State v. Smith
State v. Smith
Opinion of the Court
The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, in criminal casés, is to be ascertained by a construction of the Judiciary Act taken; together. The first section creates the County Courts, and defines their jurisdiction ; the first thing to be noticed, is the different language (as it respects the Supreme Court) used in criminal and in civil cases. In criminal eases the County Courts “shall have cognizance of all criminal
Section 6th constitutes the Supreme Court, and in defining its jurisdiction, evidently expresses what is intended to be its exclusive original jurisdiction only. Jurisdiction of the subject matter of a criminal nature, in all cases cognizable by the County Court, had been given expressly, by way of appeal, in section second.
Tbe Constitution, section 4th, had made the Judges of the Supreme Court general conservators of the peace, throughout the State, so that the powers of the Court are not extended to tmy new subject matter, by taking original cognizance. The Judiciary Act recognizes, in the first section, other jurisdiction
This construction of the Judiciary Act is supported by various Statutes, which recognize a concurrent and general jurisdiction of criminal cases in the Supreme Court.
The first section of the Act for the punishment of inferior crimes, recognizes the same jurisdiction, in case of theft, in Supreme as in County Court.
. The Act relating to fines, &c, 2 vol. p. G5, sec. 2, provides that in cases originally commenced in the Supreme Court, the fine or penalty shall be paid into the Treasury of the State — if the Supreme Court had no jurisdiction, except in cases expressly given by Statute-, the Court could not take cognizance of a breach of a penal law, except where the fine or penalty is expressly payable to the State Treasury; this section then, was useless, but this section provides that the penalty shall be paid into the State’s Treasury by reason of the prosecution being originally commenced in the Supreme Court, it contemplates a class of cases that may be prosecuted in either Court, County or Supreme, and a concurrent jurisdiction in those Courts.
Judgment — Plea insufficient..
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.