People of the Territory v. Solomon
People of the Territory v. Solomon
Opinion of the Court
It appears from the record in this case that one Eanny Davenport was charged with keeping^ house of ill-fame,
1. It was objected to the complaint that it failed to allege that said Davenport was released from custody. In reply to this objection it is contended that although the complaint does not in terms state that the accused was discharged from custody, yet that the allegation that she was “admitted to bail” is equivalent thereto. The release from custody is in contemplation of law to take place after the execution and acceptance of the undertaking. It is declared in the undertaking itself, in speaking of the charge, that “said defendant having been held to answer thereon, and admitted to bail by said commissioner,” etc., the sureties undertook that she should appear, etc. This language indicates that the accused had already been admitted to bail before the undertaking was given; but it is not contended that the accused had been released from custody before the execution of the undertaking; and, in
2. The statement that the accused did not appear is not equivalent to saying that the accused was released on bail, nor did it necessarily include such a release. Had she been at large .from any other cause than the giving and accepting of the bail, the sureties would not be responsible. The undertaking could be of no validity unless the prisoner was discharged by reason of its being given. It is that which gives to the undertaking its vitality. The complaint should state every such fact necessary to its •validity, and without such allegation the complaint is fatally defective. It did not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. Los Angeles Co. v. Babcock, 45 Cal., 253. This point being decisive of the case, it is unnecessary to consider other points. The judgment and order of the lower court are reversed and the cause remanded, with directions to the lower court to sustain the demurrer to the complaint, with leave to the plaintiff to amend.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- THE PEOPLE OF THE TERRITORY OF UTAH v. ALFRED SOLOMON and Another
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published