Kombea Corp. v. Noguar L.C.
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- Vehicle Intelligence & Safety LLC v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC (District Court, N.D. Illinois 2015)
- Kroy IP Holdings, LLC v. Safeway, Inc. (District Court, E.D. Texas 2015)
- Epic Technology, LLC v. Fitnow, Inc. (District Court, D. Utah 2015)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
This matter is before the Court on Plaintiff KomBea Corporation’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment declaring the invalidity of United States Patents Nos. 8,503,619; 7,933,387; 8,438,494; and 7,640,510 under 35 U.S.C. § 101. The Court heard oral argument on Plaintiffs Motion on December 9, 2014. For the reasons discussed more fully below, the Court will grant Plaintiffs Motion.
I. BACKGROUND
Defendant Noguar L.C. (“Noguar”) holds United States Patents Nos. 8,503,619 (the “'619 patent”); 7,933,387 (the “'387 patent”); 8,438,494 (the “'494 patent”); and 7,640,510 (the “'510 patent”) (collectively the “patents-in-suit”). The patents-in-suit generally pertain to a telemarketing system that allows an agent to use prerecorded scripts, live voice, and interjections during a telemarketing call to tailor the call to potential customers while giving the impression that the conversation is person-to-person. The '619 patent relates to a
II. SUMMARY JUDGMENT STANDARD
Summary judgment is appropriate “if the movant shows that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.”
A patent is presumed valid, and each claim of a patent is presumed valid independently of the validity of other claims.
III. DISCUSSION
Section 101 of the Patent Act defines patent eligible subject matter. It provides, “Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.”
To make the distinction between those patents that claim the building blocks of human ingenuity and those that claim something more, the Court uses the two-step analysis found in Mayo Collaborative Services v. Prometheus Laboratories, Inc. “First, we determine whether the claims at issue are directed to one of those patent-ineligible concepts. If so, we then ask, ‘what else is there in the claims before us?’ ”
Plaintiff ai'gues that Defendant’s “claimed invention is nothing more than an abstract idea applied through a generic computer” and is not patentable subject matter.
The Court will apply the two-step Mayo analysis set forth above to determine the patent eligibility of the patents-in-suit. Doing so, the Court finds that the patents-in-suit are similar to those discussed in Bilski v. Kappos
In Bilski, the Supreme Court considered whether patents that related to hedging risk in a trading market were directed to patent-ineligible concepts.
The concept of risk hedging we identified as an abstract idea ... cannot be described as a preexisting, fundamental truth. The patents in Bilski simply involved a series of steps instructing how to hedge risk. Although hedging is a longstanding commercial practice, it is a method of organizing human activity, not a truth about the natural world that has always existed.22
Like the patents in Bilski and Alice, the patents-in-suit relate to a fundamental economic practice and a method of organizing human activity. Specifically, the concepts contemplated by the patents-in-suit are directed toward basic sales techniques executed with the aid of a computer to create efficiencies. Defendant describes the '619 patent as a method that allows a telemarketing agent to “choose between prerecorded scripts that elicit a response from the contact and prerecorded conversation content.”
The '387 patent is similar to the '619 patent in that it describes a method that allows a telemarketing agent to choose between prerecorded scripted responses and recorded interjections.
The '494 patent relates to an apparatus, system, and method of creating an agent-controlled computerized telemarketing sales presentation comprised of prerecorded audio and the agent’s live interjections.
The '510 patent claims a method for presenting prerecorded scripts to potential customers that reference personal information about the potential customer received earlier in the call.
Defendant argues, “The real genius of Noguar’s inventions is the recognition that by combining a small number of interjections with prerecorded sales scripts, the call actually sounds live.”
While it is true that the patents do not claim traditionally patent-ineligible subject matter, they do claim the fundamental economic practices involved in an effective sales call. The claims are also a method for organizing and limiting the choices and activity of a telemarketing sales agent so that the agent presents the prerecorded script more efficiently while mimicking real conversation. The Supreme Court’s discussion of Bilski in Alice is instructive. The Court said that “the concept of risk hedging we identified as an abstract idea ... cannot be described as a preexisting, fundamental truth” but as “a longstanding commercial practice, ... a method of organizing human activity.”
The Federal Circuit and several district courts have begun applying Bilski and Alice ’s analysis to determine subject matter patentability and, as previously noted, the Court finds support of its analysis in these cases — several of which are particularly instructive.
