Town of Stowe v. Luce
Town of Stowe v. Luce
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered, at the circuit session in September, by
This is an action of debt, brought by the town of Stowe, on a penal bond executed in March, 1848, to secure to the town of Mansfield the payment of the surplus money belonging to that town, and in the hands of the trustees, who are the principals in the bond. The declai’ation was demurred to, and the question is, can this action be sustained? In November, 1848, the town of Mansfield was annexed to, and became a part of the town of Stowe, and the third section of the act annexing it to Stowe, provided “ that the United States surplus money belonging to the town of Mansfield should become the funds of the town of Stowe, and that the trustees of the town of Stowe might maintain an action on any notes executed to the trustees of the town of Mansfield, or, if payable to the town of Mansfield, in the name of Stowe.”
This bond was executed to the inhabitants of the town of Mansfield, and the statute, in its language, only extends to notes given to the trustees of Mansfield, or payable to the town of Mansfield.
■It becomes an important inquiry, whether there is any sound principles in relation to the construction of statutes which will warrant this court to enlarge the language of the statute, so as to include in the expression, notes, penal bonds, like the one in question.
The condition of this bond is “ to secure a true and faithful execution of the office of trustees appointed to manage the sur
We think,'then, without considering any other objection taken by counsel to the declaration, and without at all considering the question, whether it was competent for the legislature to pass a law giving to the town of Stowe a right to maintain an action on this
The judgment of the county court is reversed, and judgment for the defendants to recover their costs, for the insufficiency of the declaration.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- The Town of Stowe v. Ivory Luce, Joshua Luce, Guy Nutting, A. Peterson, James Harris and James G. Harris
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- The provision in the act of the legislature entitled a an act to annex Mansfield to Stowe,” approved November 11,1848, (Laws of 1848, p. 11,) that the United States surplus money belonging to the town of Mansfield shall become the funds of the town of Stowe, and that the trustees of the town of Stowe may maintain an action on any notes executed to the trustees of Mansfield, or payable to the town of Mansfield, in the name of Stowe, does not authorize or enable the town of Stowe to maintain an action upon the official bond executed to the town of Mansfield by the former trustees of that town.