Kalaher v. Brown
Kalaher v. Brown
Opinion of the Court
The defendant, Mrs. Verla Mae Brown, appeals from a judgment in favor of William Kalaher for $948.24 damages from a collision between their cars. She claims that plaintiff’s negligence as a matter of law was a proximate contributing cause of the accident. The trial court, hearing the case without a jury, found that defendant’s negligence was the sole proximate cause of the accident. We affirm.
The accident occurred at 6800 South Orchard Drive in Bountiful, between 4:30 and 5 :45 p. m. on November 9, 195S, where a street labeled Davis County 200 W., which is referred to in the record as 6800 South, enters Orchard Drive from the north. Orchard Drive runs in a northeasterly direction from Highway 91 on the south along the southeast side of Bountiful, changing its course at various places so that it slopes slightly to the southwest, with higher ground to the northwest and lower ground and the mountains to the southeast. Usually, and particularly at the place of this accident, Orchard Drive goes much farther distance north and south than it does east or west. Directly across Orchard Drive from where the street enters from the north, Hart’s Market is located on the southeast side of Orchard Drive. It has a parking lot on the northeast end and room to park cars parallel with Orchard Drive between the sidewalk in front of the Market and the southeast side of such drive.
The map illustrates this situation: Defendant’s car is marked No. 1, plaintiff’s car marked No. 2, Nos. 3 and 4 are cars parked in front of Hart’s Market, which plaintiff’s car ran into after the collision. No. S is another car which was stopped at the stop sign when defendant started.
The accident occurred after dark and all cars had headlights on, and at that time of year there was no foliage on the trees. Plaintiff was driving toward the southwest on Orchard Drive, and the defendant was driving south into Orchard Drive from the street entering from the north, intending to turn left when she entered that drive and to travel in a northwest direction after entering Orchard Drive. Defendant stopped for the stop sign and waited for other cars to pass which were going toward the northwest on Orchard Drive, and then, without seeing plaintiff’s car approaching from the northwest, where he was about 50 feet away, she drove into Orchard Drive in. front of him. He testified that he tried to stop his car when he first saw her — about 50 feet away — and to turn it to the east, but that his brakes did not have time to-take effect. But his car did turn to the east striking the left front end of her car with right front of his car. Thereupon: his car veered to the east into the west side of two cars parked in front of Hart’s-Market.
There is not a word of evidence as. to how far from the northwest side of the Orchard Drive pavement defendant stopped her car for the stop sign before entering. The defendant has the burden of proving contributory negligence which proximately" caused the accident on the part of the-plaintiff. For all that appears in the evidence, defendant’s car may have stopped for the stop sign within two feet of the northwest edge of the Orchard Drive pavement, from which point she started and drove her car in front of his oncoming car. A finding to that effect would be rea
*349
Judgment is affirmed with costs to respondent.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- William KALAHER, and v. Verla Mae BROWN, and
- Status
- Published