Pretlow v. Bailey's Ex'x
Pretlow v. Bailey's Ex'x
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is a case involving the right of a
The court is therefore of opinion that the circuit court erred in overruling, instead of sustaining, the exception taken by the defendant Pretlow to the report of Commissioner Gordon, dated 28th September and filed 2d October, 1872; and that so much of the decree appealed from as is in conflict with the foregoing opinion, outfit to be reversed and annulled with costs, and a decree rendered in conformity therewith.
The decree was as follows:
This day came again the parties by their counsel, and the court having maturely considered the transcript of the record of the decree aforesaid and the arguments of counsel, is of opinion, for reasons stated in writing and filed with the record, that it has jurisdiction of this appeal, and that the circuit court' erred in overruling, instead of sustaining, the exception taken by the appellant Pret-low to the report of Commissioner Gordon, dated 28th September and filed 2d October, 1872. Therefore it is decreed and ordered, that so much of the decree appealed from as is in conflict with the foregoing opinion and erroneous as aforesaid, be reversed and annulled, and that the appellee, Ann Eliza Bailey, out of her o.wn estate, and the ap-pellee, Ann Eliza Bailey, executrix ot Thomas R. Bailey, deceased, out of the estate of her said testator in her hands to be administered, do pay to the appellant his costs-by him expended in the prosecution of his appeal aforesaid here. And *this cour.t, proceeding to render such decree as the said circuit court ought to have rendered, in lieu of so much of the said decree as is erroneous and reversed and annulled as aforesaid, it is further decreed and ordered that the said exception taken by the said defendant Pretlow to the said report of Commissioner Gordon, be and the same is hereby sustained. And it is ordered that this cause be remanded to the said circuit court of Albemarle county for further proceedings to be had therein to a final decree; which is ordered to be forthwith certified to the said circuit court of Albemarle county.
Decree reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Pretlow v. Bailey's Ex'x & als.
- Status
- Published