0G$ÿ.4<4 ÿ73ÿ6;4ÿ8** ÿ47 5ÿ9 ÿ;5ÿ4F46ÿ 0ÿ ÿ ? ",G,$&&ÿyÿ !%!$&Cÿ>ÿ  00$#&ÿ4+67 ÿzÿ ,#!"$0&$ÿ ÿ% ÿ-$ÿPQ89ÿ*7 4ÿ97F964*Mÿ%ÿ;7+5ÿ37ÿ9 5696<4ÿ695Q5$ÿ= 64ÿ'76$ÿ96ÿ00>0%$ÿ 345637ÿ536894ÿ 9947ÿ963796ÿ76ÿ6 4ÿ77ÿ74ÿ ÿ67ÿ34474ÿ9ÿ67ÿ3464ÿ ÿ997ÿ ÿ  ÿ!6ÿ" #ÿ 45437ÿ345637ÿ$ÿ%3ÿ&'39#ÿ ÿ (779ÿ563796ÿ6ÿ%3ÿ&'39)ÿ345637ÿ34ÿ34536 4ÿ84379ÿ63ÿ43$ÿ84379ÿ 36ÿÿ345637ÿ4ÿ534534ÿ9ÿ*+,-+.ÿ/0ÿ123ÿ45ÿ6789:ÿ;ÿ6<=7+ÿ>/.0?ÿ!6ÿ@ A@BCDE?ÿFGFDÿHIÿ C0BG"Fÿ 4ÿ ÿ(54ÿJ 73ÿKÿ@C?ÿFGDFD#?ÿÿ4ÿ77ÿ9'4L94ÿ98684ÿÿ94Mÿ894ÿ ÿ4N4ÿ7997 ?ÿ6Nÿ6743ÿ9 4ÿ&76Nÿ563796ÿ6ÿ74ÿ5344 7ÿ345637ÿ34ÿ44 39$ÿ 4A5499?ÿ9 9Nÿ97ÿ9 96ÿ6ÿO47979643)ÿ49ÿ9763$?ÿ6743ÿ563796ÿ5543ÿ N443$ÿN4ÿP4=Q7>ÿ997ÿFF?ÿ94ÿJ$ÿF ?ÿFGF@ÿ  ÿ!6ÿC"A@#ÿ7ÿ@A"ÿRÿ A@Cÿ 563796ÿ6ÿ%3ÿ&'39)ÿ45437ÿ345637ÿ4399Nÿ9ÿ99796ÿÿ4599NÿN443ÿ 9 66N9ÿ6457#?ÿ-+ÿ*+,-+.?ÿFGFDÿHIÿC0BG"F?ÿS-9:ÿ997ÿ ÿ7ÿ@A"?ÿ A@G?ÿ@"A@0?ÿRÿFFA F"ÿ 9 9Nÿ74ÿ4#ÿ ÿ & 9796$?ÿÿT6397$ÿ6ÿ74ÿ974 ÿ6ÿ49ÿ9743734ÿ974ÿ9ÿ74ÿ53447ÿ345637ÿLÿ 6ÿ974ÿ9ÿ*+,-+.ÿP4=Q7>ÿ997ÿFF?ÿ94ÿJ$ÿF ?ÿFGF@ÿ  ÿ!6ÿC"A@#ÿ7ÿ@DA@ ÿ 979Nÿ 344344#?ÿ-+ÿ*+,-+.?ÿFGFDÿHIÿC0BG"F?ÿS-9:ÿ997ÿ ÿ7ÿF0AF ÿ 979NÿC ÿ344344ÿL434ÿ" ÿ 6ÿ74ÿL434ÿ6ÿ974ÿ9ÿ%3ÿ&'39)ÿ45437ÿ345637ÿ9ÿ*+,-+.#ÿU ?ÿ ÿ6ÿ77ÿ9743734ÿÿ 34$ÿ44ÿ947994ÿÿ34894L4ÿ9ÿ64796ÿL97ÿ9ÿ43943ÿ345637ÿÿÿ ÿ 5437ÿ$ÿL4ÿ346$ÿ34$ÿ6ÿ7493ÿ6Lÿ53963ÿE94ÿO36N3ÿL63'?ÿ63ÿ456$ÿ 534896 $A484654ÿ45796ÿ6ÿ94799ÿ6457ÿV 7ÿ74ÿ63ÿ34474ÿ 7ÿ79ÿ3447ÿ 74ÿL63'ÿ64ÿ9ÿ74ÿ17.ÿ79ÿ:7+WÿH434ÿ 779ÿ563796ÿ6ÿÿ345637ÿ84ÿ34$ÿ44ÿ374?ÿ ÿ ÿ6ÿ74ÿ 556379Nÿ9743734ÿÿ34$ÿ44ÿ947994ÿÿ34894L4?ÿ74ÿ99Nÿ3463 ÿ 6ÿ54397ÿÿ47439796ÿ77ÿ74ÿ794ÿ3N4ÿ63ÿ 9796ÿ3443?ÿ34894L?ÿ379N?ÿÿ 4979NÿLÿ346$ÿ44 3$ÿX434?ÿ74$ÿ6ÿ67ÿ474$ÿ459ÿL$ÿ ÿ654796ÿ9ÿ L3374ÿ63ÿ63ÿ547ÿ536 9Nÿ7439ÿ 779$ÿ 597984ÿ6ÿ%3ÿ&'39)ÿ53963ÿL63'ÿ 63ÿ34894L9Nÿ9743734ÿ4ÿÿ534896 $ÿ34894L4ÿ9ÿ534539Nÿ77ÿL63'ÿÿ ÿ

