Carter v. Ragland
Carter v. Ragland
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an appeal from a decree of the Circuit court of Hanover county.
The facts disclosed by the record, so far as it is material to refer to them, are substantially as follows :
The appellee, Ragland, purchased of one George F. Booker, on the 16th September 1862, a tract of land lying in the county of Hanover, known as “Laurel Grove,” containing 340J acres, at the price of $25 per acre. He paid the purchase money in cash, in Confederate States treasury notes, then but slightly depreciated, and received a deed for the land.
Shortly after this purchase, Ragland authorized ’W. Goddin, a real estate auctioneer, to resell the laud for him, so that he should sustain no loss. Goddin, early in October 1862, sold the farm to the appellant, Carter, at the same price which Ragland had paid, but upon a credit of one, two, three and four years. Carter accordingly executed his four notes payable to Ragland for the sum of $2,147.87, with interest from the 16th September 1862, and payable at one, two, three and four years. A deed conveying the laud to Carter was executed by Ragland ; and the laud was then conveyed by Carter to Goddin, in trust to secure the payment of these notes as they became due.
Carter immediately took possession of the land, and has been in possession ever since. He has paid towards the purchase money only $1,000, which was paid on the 17th of October 1863, and was credited on the first bond. Two of the purchase money bonds fell due after the close of the war—one on the 4th day of October 1865, and the other on the 4th day of October 1866. But the appellant, it seems, never paid, or offered to pay, anything more on said bonds, except the sum of $1,000, which was paid in Confederate States treasury notes on the 17th October 1863. Thus matters stood between the parties until the year 1867, when the appellee directed
From this decree Carter appealed to the District court at Fredericksburg; which affirmed the decree of the Circuit court of Hanover: to which decree of affirmance an appeal was allowed to this court.
It will be observed that in this case, two of the purchase money bonds became due after the close of the war, when the currency in which they were stipulated to be paid had perished; and as to these a strict compliance with the contract of the parties has become
The court is therefore of opinion, that the said Circuit court ought to have put the said appellant to his election, either to give up the laud, and have the contract of sale vacated and annulled, and to receive the value of the Confederate States treasury notes (which he paid towards the purchase money,) as of the 17th October 1863, and to account for the rents and profits of the laud for the time it has been in his possession ; or if he elects to retain the land then he should be required to pay its reasonable value at the time of the sale, such value to be ascertained by a commissioner of said Circuit court, subject to a credit of the proportion which the amount he has paid bears to the amount he agreed to pay; the balance to carry interest from the 16th day of September 1862.
The court is, therefore, of opinion that the said decrees
Decree reversed..
Reference
- Status
- Published