Sherman v. Abell
Sherman v. Abell
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The orator prays for an injunction against the defendant Abell as administrator with the will annexed of Tilly Gilbert, and defendant Fish as administrator of Hannah B. Howe, restraining them from the enforcement and collection of the bond which was allowed against the estate of Hannah B. Howe, out of said estate. Some of the grounds upon which the orator predicates his right, were considered and decided in the case of Abell, admr. of Tilly Gilbert v. Howe et als. 43 Vt. 403. It was then claimed, as it is now, that the bequest in the will of Tilly Gilbert to James Jarvis Gilbert, was a trust fund in the hands of the executors and administrators of Tilly Gilbert, and that they held said funds as trustees ; that they constituted no part of the estate of Tilly Gilbert, and consequently that they should prosecute or defend in matters connected with said funds in their character of trustees, and not as executors or administrators. The court held that it was the right and duty of the administrator, to gather up the fragments that remain of said estate, and bring them into the probate court, and place them in order and due course of administration, according to the will, ,so that the right and duty of the administrator, as such, to control and administer this fund, was there conclusively settled.
The objection that the suit was prematurely brought, for the reason that it did not appear that Howe had been ordered by the probate court to pay over the funds in his hands to his successor, was virtually overruled, by the court’s retaining jurisdiction of the suit, and allowing it to proceed to a final decree. So that the orator’s right to equitable relief, must stand upon the facts stated in the bill and answers, and appearing from the proofs. Upon the settlement of John Howe with the probate court, it was ascertained that he had in his hands, belonging to the estate of Tilly Gilbert, the sum of $2,996.30. It stands admitted that John Howe was at that time wholly insolvent, and a non-resident of the
The bank stock, that the orator seeks to exempt from liability to pay the above claim, he derived title to from the heirs of Hannah B. Howe. Our statute makes the personal estate first chargeable with the payment of debts and expenses of administration. Gen. Sts. ch. 52, § 5. The right of the heirs to the personal estate, was subordinate to the rights of creditors, and they had nothing in such estate to convey, except what might remain after the payment of the debts against the estate and the expenses of administration. The orator has shown no equity that entitles him to an injunction restraining the administrator from administering upon so much of the personal estate of Hannah B. Howe as may be necessary for the payment of the claims allowed against her estate, and the expenses of administration.
The orator further claims, that if said claim is to be paid out of the estate of Hannah B. Howe, that the defendants, who have acquired title to a portion of the real estate belonging to said estate, from the heirs-at-law, should contribute' to such payment. The payment of debts^and expenses of administration, rested primarily upon the personal estate, and until that was exhausted, no resort
The pro forma decree for the orator against Abell and Fish, is reversed, and cause remanded, with mandate, that the bill as to them, be dismissed with costs. The order of said court overruling the demurrer of the defendants Barrows, Benedict, and Griswold, is reversed, and mandate that the demurrer is allowed, and bill as to them to be dismissed with costs. The defendants James A. and Caroline H. Paige, not having filed any answer to the bill, the orator was entitled to have the bill taken as confessed against them. As no such record seems to have been made before the cause passed to this court, the bill will be taken as confessed against them, and decree to be entered for orator against them accordingly.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Carlos S. Sherman v. Rodney C. Abell, Nathaniel Fish, administrator of Hannah B. Howe's Estate, Franklin A. Barrows, Johnson S. Benedict, S. H. Griswold, James A. Paige, and Caroline H. Paige
- Status
- Published