U9ÿ643ÿ9ÿ69747ÿL97ÿ53963ÿ4996ÿ34 9Nÿ%3ÿ&'39)ÿ654796ÿ63ÿ 9474$ÿ 77974ÿ99NÿYÿ4N?ÿ*+,-+.?ÿFGF0ÿHIÿFF@ "G?ÿ7ÿZDA ÿ 34 9Nÿ%3ÿ &'39)ÿ34474ÿ794ÿ$ÿFG[ÿ4ÿ6ÿ44 984ÿ99N?ÿ9 9Nÿ 779ÿ794ÿ48674ÿ76ÿ 9743734ÿ34894Lÿÿ345637ÿ53453796#\ÿP4]7+?ÿFGF0ÿHIÿF0G00C0?ÿ7ÿZDÿ 99NÿÿFG[ÿ 796ÿ553653974ÿ76ÿ67ÿ63ÿ44 984ÿ99Nÿ3474ÿ76ÿ34894Lÿ6ÿ49ÿ9743734ÿÿ 63ÿ74ÿ99Nÿ6ÿ99737984ÿ7'#\ÿ^=Q454_^WW4?ÿFGF0ÿHIÿCGD"FFF?ÿ7ÿZCÿ 55$9NÿÿFG[ÿ Dÿ ÿ %3ÿ&'39ÿ6ÿ6NN4ÿ5536974$ÿDÿ63ÿ63ÿ379Nÿ9ÿ45437ÿ345637ÿ̀7439ÿJ67ÿ7ÿCCAC0ÿ ÿ ÿU4ÿ 4796ÿ7974ÿaV394ÿJ49ÿX9763$?bÿL9ÿ 39M4ÿ74ÿ49ÿ3463 ÿ34894L4?ÿ65394ÿ 5536974$ÿFÿ5N4ÿ6ÿ74ÿF A5N4A6Nÿ345637ÿ997ÿ ÿ7ÿ"A0ÿ ÿ ÿ%3ÿ&'39ÿ6NN4ÿ5536974$ÿ@0ÿ63ÿ63ÿ439Nÿÿ34894L9Nÿ9743734ÿ̀7439ÿJ67ÿ7ÿCCAC0ÿ 3456789 ÿ 45ÿ ÿ59983894ÿ8ÿ48494ÿ98438634ÿ3494ÿ 5ÿ47494ÿ43ÿ63ÿ  ÿ 0ÿ !ÿ"# 0$%&ÿ8ÿ'%(&ÿ)345679*ÿ+3,ÿ- 39.ÿ34/64845ÿ894ÿ0ÿ% 1ÿ 45ÿ ÿ 59983894ÿ8ÿ47494ÿ98438634ÿ3494ÿ 5ÿ84ÿ 8634ÿ2ÿ84ÿ34689*ÿ34338,ÿÿ ÿ

