State v. Barrows
State v. Barrows
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The respondent was complained of before a justice of the peace for an assault and battery, and there convicted and sentenced to pay a fine of $20. The respondent appealed to the County Court, and there filed a motion to dismiss the prosecution, on the claimed ground that the justice had imposed a larger fine than he was authorized by statute ta impose for such an offense. She claims that the justice’s jurisdiction in this respect is that conferred by sec. 1666, R. L., or the power to impose afine not exceeding $10. The justice of the peace held that the offense charged was that defined by sec. 4228, R. L., or that of breaking and disturbing the public peace by the assault; and that by sec. 4235, R. L., he was empowered to impose a fine of $20. If the contention of the respondent is correct, inasmuch as the justice had jurisdiction of the offense, or of the process, subject-matter, and respondent, it is not quite apparent how it follows that the prosecution should be quashed or dismissed because he imposed a larger fine than he was authorized by statute to impose. The respondent had brought her case into the County Court by appeal, where that error, if it were one, could be corrected and only the lawful fine imposed. The fact that the justice in a case in which confessedly he had jurisdiction committed an error in regard to the amount of the fine he was authorized to impose, would not oust the appellate court of jurisdiction to do in the case what the justice was authorized to do, and should have done.
But passing this point, we think it would be a surprise to the profession and contrary to the almost universal practice, to hold that a justice of the peace by virtue of sections 4228 and 4235, is not authorized under the complaint to im
The judgment is, that the respondent takes nothing by her exceptions, and the cause is remanded to the County Court to be further proceeded with.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- STATE v. NELLIE BARROWS
- Status
- Published