In buy SAFE, Inc. v. Google, Inc.,
In Ultramercial, Inc. v. Hulu, LLC,
Most recently, however, in DDR Holdings, LLC v. Hotels.com, L.P.,
The patents-in-suit are distinguishable from the patents in DDR Holdings. First, the patents-in-suit are not directed toward solving a new problem, unique to a technological field. Rather the patents-in-suit are directed toward performing fundamental commercial practices more efficiently. Second, the patents-in-suit are not a new solution to a unique problem; they only employ a combination of sales techniques and basic telemarketing technology to create an efficient system. Lastly, the patents-in-suit do not describe a new way of manipulating technology beyond its conventional or routine use. For these reasons, the patents-in-suit are more akin to those described in Bilski and Alice, than the patents at issue in DDR Holdings.
In addition to the Federal Circuit cases outlined above, several district courts have made patentability inquiries applying Bilski and Alice. In Tuxis Technologies,
In Open Text S.A. v. Alfresco Software Ltd.,
For the reasons stated above, the Court finds that the patents-in-suit are similar to those in Bilski and Alice and are directed toward an abstract idea.
To determine whether the patents’ claims transform the abstract ideas into patent-eligible inventions, the Court considers whether the patent claims “contain an inventive concept sufficient to transform the claimed abstract idea into a patent-eligible application.”
In Mayo, the Court examined whether the claims of a patent that was directed toward an abstract idea were sufficiently inventive. The Court found that process claims that amounted to “nothing significantly more than an instruction to doctors to apply the [abstract idea]” were insufficient ta be considered an inventive concept.
Plaintiff argues that Defendant’s patents are invalid because the patents simply apply abstract ideas through a computer.
Defendant argues that it is “not ... accurate to say that Noguar implements
If the role of the computer is as minor as Defendant claims, Defendant’s patents are simply abstract ideas relating to a fundamental economic practice or organization of human behavior and nothing ' more. If, as in Alice, abstract concepts implemented by computers are not sufficiently inventive, then executing abstract concepts with the aid of computers is not sufficiently inventive. Although using prerecorded scripts, prerecorded and live interjections, and personal information to mimic real conversation may be a more effective sales technique, it is ultimately a method organizing the behavior of a telemarketing sales agent. Like the instruction to doctors in Mayo to apply the scientific principle, the patents-in-suit are a set of instructions to implement fundamental sales techniques with the aid of a computer. Other than the recitation of the above discussed abstract ideas and how to execute those ideas with the help of a computer, the claims of the patents-in-suit describe nothing more. On this basis, the Court can conclude that the patents-in-suit are not eligible for protection.
Before concluding, the Court will address an argument made by Defendant at oral argument. Defendant argued that the patents-in-suit are “the solution of a problem that’s been tackled for years and ... never been effectively solved.” Further, Defendant argued that the patents-in-suit have an inventive concept because they do not “merely [implement] with a computer something that has been done by hand before because it never has been able to have been done manually with the kind of accuracy and all of the other parameters that are required by these systems. You know, it was just heretofore impossible.” It is immaterial to the Court’s analysis whether anyone has combined the sales techniques within the claimed patents as accurately and efficiently as Defendant. In Bancorp Services, LLC v. Sun Life Assurance Co. of Canada,
For the reasons discussed above, the Court finds that Plaintiff has met its burden of demonstrating clear and convincing evidence that the presumed valid patents-in-suit are, in fact, invalid under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
III. CONCLUSION
It is therefore
. Fed.R.Civ.P. 56(a).
. Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323, 106 S.Ct. 2548, 91 L.Ed.2d 265 (1986) (citation and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Novartis Corp. v. Ben Venue Lab., Inc., 271 F.3d 1043, 1046 (Fed.Cir. 2001).
. 35 U.S.C. § 282.
. Id.
. See Beckson Marine, Inc. v. NFM, Inc., 292 F.3d 718, 725 (Fed.Cir. 2002).
. Ryko Mfg. Co. v. Nu-Star, Inc., 950 F.2d 714, 716 (Fed.Cir. 1991).
. 35 U.S.C. § 101.
. Mayo Collaborative Servs. v. Prometheus Labs., Inc., - U.S. -, 132 S.Ct. 1289, 1293, 182 L.Ed.2d 321 (2012) (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank Int’l, - U.S. -, 134 S.Ct. 2347, 2354, 189 L.Ed.2d 296 (2014) (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Id.
. Id.
. Id. at 2355 (quoting Mayo, 132 S.Ct. at 1296-97).
. Id. (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Docket No. 34, at 1.
. Docket No. 33, at 11.
. 561 U.S. 593, 130 S.Ct. 3218, 177 L.Ed.2d 792 (2010).
. Id. at 599, 130 S.Ct. 3218.