4ÿ9*8ÿ2ÿ84ÿ68 89ÿ433ÿ98ÿ+3,ÿ- 39.ÿ3393ÿ 3ÿ84ÿ99*ÿ23ÿ3434845ÿ64ÿ 2ÿ334960ÿ349445ÿ98438634ÿ 5ÿ84ÿ7ÿ2ÿ99*ÿ5489ÿ62297948ÿ8ÿ568920ÿ84ÿ26ÿ 68ÿ 34/64845ÿ4ÿ295ÿ88ÿÿ3456789 ÿ2ÿ 1ÿ9ÿ34 4,ÿ648989 43ÿ9ÿ86ÿ 3545ÿ789:;<=>==ÿ23ÿ +3,ÿ- 39.ÿ43438ÿ244ÿ) 8ÿ97659*ÿ9ÿ348943ÿ244" ÿ3424789*ÿ? 0@% , ÿ34/64845ÿ23ÿ43438ÿ 244ÿ4ÿ? %% , ÿ9*ÿ8"ÿ"9ÿ3456745ÿ630ÿ384ÿ 5ÿ84ÿ4ÿ?%@@ , ÿ34689*ÿ23ÿ84ÿ # 43ÿ343748*4ÿ3456789 ,ÿÿ ÿ

A BÿDEF GHFÿ ÿ

648989 43ÿ44ÿ349 63448ÿ23ÿ84ÿ34338ÿ3343345ÿ0ÿ+3,ÿI3*9ÿ 5ÿ2945ÿ ÿJ60ÿ #ÿ %,ÿK ÿI998ÿ Lÿ)IMNÿO ,ÿ$&ÿ)+3,ÿI3*9.ÿ43438ÿ34338,ÿ+3,ÿI3*9ÿ3474945ÿÿ 747ÿ23ÿ 95 ÿ!ÿN93ÿ!!Mÿ5845" ÿP 37ÿ ÿ %ÿ23ÿ9ÿ348943ÿ244ÿ2ÿ?& , ÿ 5ÿ 945ÿ84ÿ293ÿ ÿ55989 ÿ? &# &, ÿ23ÿ 3ÿ3989*ÿ98ÿ23ÿÿ88ÿ34/64845ÿ78ÿ2ÿ ?$ # &, ,ÿ48439ÿP 8,ÿ8ÿ 0ÿQÿ%L(%#,ÿÿ ÿÿ -ÿ3389 ÿ2ÿ+3,ÿI3*9.ÿ34338ÿ443ÿ68 890ÿ837ÿ *6*4ÿ23ÿÿ3393ÿ R 7794ÿ63*3ÿ54799 ÿ97ÿ ÿ92345ÿ0ÿÿ34338ÿ2945ÿ0ÿ ÿ489340ÿSTT UVÿ43438,ÿ WXYZG ÿGSHGUÿ[BÿK \]^ÿXTÿ_ GVFÿ̀ÿ_aYGUÿK [EBÿO ,ÿ"%(""@LRÿ "ÿ !