Ellett v. Commonwealth
Ellett v. Commonwealth
Opinion of the Court
We find no error in the judgment of the hustings court, and it will, therefore, be affirmed.
Affirmed.
Reference
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Taxation—Life Estate in Choses in Action—Nonresident Trustee.—.Where a citizen of this State, resident in the State, has a life estate in'choses in action held in trust for him by a nonresident trustee, such choses are taxable in this State, although they are not and never have been within the State, and the trustee is not a resident of the State. 2. Taxation—Life Estate in Choses in Action—Nomresident Trus- . tee.—The tax, though assessed in the name of the trustee, is not against him but against the beneficiary. The trustee is the mere conduit through the medium of which the tax upon the property of a citizen passes into the treasury. 3. Taxation—Life Estate in Choses in Action—Nonresident Trustee.—In the instant case, it was objected that under the prolusions of section 492 of the Code of 1904, as amended by Acts 1918, p. 169, the assessment should have been listed in the name of the trustee and not that of the life tenant. Held: That it was wholly immaterial to the life tenant whether the tax was assessed to and paid by the trustees or the life tenant, and one liable to assessment for taxes cannot evade payment, by reason of errors or irregularities which do not prejudice his rights. 4. Taxation—Life Estate in Choses in Action—Nonresident Trustee—Situs for Taxation.-—-Section 492 of the Code of 1904, as amended by Acts 1918, p. 169, -Code of 1919, section 2307, undertakes to fix the situs for taxation of intangible property held by. a trustee for the benefit of a person over twenty-one years of age. The situs sought to be fixed is a situs in this State. If the trustee is not a resident of the State, then as to the fund held by the trustee there is no trustee for the purpose of the statute, and the property is, under the terms of the statute, to be listed by and taxed to the beneficiary in the county or corporation wherein he resides.