Fuller v. Briggs
Fuller v. Briggs
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The defendant was collector of the customs for the district of Vermont, and the plaintiff a deputy, who served in that capacity under the defendant; and this suit is brought to recover for those services. The suit is founded upon an express undertaking of the defendant to be personally responsible to the plaintiff for his services. And so far as the testimony had any legal tendency to establish that fact, or was proper for the consideration of the jury in passing upon the question, in connection with the previous request of the defendant to the plaintiff to perform the service, and the subsequent repeated promises of the defendant to pay for the same, we do not see why it was not properly received and submitted to the jury. To such use, only, was this testimony restricted by the county court in their instructions to the jury. The testimony had a tendency to account for the promises subsequently made by the defendant to the attorney of the plaintiff, as indicating how the parties originally understood the contract.
The defendant insisted, that the plaintiff could not recover without proof of an express promise on the part of the defendant, and that it was necessary, that the plaintiff should deliver to the defendant a proper voucher, enabling him to charge the amount in his account with the government, before he was entitled to recover. The case shows, that the plaintiff had furnished his attorney such a voucher, of which the defendant was informed by the attorney, and
The defendant moved in arrest of judgment for the insufficiency of the declaration, which motion was overruled by the court below. This question does not seem to have been much relied upon at the argument, and we are unable to discover any such insufficiency in the declaration, as to the warrant an arrest of the judgment.
The motion in arrest was properly overruled, and the judgment of the county court is affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Frederic Fuller v. William P. Briggs
- Status
- Published