ÿ$ %00"%ÿ8ÿ'" ( "$ÿ)N45,ÿM,ÿb347,ÿP83,ÿJ64ÿ &ÿ "ÿ)3479ÿ 843ÿ59769*ÿcVF Uÿ33 *ÿ 4ÿdVFÿI998ÿ Lÿ8ÿ"#( "ÿ)+3,ÿI3*9ÿ33959*ÿÿ4597ÿ8430ÿ2ÿ7689 ,ÿP0ÿ7 743ÿ 68ÿ89ÿ 993980ÿ9ÿ49*8445ÿ0ÿ84ÿ278ÿ88ÿ67ÿ964ÿ434ÿ334960ÿ3945ÿ9ÿ 843ÿ 8843ÿ 99*ÿ+3,ÿI3*9,ÿb74569*ÿe3543ÿ9645ÿP 3,ÿ ÿ %ÿ)IMNÿO ,ÿ$$ÿ8ÿ"( ÿUÿG^Xÿ,ÿ K \]^ÿXTÿ_ GVFÿ`ÿ_aYGUÿK [EBÿO ,ÿ ("% "Rÿ 0ÿ !ÿ"##@@&$ÿ)N45,ÿM,ÿb347,ÿP83,ÿP 0ÿ @ÿ 0ÿ)3479ÿ 843ÿ 439*ÿ88ÿ+3,ÿI3*9.ÿ34338ÿ595ÿ 8ÿ7 45*4ÿ49843ÿ84ÿ GSHGUÿ369*f 3ÿ84ÿ43438ÿ4ÿ399 ÿ92345ÿ88ÿ 09f 5ÿ959789*ÿ88ÿ+3,ÿ I3*9.ÿ34338ÿ940ÿ 65ÿ 8ÿ4ÿ73459845ÿE ÿGEXÿG^Xÿ[BÿK \]^ÿXTÿ_ GVFÿ̀ÿ_aYGUÿK [EBÿ O ,ÿ ("% "Rÿ &ÿ !ÿL L@&%ÿ8ÿ'"ÿ)N45,ÿM,ÿb347,ÿP83,ÿN4,ÿ0ÿ &ÿ)3479ÿ 843ÿ 89*ÿ #ÿ ÿ )?& , ÿ)348943ÿ244ÿgÿ? 0@% , ÿ)43438ÿ244ÿhÿ?$"@% , ÿ88ÿ78ÿ79845ÿ98ÿ+3,ÿ- 39.ÿ 9448ÿ9ÿ89ÿ74,ÿK ÿ48439ÿP 8,ÿ8ÿ%,ÿ48ÿ3343ÿ88ÿ648989 43ÿ395ÿ84ÿ348943ÿ244ÿ 5ÿ 8ÿ84ÿ43438ÿ244ÿ 9ÿ89ÿ 8843,ÿ-ÿ84ÿ348943ÿ244ÿ9ÿ*4430ÿ34 4ÿ98ÿ9ÿ 8ÿ976545ÿ9ÿ88ÿ49*ÿ3456745ÿ434,ÿÿ ÿ" ÿi4ÿ3456789 ÿ9ÿ776845ÿÿ2jÿ)?&& ÿ(ÿ?& ÿhÿ?& ÿÿ%@,@ÿ63ÿ945ÿhÿ? %% , ÿ3456789 ,ÿ ÿ"" ÿi4ÿ3456789 ÿ9ÿ776845ÿÿ2jÿ)? 0@% , ÿ(ÿ? %% , ÿhÿ? %% ÿÿ 1ÿ3456789 ÿhÿ?%@@ , ÿ 3456789 ,ÿ ÿ" ÿ+3,ÿI3*9ÿ945ÿ%L,"ÿ63ÿ8ÿ ÿ630ÿ384ÿ2ÿ?&& ,ÿ 3453ÿ67838ÿ58876953 ÿ934ÿÿ84549ÿ45ÿ ÿ7933 ÿ7ÿ393978ÿ53378ÿ 8ÿ5ÿ67838ÿ 5965397ÿ ÿ

