Harrison v. Tiernans
Harrison v. Tiernans
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
It was decided by this Court, in the case of Shelton v. Pollock & Co. 1 Hen. & Munf. 423, that if the Sheriff returns a writ executed, and (he name of the appearance bail, but does not return the bail bond, or a copy thereof to the clerk’s office, together with the writ, judgment ought not to be entered against the bail, but against the Sheriff.
In the case at bar, the Sheriff' returned with the writ, a writing purporting to be a bail bond, but which specifies no sum of money to be paid by the obligor to the obligee; the part of the writing, in which the sum of money intended to be paid is usually inserted, being left entirely blank. And the question is, whether such a writing can be regarded as a good bail bond ?
“A bond is a deed, whereby-the obligor obliges himself to pay a certain sum of money to another, at a day appointed. If this be all, the bond is called a single one, simplex obligatio; but thei’e is generally a condition added, that if the obligor does some particular act, the obligation shall be void, or else to remain in full force.” 2 Black. Com. 340. The obligation to pay money, is then of the essence of a bond, and is, in fact, the only stipulation which the bond contains. But, in the case before us, the stipulation is to pay nothing. It is no bond; it is a nullity.
Nor can this defect be supplied by the recital in the condition. The condition forms no part of the obligation or bond. It is entirely for the benefit of the obligor; stating matter by which the obligation or bond may be discharged. He may, or he may not comply with it, at his election. If he be unwilling or unable to comply with the condition, the law intends that the bond shall charge him. But how can this be, when the bond itself is a nullity ?
This case, therefore, cannot be distinguished from that of Shelton v. Pollock & Co.
The Court is of opinion to reverse the judgment and remand the cause to the Superior Court, that it may be sent to the Rules, that it may be proceeded in according to law.
Judge Green absent.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Harrison v. Tiernans. Two Suits
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published