M'Rea v. Brown
M'Rea v. Brown
Opinion of the Court
The 5th section of the act, entitled £c An act concerning the proceedings in courts of chancery, and for other purposes,” relied on by the counsel for the appellee, does not, upon sound construction, authorize a judgment for interest on.costs. The words are, “ Upon all judgments, interest shall be awarded on. the principal sum, or damages recovered, and costs, until such judgment shall be satisfied.” Costs, generally, are not a part of the judgment; they are given by the law, and not the court, in most cases, and follow the judgment as incidental thereto. The phraseology of the sentence under consideration clearly distinguishes them from the judgment; if included in it, the words “ and costs” would have been entirely superfluous; and the expressions which follow immediately after the words “ and costs,” evidently mark the intention of the legislature, if possible, more strongly; they are, “ until such judgment shall be satisfied ;” that is, the judgment for the principal sum, or damages, mentioned in the first member of the section; which judgment certainly does not include costs; unless, indeed, costs can be said to be a part of the principal sum, or damages recovered.
The general principle is, that costs are, considered as an appendage to the judgment, rather
Such being the general principle, it would require clear legislative expressions to change it, in any particular case : and no act, or section of an act, shall be construed to have that effect, which, by any fair construction, or even by a natural transposition of the words, can be otherwise accounted for and satisfied. In the case before us, the legislature, in allowing damages upon costs to be given by the appellate court, in two several instances in the act in question,
I am, therefore, of opinion that, on this ground only the judgment must be reversed.
Judge Fleming concurred; and’the judgment was unanimously reversed.
See 2 Fonb. 424.
Rev. Code, vol. 2, p. 29.
1 Munf. 179.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.