734ÿ3498ÿ533ÿ5ÿ ÿ ÿ!3953ÿ87" ÿÿ839!5397#ÿ5ÿ34!8ÿ34ÿ67ÿ 78ÿ73ÿ93ÿ5ÿ$563ÿ 395397ÿ59ÿ34ÿ$33ÿ37ÿ 4964ÿ ÿ845498ÿ73ÿ 9!6 ÿ34ÿ87!397ÿ7ÿ3498ÿ659ÿ%ÿ5 9397#ÿ34ÿ553ÿ7"5ÿ9ÿ$3ÿ739ÿ558ÿ 993 ÿ37ÿ34ÿ7397ÿ5 889ÿ&393978ÿ347ÿ7ÿ65!85397#ÿ534ÿ345ÿ34ÿ73ÿ58ÿ5ÿ47ÿ ÿ ' "3488#ÿ34ÿ587588ÿ7ÿ34ÿ67838ÿ58876953 ÿ934ÿ3498ÿ5396!5ÿ6773ÿ7ÿ 7(ÿ98ÿ53ÿ988!ÿ)**ÿ+ , ÿ-.ÿ)*/0 ÿ1ÿ2* 345ÿ6ÿ27, 8ÿ)*9-:.#ÿ'7ÿ;;<=>?@A#ÿB=;@ÿCDÿ;=EBB0@#ÿ 53ÿF;GÿHI ÿJÿK6ÿL83ÿIÿB@#ÿB=;@ÿH$889ÿ676ÿ4ÿ5ÿ$3ÿ83 ÿ5734ÿ $38ÿ7(ÿ7!63ÿ58ÿ498ÿ7 Mÿ+ , ÿ-.ÿ)*/0 ÿ1ÿ2* 345ÿ6ÿ27,.ÿ)*9-:.#ÿ;BEÿI ÿJÿ>E;#ÿ 0=?ÿHB=;>ÿH99ÿ7ÿ5!8ÿ7ÿ986397ÿ4ÿ$3ÿ67838ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ53ÿ34ÿ8695ÿ583ÿ 7!ÿ34ÿ$38ÿ73ÿ45ÿ ÿ5959N ÿ5ÿ9ÿ73ÿÿ7ÿ34ÿ$38ÿ7997ÿ&7ÿ 5339!397ÿ58ÿ34ÿ5639 ÿH5ÿ34ÿ5398ÿ37ÿ"5!53ÿ5ÿ$38ÿ658<86996ÿ55898ÿ $38ÿ47ÿ8!93ÿ738ÿ9ÿ34ÿA5669ÿ&75ÿ!83ÿ347ÿ35(ÿ65ÿ37ÿ9 39ÿ34ÿ87!68ÿ 7ÿ 4964ÿ34ÿÿOÿ$38ÿ847!ÿ73ÿÿ67853 ÿ4587 P9ÿ53ÿ5P9ÿ349ÿ Q7997Rÿ89ÿ6798ÿH"539ÿ7ÿ73498ÿ87 7ÿ88ÿ7(ÿ ÿ ÿ84549ÿ99653 ÿ3453ÿ4ÿQ$6! Rÿ47!8ÿ7ÿ498ÿ9"796ÿ3453ÿ!9653 ÿ498ÿ738ÿ 53 ÿ37ÿ"97!8ÿ738ÿ5ÿ3453ÿ53 ÿ68ÿ%ÿ34ÿ85 ÿ9"796#ÿ47 "#ÿ4ÿ7 ÿ BGÿ47!8ÿ53ÿ83ÿ"9 9ÿQ637(98ÿ5ÿ'Iÿ(Sÿ9ÿ8388ÿ878ÿ347ÿHL58!5ÿ3ÿ5ÿ B=;BRP5338ÿ986!88 ÿ9ÿ734ÿ TUV 8ÿ5ÿ ÿ%39ÿL73ÿ53ÿ@Wÿÿ84549ÿ587ÿ9 ÿ 7ÿGEÿ47!8ÿ83ÿ539ÿ34ÿ7397ÿ7ÿ498ÿ73ÿ3453ÿ673598ÿ34ÿ5!5ÿ53ÿ988!ÿ4ÿXTÿ O6679#ÿ%ÿ9857 ÿ9!8 3ÿ7ÿ3498ÿ5863ÿ7ÿ ÿ845498ÿ67838#ÿ !69ÿ34ÿ 9!85ÿ57!3ÿÿYG#@;===;Gÿ%ÿ!3!ÿ6588#ÿ659538ÿ65ÿ$63ÿ673ÿ9857 56ÿ 7ÿ ÿ845498ÿ 7(ÿ9ÿ4ÿ559ÿ77 8ÿ73978ÿ7ÿ498ÿ 933ÿ73ÿ7ÿ734ÿ6588ÿ7ÿ $38#ÿ5ÿ34ÿ598ÿ37ÿ5 Z!53ÿ6 93ÿ498ÿ87!68ÿ5ÿ37ÿ7"9 ÿ8!9693ÿ99ÿ 3598ÿ ÿ &39397ÿ98ÿ34!8ÿ5 5 ÿ[\\]^_`abbÿ7ÿ ÿ84;5@498ÿ$3ÿ 8ÿH73ÿ96!9ÿ498ÿ 359ÿ #ÿ639ÿYB?#E=?==ÿZ!83 ÿ7ÿ$3ÿ 8#ÿ88ÿYG#@;===ÿ7 9ÿ37ÿ498ÿ !6 ÿ 39 ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ;Gÿ ÿ