. Id. at 611-12, 130 S.Ct. 3218 (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Alice, 134 S.Ct. at 2355.
. Id. at 2356 (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Id. (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Docket No. 33, at 13; U.S. Patent No. 8,503,619 (filed Apr. 25, 2011).
. U.S. Patent No. 7,933,387 (filed Aug. 1, 2001).
. U.S. Patent No. 8,438,494 (filed Dec. 28, 2009).
. U.S. Patent No. 7,640,510 (filed Mar. 28, 2005).
. Docket No. 33, at 17.
. Id.
. Id.
. Alice, 134 S.Ct. at 2356 (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. 765 F.3d 1350 (Fed.Cir. 2014).
. Id.
. 772 F.3d 709 (Fed.Cir. 2014).
. Id.
. 773 F.3d 1245 (Fed.Cir. 2014).
. Id. at 1248-49 (internal quotation marks omitted).
. Id. at 1257 (stating "the claimed solution is necessarily rooted in computer technology in order to overcome a problem specifically arising in the realm of computer networks”).
. Id. at *1258-59.
. Id.
. No. 13-1771-RGA, 2014 WL 4382446 (D.Del. Sept. 3, 2014).
. Id. at *1-*2.
. Id. at *3.
. No. 13-CV-04843-JD, 2014 WL 4684429 (N.D.Cal. Sept. 19, 2014).
. Id. at *4.
. Id.
. In addition to the discussed cases, the Court's conclusion also finds support in decisions by other federal district courts. Cal. Inst. of Tech. v. Hughes Commc’ns Inc., 59 F.Supp.3d 974, 991-92, No. 2:13-cv-07245-MRP-JEM, 2014 WL 5661290, at *13 (C.D.Cal. Nov. 3, 2014) (finding claims directed toward encoding and decoding data for error correction to be abstract); Enfish v. Microsoft Corp., 56 F.Supp.3d 1167, 1175-77, No. 2:12-CV-07360-MRP-MRW, 2014 WL 5661456, at *6-*7 (C.D.Cal. Nov. 3, 2014) (finding claims directed toward storing, organizing, and retrieving memory in a logical table to be an abstract idea); Amdocs (Israel) Ltd. v. Openet Telecom, Inc., 56 F.Supp.3d 813, 820, No. 1:10-CV-910 (LMB/TRJ), 2014 WL 5430956, at *6 (E.D.Va. Oct. 24, 2014) (finding that "correlating two network accounting records to enhance the first record” is an abstract idea); Cogent Med., Inc. v. Elsevier Inc., 70 F.Supp.3d 1058, 1063-65, Nos. C-1304479 RMW, C-13-4483, C-13-4486, 2014 WL 4966326, at *4 (N.D.Cal. Sept. 30, 2014) (finding that claims directed towards maintaining and searching a library of information to be abstract); Card Verification Solutions, LLC v. Citigroup Inc., No. 13 C 6339, 2014 WL 4922524, at *4 (N.D.Ill. Sept. 29, 2014) (finding "passing along confidential information through a trusted, third-party intermediary to ensure both that a consumer can complete the transaction and that the necessary confidential information remains secure” to be an abstract idea); Every Penny Counts, Inc. v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., No. 8:11-cv-2826-T-23TBM, 2014 WL 4540319, at *4 (M.D.Fla. Sept. 11, 2014) (finding "a method of and a system of automated saving or automated charitable giving” to be directed toward an abstract idea); Eclipse IP LLC v. McKinley Equip. Corp., No. SACV 14-742-GW(AJWx), 2014 WL 4407592, at *7 (C.D.Cal. Sept. 4, 2014) (finding claims directed to the "idea of asking someone whether they want to perform a task, and if they do, waiting for them to complete it, and if they do not, asking someone else” to be abstract); Loyalty Conversion Sys. Corp. v. Am. Airlines, Inc., 66 F.Supp.3d 829, 840, No. 2:13-CV-65, 2014 WL 4364848, at *8 (E.D.Tex. Sept. 3, 2014) (finding "the conversion of loyalty award points of one vendor into loyalty award points
. Mayo, 132 S.Ct. at 1298.
. Alice, 134 S.Ct. at 2357 (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).
. Id.
. Mayo, 132 S.Ct. at 1298.
. Alice, 134 S.Ct. at 2358.
. Docket No. 34, at 6.
. Id. at 6-7.
. Id. at 8 (citing Tuxis, 2014 WL 4382446, at *5).
. Docket No. 33, at 16.
. 687 F.3d 1266 (Fed.Cir. 2012).
. Id. at 1278.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.