HHBGÿ47!8ÿ9 ÿÿÿ84549ÿcÿGEÿ5 93975ÿ47!8ÿ9 ÿÿÿ84549ÿ$ÿY??===ÿdÿYG#@;===ÿ !6397ÿ ÿ ;@ÿH

Y?#=====ÿH359ÿ ÿcÿYÿB?#E=?==ÿH$3ÿ 8ÿdÿYG=#E=?==ÿ3735ÿ67838ÿ58876953 ÿ 934ÿ ÿ845498ÿ 9"7" 3ÿ9ÿ3498ÿ658ÿ)**ÿ%39ÿL73ÿ53ÿ@ÿ%3ÿ558ÿ3453ÿ&39397ÿ59ÿ34ÿ359ÿ ÿ5ÿ73ÿ34ÿ$3ÿ 8ÿ 9ÿ3498ÿ533ÿO8ÿ34ÿ359ÿ ÿ98ÿ5ÿ5875#ÿ93ÿ98ÿ73ÿ96! ÿ9ÿ3735ÿ9ÿ !6 ÿ4ÿÿ 3455678ÿÿ 6ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿ!ÿ ÿ"ÿ"!!# $ÿ" ÿ%" ÿ"##ÿ ÿ& ÿ  ÿ"ÿ " "%#ÿ" ÿ"&"#'ÿ ( $ÿ)  ÿ ÿ"*"ÿ  ÿ ÿÿ "#ÿ"(  ÿ ÿ +,-./,01,2$ÿ  3ÿ ÿ456$7809:;ÿ ÿ  ÿ ÿ* #ÿ< 9ÿ= (" ÿ*" ÿ#"ÿ"  '$ÿ!# ÿ 477$6>>9>8ÿ ÿ)  ? ÿ  $ÿ!# ÿ4;@97:ÿ ÿA9ÿB  3C? ÿ  9ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ

DEFDGHIJEFÿ ÿ

LÿM" ÿÿ!(  ÿ" ÿ"*"ÿ ÿ" "%#ÿ"  '? ÿ ÿ" ÿ  ÿ ÿ  #ÿ #" ("  9ÿN ÿ7;OP9ÿ  3#'$ÿQÿ%'ÿRBSL$ÿ ÿ!"$7ÿ;)  ? ÿT ÿ<  9ÿ )  ÿ" ÿÿ  #ÿ"ÿ"*"ÿÿ "#ÿ"(  ÿ ÿ+U-.0-/1U2 ÿ" ÿ ## * Vÿ ÿ

WX1ÿYZ[\\]Xÿ^]_`ab.ÿcXd1Vÿ

B& ÿ  '? ÿT Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 4>6$:8:9@@ÿ B ÿ ÿ  '? ÿT Vÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ eÿ4ÿ7$7579;@ÿ *"ÿ  '? ÿT Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 4>7$06f9;@ÿ ÿ

B& ÿ  '? ÿg  Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 4;6$0:09:;ÿ B ÿ ÿ  '? ÿg  Vÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ eÿ47@$f>@9@@ÿ *"ÿ  '? ÿg  Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 456$7809:;ÿ ÿ

L "#ÿ*"ÿ  '? ÿT ÿ" ÿg  Vÿ ÿ ÿ +i-.UUj1/,ÿ ÿ

Ykl]l]mbknVÿ ÿ ÿ B& ÿ)  ? ÿg  Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 477$6>>9>8ÿ L "#ÿ*"ÿ)  ? ÿg  Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +oo.0--1-jÿ ÿ pn1ÿqa`mbÿqm_n]rskt.ÿcXd1Vÿ ÿ

B& ÿ  '? ÿT Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 40$7;097@ÿ B ÿ ÿ  '? ÿT Vÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ eÿ46@>96@ÿ *"ÿ  '? ÿT Vÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 4f$:;59:@ÿ ÿ

7;ÿ ÿ

L ÿ"(  ÿ ÿ  ÿ ÿ uÿ"##ÿ#3"#ÿ!  ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ("9ÿL ÿ"*"ÿ  (!"  ÿ"##ÿ"3 ÿ%'ÿ ÿ"  'ÿ"3" ÿ"ÿ#  $ÿv"u" ÿ  wÿ" ÿ*##ÿ" ÿ ÿ ÿ#3"#ÿ u  ÿ 9ÿT( $ÿxÿ7;OPO>Pÿ !u  ÿ" ÿ"  'ÿ (ÿ"3 3ÿ ÿ ## 3ÿ ÿO # 3ÿ  Pÿ"ÿ* #ÿ%ÿ ÿ"  ÿ ÿÿ"(  ÿ"*"ÿ  9ÿ3yyÿyy76zz8ÿ{y|}ÿ~ÿ3y|€8ÿÿy6z‚ÿƒÿ456ÿ3y7~„ÿ†‡ÿˆ†‰ÿŠ‹†ÿŒˆy‰ÿ7Š Šÿ ÿÿ 345647849ÿ88 47ÿ 787ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 0ÿ 949ÿ88 47ÿ 787ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 0ÿ ÿ  8ÿ949ÿ88 47ÿ447ÿ9ÿ 787ÿ ÿ ÿ !"#ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ %&'('()*&+ÿ(,ÿ-.-+/&/ÿ-'')+*&01,ÿ2&&,ÿ-*/ÿ3),',ÿ(*ÿ'4&ÿ')'-5ÿ-6)7*'ÿ)2ÿ #8 98:"#ÿ;+&<+&,&*'(*=ÿ >8 ##?":!ÿ2)+ÿ@,"ÿ%4055(,ÿA(/6-*1,ÿ2&&,ÿ-*/ÿ3),', ÿ BB 988"8?ÿ2)+ÿ%&'('()*&+1,ÿ<&+,)*-550ÿ (*37++&/ÿ3),', ÿ-*/ÿ !"#ÿ2)+ÿC+"ÿD-6)*ÿD)/+(=7&E1,ÿ2&&,ÿ-*/ÿ3),',Fÿ')ÿG&ÿ<-(/ÿ'4+)7=4ÿ -*ÿHIJÿ/&<),('ÿ')ÿ%&'('()*&+1,ÿ3)7*,&51,ÿKLMNHÿ-33)7*'ÿ2)+ÿ<+)6<'ÿ/(,G7+,&6&*'"ÿÿ ÿ

Oÿ8P4ÿQ74R4ÿSÿÿT 8U ÿS ÿ4VU4ÿSU49ÿW6768ÿ8ÿ3ÿWW49UXÿYZÿ8P4ÿ4[ÿSÿ8P4ÿ  68ÿ\JHMMÿ]^N]Dÿ_`Ca@]^NÿUÿRR 9R4ÿU8Pÿ8P4ÿ84T7ÿSÿ8PU7ÿb4RU7U ÿÿ c ÿ

KNÿK\ÿ\LÿLDC]D]C"ÿÿ ÿ d7dÿYUÿeÿ R ÿÿ YUÿeÿ R ÿÿ PU4SÿfW4RUÿg784ÿ ÿ ÿ

cÿ ÿ h6768ÿ8ÿiRRU4ÿ364ÿjkZÿ8P4ÿW8U47ÿTÿ4XW49U84ÿ48ÿSÿl69mT48ÿUSÿjlU8ÿ ÿ74W84kÿ8P4ÿSU4ÿ 8UR47ÿ4 6RUmÿ8P4UÿUmP8ÿ8ÿ744[ÿ4VU4ÿ

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.